Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Motor types on a lathe

Posts

Motor types on a lathe

#1

Motor types on a lathe

Roger Chandler

Motor types on a lathe

The question was raised about the Revo lathe from Laguna got me wondering about motor configurations on a lathe. My Grizzly G0698 has a DC brushless motor........they changed that to an A/C motor on the next iteration G0733........I have wondered why a number of times.

I found this information on Brushless DC motors.........

http://www.howstuffworks.com/brushless-motor.htm

According to them there are many advantages to a brushless DC motor, including more torque and better control of the efficiency because of the computer components and less wear.......no brushes to replace, no sparking, less noise...........runs cooler. The only disadvantage listed is the higher initial cost.

I am wondering if this info on dc brushless motors comports with the understanding of others here who use lathes with an A/C motor and inverter? Any advantages of an A/C motor on a lathe?

Doing further reading on this website.......

http://www.slmti.com/brushless.asp

they state other advantages.......safer in explosion prone areas [think dusty areas] safer around liquids, no brush residue on the internal components, making them need less maintenance,[ better for bearings inside the motor, etc.] better control for speed, higher inertia [torque] and a smaller dc brushless motor can accomplish the same load requirements as a larger A/C motor.

I am just wondering then why the manufacturers of most lathes are using higher maintenance A/C motors on their lathes, if these advantages are so prominent? Is it just a matter of cost? Then perhaps being able to sell replacement parts later on?

Hummm........

Re: Motor types on a lathe

#2

Re: Motor types on a lathe

Bill Howatt

The brushless may be lower maintenance compared to a typical DC motor with brushes but I doubt it is any better than a standard 3-phase motor used with the usual variable-frequency drives. The 3-phase motors are just windings and rotor and have no centrifugal switch and capacitor like a single-phase AC motor.

The brushless motors have sensors embedded in them and a bunch of wires running back to a control board. How easy it is to find a universal replacement control-board would by my concern. I can buy any old 2 HP VFD and connect my 2HP 3-phase motor.

The brushless motor in larger sizes is relatively new and they may well become a much more common solution.

Re: Motor types on a lathe

#3

3 phase A/C motor vs. brushless D/C

Roger Chandler

Further exploring the motor types on a lathe..........is there an advantage for the 3 phase A/C motor with an inverter that runs it off single phase a/c power over the d/c brushless motor run by an inverter?

issues such as start up torque, and torque under load, etc. Efficiency in power output and efficiency in power consumption? Speed variations and available torque for our purpose?

Perhaps someone with an engineering degree or understanding can answer these issues.

Re: Motor types on a lathe

#4

Re: 3 phase A/C motor vs. brushless D/C

Roger Chandler

Do 3 Phase a/c motors have brushes? Seems I read about electric car technology somewhere that mentioned the stator being laminated so that conductors produce the alternating current..........I am not certain of that, but if anyone can explain the benefits/advantages of each type, then that would be great!!!

Re: Motor types on a lathe

#5

Re: 3 phase A/C motor vs. brushless D/C

Bill Howatt

3-phase motors don't have brushes and the only commonly found AC motor that does is the universal motor which is found on things like routers, corded electric-drills, portable circular saws, vacuum cleaners, table-top table saws. They apparently can run off DC as well.

The most common type of motor in the shop for stationary tools like table-saws, drill-presses, etc is the capacitor start induction motor. No brushes. The other common type often found in furnace fan type applications is the split-phase which has no brushed.

There is an old motor type not encountered in modern stuff that you are likely to see which is the repulsion-induction motor which has brushes but IIRC only for extra starting torque.

The torque of 3-phase motors driven by a VFD can get complicated because the VFD can be setup to provide various characteristics although it is safe to say that the motor is better off running at a higher than a real slow speed which is why they frequently have a couple of pulley ranges on tools like lathes.

Bill

Re: Motor types on a lathe

#6

Re: 3 phase A/C motor vs. brushless D/C

Roger Chandler

Thanks Bill for the info on the motors.........I like to know how things work, but sometimes the rationale for why a machine is configured is hard to come by.

Re: Motor types on a lathe

#7

Jesper, Denmark

Re: 3 phase A/C motor vs. brushless D/C

Jesper, Denmark

The rationale for using standard squirrel cage 3-phase AC motors is that they are cheap, made by the millions worldwide, easy to find replacements for and both reliable and efficient. Unfortunately, there are two standards for fixing motor dimensions and enclosure specifications: a US standard and an ISO standard used in the rest of the world - except that Japan have a local standard, but not used outside Japan.

As Bill mentioned, their characteristics can be changed to suit the application though programming a VFD.

Re: Motor types on a lathe

#8

Re: 3 phase A/C motor vs. brushless D/C

Alex Y

Interesting discussion, Bill and Roger.

Where does the Nova DVR fit into this generic classification of motor types?

Are the fractional HP motors found on variable speed mini-lathes typically brushless DC?

Re: Motor types on a lathe

#9

Re: 3 phase A/C motor vs. brushless D/C

Bill Howatt

I think the Nova DVR motor doesn't fit into the very general classes mentioned above. DVR means digital variable reluctance and is a microprocessor controlled design built to achieve high torque at a full range of speeds. It is most closely related to a brushless DC motor compared to the other types.

I believe the fractional HP motors used on mini-lathes are brush motors. I can't speak for all of them but the Jet uses brushes. Given that they are so common and relatively inexpensive I would think this is what you will find on most, if not all, of them.

I don't think I mentioned that one of the big advantages of universal motors often used in hand-held tools is that they can easily be controlled by voltage levels using circuits similar to a light-dimmer which makes variable-speed routers and drills inexpensive to implement.

Regular induction motors like the 3-phase, capacitor start, split-phase etc cannot be controlled by voltage level and their speed is determined by the frequency of the applied AC. This is why Variable-Frequency-Drives (VFDs) are used for speed control and this is only practical on 3-phase motors. A VFD for single-phase motors does exist but it was expensive, limited in power and only worked on certain motors.

Bill

Re: Motor types on a lathe

#10

Re: 3 phase A/C motor vs. brushless D/C

Roger Chandler

This has been a very informative discussion! Thanks to everyone so far who has chimed in to help us gain understanding.

If others have helpful info, please post.......the more info we have the better so far as it is correct info! :D

Re: Motor types on a lathe

#11

Re: 3 phase A/C motor vs. brushless D/C

John Lucas

It's been my experience that DC motors in general lose lots of power when you reduce the voltage going to them. Not sure mine were brushless but they were practically useless at the really slow speed ranges. The 3 phase motors with Variable Frequency Drive still have tones of power at the low speeds.