Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Designed vs Seen - and what you can do about it *LINK*

Posts

Designed vs Seen - and what you can do about it *LINK*

#1

Designed vs Seen - and what you can do about it *LINK*

charlie belden

Started with the question:

Why DESIGN in SIDE VIEW from 12" to 18" away on a flat piece of paper - when the actual piece is usually not SEEN in SIDE VIEW nor from 12" to 18" away?

Here's the apparent paradox of DESIGN and SEEN


I had a feeling that there was a way to figure out how to take the ORIGINAL DESIGN and stretch it vertically to have the TYPICALLY SEEN appear very similar to the ORIGINAL DESIGN - and still be able to see most of the details of the piece from 2 or 3 feet away - from a normal viewing height.

Turns out there seems to be a way to do just that, and I've done all the math and created a downloadable Excel spreadsheet that will let you input your Viewing Parameters Values - and get the Vertical Adjustment Factor needed to scale up your Original Design - only vertically.

Have put up a web page on Why and How that includes a link to the spreadsheet so you can download and play with it. I may add a page on how to use SketchUp to create 1:1 scale virtual 3D models of a piece, beginning with a 2D SIDE VIEW PROFILE, "spin it" to create the 3D object and then stretch that object vertically and then view the Adjusted Design object from any vantage point.

Comments, questions and suggestions on how to make this info clearer and more understandable are welcomed.


Web page with link to spreadsheet

Re: Designed vs Seen - and what you can do about it *LINK*

#2

It Appears

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Charlie, that you're spending a great deal of time trying to deal with the visual translation between 2-D and 3-D, and the distortions that occur when you take a moving image and translate it to a single static view on a flat surface.

Viewing an object "live and in person" is a continually moving/changing exercise even if the object is fixed and immovable. Absent the ability to present the image holographically such that it can be walked around and viewed from the full 360x360 [that's a sphere, son ;) ] available to live viewers whose eyes may be anywhere from 40" to 94" off the floor, I'm unclear about the goal of your effort. The design of a free-standing object must account for the sphere of viewing points as well as the space in which it's placed. We see objects based upon reflected light and the constantly changing figure/ground relationships between an object and the space around it.

Are you trying to adjust the design of 3-D object so that it must be viewed from a single point on that sphere of possible views? Why? You might be able to come up with a set of distortions that "work" from your chosen point of view, but the piece would then fail as a design from most all of the others. You'd be left with a piece that only looks "good" in a single flat photograph rather than as a hard 3-D item. I don't think you intend to merely design a photograph, but that seems to be what you're doing here.

I can "see" where all your calculations and formulas might have real use if you're making CGI objects for a motion picture or video. Not sure what use they are to someone simply making the real object on a lathe.

Am I missing something?

Re: Designed vs Seen - and what you can do about it *LINK*

#3

horizontal vs vertical perception

Jorge

Charlie, to me the hurdle is that the horizontal and vertical perception are not the same. What looks really good horizontally may not please once it is vertical.

I did not quite grasp what you were trying to convey.

Re: Designed vs Seen - and what you can do about it *LINK*

#4

Re: horizontal vs vertical perception

Bill Howatt

I certainly agree with the horizontal vs vertical perception issue. I often unscrew my chuck and put the piece vertical to see what it is going to look like when displayed.

Maybe my eyeballs are challenged but I do find it can make a difference.

Bill

Re: Designed vs Seen - and what you can do about it *LINK*

#5

Re: It Appears

charlie belden

Mark:

I believe that turned pieces are experienced basically in two phases

- from a distance, where the form, size and profile of the form are the Attractor

- from close up, where the form and profile are less important, and are difficult to see anyway because they're not being seen in Side View Profile - the details of the piece become the Attractor

From a distance details may not be apparent.

From up close, the profile isn't what's being seen.

Pick ONE.

What I'm looking into is the possibility of an intermediate phase - far enough to see basically the Designed In Side View Profile - AND - close enough to also see details of the piece. Normally the viewer can see A OR B, but not both

While it's true that there is probably a perfect viewing vantage point for a specific piece placed at a specific location in 3D space, I'm not after that. What I am investigating is a good compromise between Phase 1 and Phase 2, a generic intermediate.

Seems the range of this intermediate phase would likely be between 2 and 4 feet.

The piece is likely to be displayed at either about waist level or mid chest level - but NOT likely to be displayed at Eye Height.

Basically what I'm after is something that approximates what we show in the photographs we take of pieces - but from a more real world vantage point and piece location.

We quite often do things "because that's the way it's been done". Maybe Jesuits are to blame for my asking WHY? - and thinking about what's missing and maybe ways to fill in gaps.

