Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

HOW we see - what we PERCEIVE

Posts

HOW we see - what we PERCEIVE

#1

HOW we see - what we PERCEIVE

charlie belden

Perception is contextual. WHAt we perceive depends of how we see something.

Now when a turning is being displayed - and viewed - the viewer would see from a distance, basically the profile we designed. But at that distance few if any details of the piece would be seen. When the viewer gets close enough to really see the details of the piece, he/she would be too close to see the profile we designed. However, somewhere between the two viewing distances may be an Optimal Viewing Distance - where the viewer basically sees that nice profile we designed, as we designed it, AND some or most of the details we worked so hard to create, or bring out of the wood.

As turners,

we often DESIGN on a flat piece of paper viewed from 12-18" away, looking basically square on to the paper. (1) in the illustration below

but the finished piece is very seldom viewed from 12-18" AND square on (2) in the illustration below

we turn the piece laying on its side - about 18-24" from our eyes (3) in the illustration below

we photograph the piece standing upright and from a point 18-20" away, but slightly above square on - looking down a bit (4) in the illustration below

and then we display the piece about 30" above the floor and view it from about 30" away - a vantage point from which both the form and its proportions can be seen AS WELL as details of the piece - like grain patterns, textures, piercing. etc.. (5) in the illustration below

To see the piece the way it was designed on paper, the viewer would have to squat down and get close - a foot to a foot and a half from the piece.


Now if the form and proportions of the profile of the piece are so important, why isn't the designing of that form and the proportions of the piece done from the vantage point of the viewer of the finished piece as the piece will be displayed?

Clay models of an idea could be used to design pieces - with the Viewer's Vantage Point in mind. But that would require another Skill Set to learn and clay is easily deformed (OOOPS, I dropped it! or OOOPS I squeezed it!).

With 3D printers becoming available and sort of affordable, you could design the piece in a CAD prorgram and "print it". Again, that would require another Skill Set - and a 3D printer.

But you could, and CAN, design the piece in Virtual 3D and view it from the peprspective of a viewer of the actual piece, seen in a normal visual context - about 30" away and from Eye Height and about 30" off the floor. Again it would require learning another Skill Set, but the cost, in terms of dollars is zilch, nada, FREE - if you use Google's FREE SketchUp app.

OR

maybe - you can just CALCULATE how much you'd need to "stretch" your original DESIGN Profile and Proportions vertically so that, when viewed from a normal vantage point, it would look much as it would if you were viewing it "square on".

IF

you know the following

1. the approximate eye height of the viewer (He)

2. the approximate distance at which the viewer will see basically the PROFILE you designed AND much of the DETAILS of the piece (Do)

3. how far off the floor the piece will be placed (Hp)

4. the actual DESIGNED HEIGHT of the piece (Ho)


I think I've worked out the math and put it in an Excel spreadsheet so I can specifiy He, Hp, Do and Ho and have Excel calculate the corresponding VERTICAL HEIGHT ADJUSTMENT FACTOR to apply to the original Height of the Designed Object to get the ADJUSTED Design object. The horizontal proportions and dimensions of the Designed Object will remain the same, only the vertical height and corresponding vertical proportions will be adjusted.

I'll be taking the Excel calculated VERTICAL HEIGHT ADJUSTMENT FACTOR and applying it to a SketchUp virtual Designed Piece and compare the visual results.

IF this idea works, I'll put up a page or two about it on my site and post a link to it. Not sure if I can attach the spreadsheet to a message here on WC and have it be downloadable. If not, I can make it downloadable from my site and post that link here.

This is a very interesting puzzle - at least to me. I've got most of the pieces in place. Still have to finish the puzzle and see what it looks like all together.

Questions, comments and suggestions welcomed. IF this works my goal is to make it quick and easy for others to use.

Re: HOW we see - what we PERCEIVE

#2

Re: HOW we see - what we PERCEIVE

Darrin Hill

this is very weird...

and where liberal arts clash with engineering..

Whenever i photograph something, i always loook from where the camera WILL be...

I set up the items, set the lights then the camera...

then shoot off a polaroid or two and adjust the lights..

not sure why everyone doenst do it that way... much easier.... MUCH easier.

