Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

old turnings

Posts

old turnings

#1

old turnings

Sergio

Hello everybody, I do not want exaggerate in posting photos now that I started but I would like to have your opinion on these goblets which I stop making months ago. I've done them with thin and normal stem, in one or more woods, natural or colored. For reference the butternut platter is just under 14 inches and the longer thin stemmed is 16 inches.The background in the thin stem goblets is terrible but soon I will get a new camera and prepare a little set up for photos, I hope. Thanks for your opinions.


Re: old turnings

#2

Re: old turnings

Don Orr

I like them all. Nice variety of shapes and woods. Proportions seem good. I like the coloring in the 1st group, except for the stems. They look kind of muddy. May not be necessary with a nicley colored bowl. I'd have to say well done overall.

Re: old turnings

#3

Re: old turnings

Don in Central Illinois

Like the shorter stems better. Long stems seem to be a statement about what a turner can do. I fo like all of them, judt a personal preference for the shorter ones.

Re: old turnings

#4

Re: old turnings

Sergio

Thank you. I agree and this is the main reaon why I stop turning gobets in general. One can get carried way. I must say that, since I turn with conventional gouges mainly and a skew only when really needed, making them is a very good practice. It allow the utilization of scrap wood and refine the difficult, at least for me, art of the proportions. The golden number is a good starting point but there are other rules, which sometimes elude me.

Thanks.