Re: Designed vs Seen - and what you can do about it *LINK*

#6

Ya-but

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

You're still trying to apply 2-dimensional design principals to a 3-dimensional object. You can't put an "x" on the floor and expect people to stand there (and ONLY there when they look at what you've made. I think your statement with regard to being able to see the profile is flawed. Unless you are dealing with a very large object such that a viewer will loose the form to their peripheral vision, the entire shape of a turning should be equally perceived. While detail in the surface may draw attention on close inspection, that doesn't negate the perception of the piece as a whole.

True, we all see more detail the closer we get closer to an object, but fractal principals will only get you as far as unassisted vision will go. A piece may be displayed at table height yet will often be viewed at "eye height" because the viewer bends, crouches or kneels to look at it which happens in galleries all the time.

If you want the profile to be viewed like a photo, angle the piece to place the center mass line at 90° to the view angle. Problem remains the it'll look silly when the viewer walks around to one side or the other. Were you to create a shape that accounts for the viewing angle in one direction, I suspect it would look pretty funky from most any other.

You can solve the "problem" by simply making a photo of the object and standing it at an angle.

Re: Designed vs Seen - and what you can do about it *LINK*

#7

Re: Ya-but

charlie belden

Mark wrote:

You're still trying to apply 2-dimensional design principals to a 3-dimensional object.

My point exactly.

Beginners and even intermediate turners begin DESIGNING in 2D - and create objects in 3D. We doodle and sketch and draw - on paper - a 2D surface - then turn in 3D. And most of us see and collect mainly 2D images of pieces, not the actual pieces. So it's not surprising that we think of DESIGNING as being done in 2D. Hey, ya' gotta start somewhere right?

More advanced turners develop the ability to think and design in 3D - and as they're turning - be able to see where they're going with the piece and recognize when they get there - and stop turning.

You can't put an "x" on the floor and expect people to stand there (and ONLY there when they look at what you've made. I think your statement with regard to being able to see the profile is flawed. Unless you are dealing with a very large object such that a viewer will loose the form to their peripheral vision, the entire shape of a turning should be equally perceived. While detail in the surface may draw attention on close inspection, that doesn't negate the perception of the piece as a whole.

The idea is not to specifiy a single point from which the piece MUST be viewed, but a point between where the viewer first notices the piece and the viewer is standing almost at the piece examining it - a third Way Point on the experience trip - where both essentially the designed profile and the details of the piece are seen. A critical transit point that may not be conscsiously be noticed by the viewer - but seen by the visual system and stuffed into the unconscious mind, perhaps to be THE memory of the piece.

True, we all see more detail the closer we get closer to an object, but fractal principals will only get you as far as unassisted vision will go. A piece may be displayed at table height yet will often be viewed at "eye height" because the viewer bends, crouches or kneels to look at it which happens in galleries all the time.


But why require that the viewer bend, croutch or kneel to see THAT view when a little design adjustment may provide that view from normal eye height. It's the artist that does the suffering during the creation. The viewer shouldn't need to also suffer to get the resulting piece.

If you want the profile to be viewed like a photo, angle the piece to place the center mass line at 90° to the view angle. Problem remains the it'll look silly when the viewer walks around to one side or the other. Were you to create a shape that accounts for the viewing angle in one direction, I suspect it would look pretty funky from most any other.

The idea I'm playing with doesn't require tilting the piece, which, as you described wouldn't look the same from the side. What's seen with this adjustment should be the same regardless of which side of the piece the viewer appoaches the piece from.

You can solve the "problem" by simply making a photo of the object and standing it at an angle.

But that wouldn't let you figure out how to adjust the original design to get the simultaneous viewed profile AND the details of the piece.

Re: Designed vs Seen - and what you can do about it *LINK*

#8

Re: Points of View

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The idea is not to specify a single point from which the piece MUST be viewed, but a point between where the viewer first notices the piece and the viewer is standing almost at the piece examining it - a third Way Point on the experience trip - where both essentially the designed profile and the details of the piece are seen. A critical transit point that may not be consciously be noticed by the viewer - but seen by the visual system and stuffed into the unconscious mind, perhaps to be THE memory of the piece.

Charlie, I think you're trying to calculate something that contains more variables that your postulates can account for or control. Without that control your assumptions that form the baseline for your calculus will fail.

But why require that the viewer bend, crouch or kneel to see THAT view when a little design adjustment may provide that view from normal eye height. It's the artist that does the suffering during the creation. The viewer shouldn't need to also suffer to get the resulting piece.

