Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Safety and the AAW

Posts

Safety and the AAW

#1

Rob Wallace

Safety and the AAW

Rob Wallace

Picking up from a previous thread, GaryG wrote (blue text):

I am a member of AAW and a member of three AAW chapters. I agree with Rob that they cannot become involved beyond education. In my position as self-proclaimed Safety Officer of Montgomery County Woodturners, I have brought this incident to the attention of our members at the last meeting, and our President is working to put a line item into our contracts with future demonstrators indicating that face shields WILL BE WORN whether they want to or not. I have to say that far too many of our professionals have demonstrated without same, generally in the guise of not being able to be heard. IMO, that is a terrible example for the members, and, frankly, one that is remembered probably more than many other aspects of the demonstrations (except, perhaps, for the joke about not moving the tool rest with the lathe on, which they all do).

I agree with your assessment Gary, and we have recently been taking a proactive stance on requiring face shields (and where appropriate, other forms of personal protection) for demonstrators at AAW events.

Sorry John, but I don't buy the arguments that you can demonstrate without face/eye protection because "nothing will happen" with such a small turning, regardless of the inability of speaking, or that the demonstrator has too much experience to need protection. I agree that turning a pen, a small box, or a mirror handle may certainly have less risk of injury than when turning a large bowl or hollow form, however THE RISK OF INJURY IS STILL THERE. One missed placement of a turning tool against ANY rotating object still carries the possibility of throwing the business-end of the turning tool into one's face or body. There are no times when a face shield is not needed! What people to do in their own shops is certainly up to them, but at AAW events we will insist on personal protection equipment.

No longer! AAW IS THE MEMBERS, and EDUCATION is the key. And that education begins in the meetings and at the demos. Rob, I feel that AAW CAN do more to encourage, and, indeed, to INSIST that demonstrators at ALL AAW demonstrations, in all 300+ clubs MUST wear full face protection.

Please remember that IT IS UP TO THE CHAPTERS TO ENFORCE THEIR OWN SAFETY RULES since the AAW, centrally, has little control on what individual chapters choose to do at their own events. Please also recall that to be covered under the AAW's comprehensive insurance, all demonstrators are required to be members of the AAW at the time of their demonstration - Perhaps this needs to be extended to include the use of face shields or other PPE? - At AAW events, we can insist that demonstrators use face shields, but it is up to the chapters to enforce this requirement at their events. One of the issues the Board is discussing is the relationship between the national organization and its chapters. This issue of concern was brought out by the recent insurance changes; one of the major issues the insurance companies cite is that the AAW, as a national organization, has a somewhat "loose" relationship (legally speaking!) with its constituent chapters, and has little control over how they function, their activities, where they meet, safety standards being enforced, equipment used and its maintenance, first aid training, etc. The questions of whether we want more central supervision of chapters as to safety compliance, official status, chapter dues (or not), comprehensive liability insurance for all chapters, etc. are all 'difficult' issues that need to be thoroughly discussed and be resolved for the benefit of the AAW and its chapters.

Let's hope there are NO demos in Tampa without FULL FACE SHIELDS by ALL 165 (or whatever number of) demonstrators. Wouldn't it be nice to see the demonstrators who are just talking and not even turning wear a face shield to make the point? How about that one Rob? Have them at the SIGs! A little humor can help make the point!

For the Tampa Symposium (just about 2 weeks away!), the Board has discussed issues of safety for the entire event,and plans to implement a few safety-education requirements and policies:

1. At the demonstrator's meeting Thursday afternoon, all demonstrators wil be reminded that they are responsible for wearing face shields when turning (or involving other power tools), or other PPE as appropriate (e.g. use of goggles when using dyes or other chemicals, etc.). Demonstrators are being encouraged to include comments and techniques involving safe woodturning practices as part of their demonstration; this was a trend seen last year in San Jose, and we hope to increase the safety awareness though the demonstrators through example and through instruction.

Furthermore, the AAW will have polycarbonate safety screens at all turning stations, and demonstrators are expected to use these to increase protection for members of the audience at their demonstration.

2. At the opening meeting on Friday morning, I will be making a few announcements and reminders to attendees regarding the AAW's policies on safety and the need to improve safety awareness, at the Symposium, when teaching new turners,a nd while conducting demonstrations at their own chapter events.