Re: HOW we see - what we PERCEIVE

#3

Re: HOW we see - what we PERCEIVE

Peter Hyde

Charlie, a couple of comments.

First you are ignoring scale. The usual size of turnings means that near or far there's not going to be much visual distortion. On big turned columns there has always been used a swelling in the mid section to create the illusion of straight tapers when viewed from normal eye height.

Secondly because of size there is distortion in horizontal as well as vertical proportions and the bigger the size gets the more perspective and vanishing points become important. Just stretching or shortening vertical dimensions will not produce a correct visual.

Just MHO

Re: HOW we see - what we PERCEIVE

#4

Re: HOW we see - what we PERCEIVE

Devon Palmer

Fantastic post. Thanks for taking the time to put this together.

Have you considered submitting this to the Woodturning Design Mag or the AAW?

Re: HOW we see - what we PERCEIVE

#5

Re: HOW we see - what we PERCEIVE

charlie belden

Peter:

SCALE is a topic for some future discussion. But you're right that compensating for perspective's visual distortions plays an important role - at architectural scale - not so much for turned 6-12" tall pieces. Yet, at turning scale, we seem to adopt Rules of Thumb for good proportions - from architecture.

The question I started with is why design in 2D - in SIDE VIEW, turn it on its side, photograph it almost but not quite in profile vertically, then display the piece so the viewer SEES it from well above how the piece was designed or photographed. Why not design the profile in 2D than adjust it so the viewer basically sees the ORIGINAL DESIGN PROFILE - from a normal vantage point.

I've figured out how to calculate a Vertical Adjustment Factor to accomplish that - vertically. And having figured out a way to do that which seems to almost work, I think the same approach I used will work for a Horizontal Adjustment Factor as well. I'm working on that and now that I know how to use trig and geometry to get there. I think it can be done. The results may look different from what we're accustomed to seeing - in photographs, but the piece should look right when viewed at some optimal distance between viewer and piece and from a more normal viewing height - where the profile is apparent AND some or most of the details of the piece can also be seen.

Now this idea may not work for anything but tall hollow forms. But I had to start somewhere.

A critical tool for working this idea out is the use of virtual 3D, being able to quickly and easily make adjustments both just vertically or just horizontally or both sequentially - and then SEE what the results are - before committing to

turning the piece.

May not work in the real world, but it's an interesting puzzle, and I like trying to solve puzzles like this - even if I can't solve it. I enjoy pursuing Wild Hare Ideas.

Devon:

If this idea works out I'll put up two or three web pages on my personal site, with illustrations and links to a YouTube video along with a spreadsheet that will do the math for you. Probably will include some SketchUp virtual 3D models and how to use SketchUp to go from 2D designed profile to Adjusted Profile. If and when I get all that done I'll post links to it here and in a few other turners forums.

As for submitting this kind of stuff to magazines, editors place a lot of restrictions on how many words, how many illustrations and specific sizes for the illustrations, and magazines are STATIC media - no video permitted though links can be provided to videos. I've been approached about doing magazine articles, but what's required to get published is just too much of a hassle - for me. If I do my own web pages, it may not be as slick as a magazine editor can produce, but I get to choose what gets presented, and how its presented, not an editor or publisher. The downside is maybe not as many turners will see what I put together to share with them - but life seems to be a series of compromises.

Re: HOW we see - what we PERCEIVE

#6

The Idea Seems to Work

charlie belden

OK - so I did a virutal 3D model of a 6" tall hollow form. Assumed a viewer's eye height at 62 3/4" (the average of the Average US male height and the Average US female height - less 4" from top of head to eyes). Assumed a pedestal or table top height of 30" (about normal table top height) and placed the viewer 30" horizontally from the axis of the piece.

Popped these values into the spreadsheet I've done for the calcs, got the Vertical Adjustment Factor then vertically scaled up the original hollow form model. I then tilted it to the viewing angle for the conditions described above.

BLUE is the original design in side view. Red is the Adjusted design seen from the above described vantage point.


This next image shows the Adjusted Piece in Side View and "Actual View" next to the Original Design piece in Side View and "Actual View".



It still appears to me that the horizontal proportions need a bit of adjusting, but much less than the vertical adjusting. Next up - exploring Horizontal Adjustment.