Re: Ya-but
charlie belden
Mark wrote:
You're still trying to apply 2-dimensional design principals to a 3-dimensional object.
But isn't that the way we seem to be told it's to be done - in 2D articles in magazines, in 2D books on turning, in 2D videos and DVDs on turning? Isn't that how presentations on design illustrate good designs and bad designs? Isn't that how demonstrators DRAW the profile of the piece they're going to do - on a white board with dry markers, or on a chalk board with chalk - or a Flip Chart they bring to the demo?
And how many times have you been told of the importance of Good Proportions and about The Golden Ratio, or The Rule of Thirds or The Rule of Fifths - and how to apply them - to a SIDE VIEW of the PROFILE you're after?
We are taught, intentionally or unintentionally, to think in 2D when designing. But what we turn are 3D objects. 2D has Line and Area. 3D has Line and Volume and Surfaces. 2D artwork can be hung at the height the artist wants the work to be seen and there are special lamps to illuminate the work from below or above. 3D artwork often doesn't have that luxury of controlling the viewing experience.
You can't put an "x" on the floor and expect people to stand there (and ONLY there when they look at what you've made.
I'm not after an ACHTUNG - YOU VILL SHTAUHND HE-AH - UND ONLY HE-AH!
As I keep pointing out, the viewer seems to currently have two viewing options - from a distance seeing basically the Designed Side View Profile, but not the details, and - from up close looking down, seeing the details but not the Designed Side View Profile. The viewer DOES NOT have BOTH options simultaneously. But I think THAT options can be made available.
I see the viewing experience as a continuum, starting from a distance and ending close to the piece. What I'm looking for is, at some range of distance in that continuum, for the viewer to see BOTH the PROFILE (actually something visually quite similar to the 2D DESIGNED PROFILE) AND the DETAILS of the piece. And the viewer doesn't even have to consciously be aware of the unique viewing experience of the piece this affords them. BUT - I think their visual system WILL store that info and USE it to try and make sense of the visual input it's receiving. And when you can get into people's subconscious mind . . .
I think your statement with regard to being able to see the profile is flawed. Unless you are dealing with a very large object such that a viewer will loose the form to their peripheral vision, the entire shape of a turning should be equally perceived. While detail in the surface may draw attention on close inspection, that doesn't negate the perception of the piece as a whole.
True, what I'm investigating, the stretching of the DESIGNED PROFILE vertically, in order to allow the viewer to see BOTH a closer approximation of the DESIGNED PROFILE while viewing the piece from normal eye height and still being able to see details of the piece - cannot satisfy - exactly - both viewing conditions. But some times Close Enough is Good Enough - and perhaps better than None At All.
True, we all see more detail the closer we get closer to an object, but fractal principals will only get you as far as unassisted vision will go. A piece may be displayed at table height yet will often be viewed at "eye height" because the viewer bends, crouches or kneels to look at it which happens in galleries all the time.
But why require the viewer to bend, fold, spindle or mutilate (sorry - wrong analogy) crouch or kneel to see what you want them to see? There seems to be at least one alternative that doesn't require that of the viewer. In general, If It's Easier to Do "A" Than to Do "B", folks will probably do "A". If you make it easy for the viewer to do what you want them to do . . .
If you want the profile to be viewed like a photo, angle the piece to place the center mass line at 90° to the view angle. Problem remains the it'll look silly when the viewer walks around to one side or the other. Were you to create a shape that accounts for the viewing angle in one direction, I suspect it would look pretty funky from most any other.
What I'm playing with would produce the same Profile AND Details viewing options, regardless of where, around the piece, the viewer is standing - because the "stretching" is done along the vertical axis of the piece - which, I assume" is square to the surface upon which the piece is being displayed.
You can solve the "problem" by simply making a photo of the object and standing it at an angle.
But then we'd be back to the shortcomings of 2D images. Why not try and provide the options of ACTUALLY seeing both "profile" AND details - in actual 3D?