Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

A turning problem

Posts

A turning problem

#1

A turning problem

Starry Chan

I was turning a small Liquid Amber bowl this afternoon and I noticed that I cannot get my tool not bouncing on the surface. This is true regardless the tool I used (bowl gouge, scraper, carbide tool). I then put my tool rest against the bowl and I manually turn the bowl to check its roundness. I discovered that the gap between the circumference and the tool rest can be as much as 1/32". The surface is definitely not perfectly round.

I turned a small walnut bowl the day before and I did not recall encountering this tool bouncing problem.

I then checked the run-out of the spindle and the run-out is less than 0.002 at 1200 RPM. For woodturning lathe, I think this is an acceptable run-out.

What causes this problem? How I can always get a smooth cut?

I am going to turn another small red bark eucalyptus bowl tomorrow to see whether I will encounter the same problem.

Starry

Re: A turning problem

#2

Need more info, such as what lathe.....

JamieDonaldson

......and does it have a rotating headstock that is either loose or not aligned with the tailstock?

Re: A turning problem

#3

Re: A turning problem

Dick Coers

First fix is sharpen the tool, then ease up on your grip, third is to make sure you are not rubbing the bevel too hard. Too much pressure on the bevel will build a washboard result and just keeps amplifying it.

Re: A turning problem

#4

Re: A turning problem, additional info

Starry Chan

The tenon is perfectly round.

The gap is always at the side grain section. This means that more wood is cut at the side grain section than the end grain section. I do understand how and why this happens.

Starry

Re: A turning problem

#5

Re: Need more info, such as what lathe.....

Starry Chan

The lathe is Jet 1642. The headstock is not loose. The blank is held using a chuck screw firmly against the jaws. Tailstock is not used.

Starry

Re: A turning problem

#6

Re: A turning problem

Starry Chan

I cannot see the unevenness and any visible wave on the surface. I only feel the tool is bouncing when I make the cut.

All the tools are sharp. When I used the scraper, I simply just ran its across the surface without pressing hard against the surface. I ran the carbide cutter he same way. Carbide cutter is a scraper anyway. The result is the same.

Starry

Re: A turning problem

#7

Re: A turning problem

Terry Scott

1 dont push the cut this means slow down your travel speed across the work

If you travel faster than the rotation I.e you dont cut the full 360 degrees before moving on you can get a spiral or chatter similar to a thread

also many timbers have allot of tension within .When you remove the wood its like cutting an elastic band

Another fault is if the wood is off balance the centrifugal force will cause you to hit and miss

My method is to turn up the speed sharp chisel slow cut

Cheers

Re: A turning problem

#8

Rob Wallace

Re: A turning problem

Rob Wallace

You did not say whether the blank you are turning is "green" (wet) or if it is a dry blank. Wet wood being turned and quickly drying ('tis the season) can distort rather quickly in some species. Barring torn grain, knots, bark inclusions, etc. that might cause the tool to "bounce", the explanation of asymmetrical stress relief is a plausible one, particularly if the bounce gets worse as the bowl is hollowed. Since you say the gaps occur in the face grain and not the end grain, this would be consistent with shrinkage effects due to drying. You may want to "near-turn" this to completion and allow it to equilibrate for a week or two (more?) before final turning and finishing. I agree with the suggestions of taking controlled, long & slow, smooth cuts with minimal pressure on the bevel.

BTW - a few comments about the wood name: If what you mean by "Liquid Amber" is what I assume it to be, the common name for this tree (and the wood) is sweetgum, and the scientific name for the genus is Liquidambar (spelling correct; one word). If you write the name of the wood on the piece when you finish it, you may wish to use the "standard" common name [sweetgum], or if writing the scientific (genus) name you may want to spell it correctly. There is no tree/wood common name of "Liquid Amber".

Rob

Re: A turning problem

#9

Re: A turning problem

Bob Edwards

Speed has not been addressed as yet. With some of the other suggested problems if you add turning to slowly will also produce the effect. Example: If you rub the bevel too hard and turn to slowly the tool is allowed to be more aggressave with the grain than against the end grain.

Re: A turning problem

#10

bob has it

John Lucas

It's usually a combination of forcing the tool to cut, pushing too hard on the bevel and the lathe speed too slow. First thing to try is to lighten up on the cut. I'm assuming you have a freshly sharpened edge. Start the cut and try to not push on the bevel. Most of us have started using the term glide the bevel or aim the bevel, rather than ride the bevel. Ride the bevel implies that you need pressure on it, and you don't.

Speed can be the culprit in that you are cutting side and end grain. The end grain will cut slower and be harder to cut. Start the cut on an already true area. Push the gouge only as fast as it wants to cut with gentle pressure. Aim the bevel in the direction you want the tool to cut. If you feel like the cut is going to slowly then turn the speed of the lathe up, rather than forcing the tool to cut faster by pushing

Re: A turning problem

#11

Re: A turning problem

Starry Chan

This blank is not green and but it is probably not 100% dry. It is 6x6x4 and it was harvested last July.

I am only working on the outside profile. This will be an once-turned piece so I am paying a lot more attention to the surface. For roughing out piece, I do not care too much about the surface quality.

As for the name of the wood, I did not know Liquidamber is just one word. This tree has leaf similar to maple and the leaves turn red or yellow in the fall. It also produces 1" round fruit. It really hurt when you step bare foot on these fruits.

Starry

Re: A turning problem

#12

Rob Wallace

You have sweetgum....

Rob Wallace

The leaf shape and form of the fruit are diagnostic....

It's LiquidambAr with a second "A"..... (No "e" in this word...)

See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liquidambar

Try some of the suggested adjustments to your cutting technique with the gouge.... this should easily be solvable.

Good Luck,

Rob

Re: A turning problem

#13

Brad Vietje

Yup.

Brad Vietje

...and using a little gentle tail stock support could help if you are at all worried about the higher RPM's, if the blank will allow it (I'm CERTAIN the insurance agent will allow it)