"Suffer"? Really? I have never suffered when making anything. Perhaps a romantic concept for some, "the starving/suffering artist, sacrificing to bring beauty into the world", but in my view, complete and utter BS. As far as the viewer goes, why should they be spoon-fed? If the piece has merit on some plane, it will first attract the viewer to come closer and then be held and invited to "explore" further. Spoon feeding works for pablum and strained peas; it has no place, in my view, in making stuff, unless, of course, your chosen market is IKEA or Walmart. ;)

BTW, I'm not a sketcher. When it comes to turning, I look at the piece of wood and have an idea in my head. The wood goes on the lathe and I translate the idea as I turn. I do not have any use for drawing the piece before I turn it. I let the wood "speak" and adjust the design, as needed, as I go. When I did sculpture, I did stick figure drawings which would then be translated into wax stick figures to work in three dimensions. Little or no paperwork, and certainly no CAD use. I would never allow myself to become so controlled by something like a CAD-made design.

Re: Designed vs Seen - and what you can do about it *LINK*

#9

Re: Ya-but

charlie belden

Mark wrote:

You're still trying to apply 2-dimensional design principals to a 3-dimensional object.

But isn't that the way we seem to be told it's to be done - in 2D articles in magazines, in 2D books on turning, in 2D videos and DVDs on turning? Isn't that how presentations on design illustrate good designs and bad designs? Isn't that how demonstrators DRAW the profile of the piece they're going to do - on a white board with dry markers, or on a chalk board with chalk - or a Flip Chart they bring to the demo?

And how many times have you been told of the importance of Good Proportions and about The Golden Ratio, or The Rule of Thirds or The Rule of Fifths - and how to apply them - to a SIDE VIEW of the PROFILE you're after?

We are taught, intentionally or unintentionally, to think in 2D when designing. But what we turn are 3D objects. 2D has Line and Area. 3D has Line and Volume and Surfaces. 2D artwork can be hung at the height the artist wants the work to be seen and there are special lamps to illuminate the work from below or above. 3D artwork often doesn't have that luxury of controlling the viewing experience.

You can't put an "x" on the floor and expect people to stand there (and ONLY there when they look at what you've made.


I'm not after an ACHTUNG - YOU VILL SHTAUHND HE-AH - UND ONLY HE-AH!

As I keep pointing out, the viewer seems to currently have two viewing options - from a distance seeing basically the Designed Side View Profile, but not the details, and - from up close looking down, seeing the details but not the Designed Side View Profile. The viewer DOES NOT have BOTH options simultaneously. But I think THAT options can be made available.

I see the viewing experience as a continuum, starting from a distance and ending close to the piece. What I'm looking for is, at some range of distance in that continuum, for the viewer to see BOTH the PROFILE (actually something visually quite similar to the 2D DESIGNED PROFILE) AND the DETAILS of the piece. And the viewer doesn't even have to consciously be aware of the unique viewing experience of the piece this affords them. BUT - I think their visual system WILL store that info and USE it to try and make sense of the visual input it's receiving. And when you can get into people's subconscious mind . . .

I think your statement with regard to being able to see the profile is flawed. Unless you are dealing with a very large object such that a viewer will loose the form to their peripheral vision, the entire shape of a turning should be equally perceived. While detail in the surface may draw attention on close inspection, that doesn't negate the perception of the piece as a whole.


True, what I'm investigating, the stretching of the DESIGNED PROFILE vertically, in order to allow the viewer to see BOTH a closer approximation of the DESIGNED PROFILE while viewing the piece from normal eye height and still being able to see details of the piece - cannot satisfy - exactly - both viewing conditions. But some times Close Enough is Good Enough - and perhaps better than None At All.

True, we all see more detail the closer we get closer to an object, but fractal principals will only get you as far as unassisted vision will go. A piece may be displayed at table height yet will often be viewed at "eye height" because the viewer bends, crouches or kneels to look at it which happens in galleries all the time.


But why require the viewer to bend, fold, spindle or mutilate (sorry - wrong analogy) crouch or kneel to see what you want them to see? There seems to be at least one alternative that doesn't require that of the viewer. In general, If It's Easier to Do "A" Than to Do "B", folks will probably do "A". If you make it easy for the viewer to do what you want them to do . . .

If you want the profile to be viewed like a photo, angle the piece to place the center mass line at 90° to the view angle. Problem remains the it'll look silly when the viewer walks around to one side or the other. Were you to create a shape that accounts for the viewing angle in one direction, I suspect it would look pretty funky from most any other.


What I'm playing with would produce the same Profile AND Details viewing options, regardless of where, around the piece, the viewer is standing - because the "stretching" is done along the vertical axis of the piece - which, I assume" is square to the surface upon which the piece is being displayed.

You can solve the "problem" by simply making a photo of the object and standing it at an angle.

But then we'd be back to the shortcomings of 2D images. Why not try and provide the options of ACTUALLY seeing both "profile" AND details - in actual 3D?