3. In the Trade Show area, ALL VENDORS at which turning or use of other power tools or cutting devices are REQUIRED to have safety screens protecting onlookers from flying chips (and hopefully anything else!) generated in the lathe area, AND that the people in the trade show doing demonstrations are REQUIRED to use safety shields while they turn. This is written into the vendor's contract with the AAW, as and agreement in accepting booth space at the Symposium; we will be checking to see that vendors and Trade Show demonstrators are compliant with their contract. This is not just a matter of common sense, but also an issue of liability.

4. Safety will be stressed throughout ALL of the YOUTH ROOM and "Learn to Turn" activities where new turners are involved. This is an important component of turning education and the instructors involved in these activities will be including safety as a major component of their training in dealing with our new turners.

5. We have at least one Safety-specific demonstration (by Ron Gerton) who was invited to do his demonstration on woodturning safety. Other demonstrations will have have safety components within them. We will be encouraging demonstrators to develop additional safety demos in the future - my demo last year was one of those that addressed lathe workstation ergonomics and safety specifically.

6. As part of my 'Special Interest Night' presentation on "Gizmos and Gadgets" I will include a special section on "Safe and Efficient Turning Tool Storage" - Some of the tool racks I have seen in person and on-line are fundamentally dangerous, and should be avoided in designing one's tool holders for safe turning operations.

I would be happy to receive additional thoughts and specific ideas regarding how the AAW can increase safety awareness, encourage the chapters to take a zero-tolerance stand about establishing and enforcing their own safety rules at chapter activities, and how we can expand our education efforts.

For those of you attending the Tampa Symposium, please do introduce yourself to me (...I'll do likewise if I see you first!), and share your thoughts on how we can make the AAW's mission of promoting safety education better and more wide ranging throughout the woodturning community! If you won't be at the symposium, please shoot me an e-mail with your ideas [ rob@woodturner.org or robturns4u@gmail.com ] - I'd love to get input from all who are equally passionate about making sure we all pursue woodturning as safely as possible!

Rob Wallace

Chair, AAW Safety Committee

Member, AAW Board of Directors

Re: Safety and the AAW

#2

Re: Safety and the AAW

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

At the national symposium at Louisville in 2006 there was a demo given by a MD that had slides of multiple turning injuries. Our thirteen year-old grandson got a very informative eyeful. I think a similar demo should be MANDATORY attendance by every symposium attendee. Make sure it is a must: charge a $50 deposit that will be refunded with an attendance stamp. That demo was attended by only a third the number as other demos. All the other demos were standing-room-only! Are you so experienced and smart that you can't hurt yourself?

Don't just talk about safety. Put some teeth in what you say. If the demonstrator can't be heard, buy a better mike! Amen to the new rules.

Re: Safety and the AAW

#3

Steven Antonucci

Policy and compliance

steven antonucci

I think you've got good policy. Waiting to see whether or not you've got compliance with policy. Will the AAW actually stop a demonstration if the demonstrator refuses to use a face shield (for whatever personal reason?) I sure hope so...it is the right move.

Notwithstanding, rather than having a single "session" that may only be run once or twice, why not make a "Safety Annex" in the vendor area? There are no shortage of "bad ideas" that could be "educated out of existence" if the AAW put as much time into it as they do the Professional Outreach Program? 15 minute running sessions could be developed and delivered EVERY year, as the symposiums attract regionally and new members come in all of the time...

If you build it, I will come.

Steve

Re: Safety and the AAW

#4

Re: Safety and the AAW

Tim O'Hearn

Rob,

I hope you will write up your thoughts on safe tool storage for an article in the AAW journal.

Re: Safety and the AAW

#5

Re: Safety and the AAW

walta

Of course every demo needs a face shield.

I think every member of the live audience should be required to wear a hard had with face shield.

After we get use to that next year we can require body armor with ceramic inserts.

Better yet we can move the audience to a separate venue and they can watch the jumbotron.

Maybe I will stay home and watch a video.

My point is the more you separate the demonstrator from the audience the less fun the event becomes.

Wearing a face shield does not make you safe.

The safety issues are

1 Turning wood with known defects

2 Turning at to high a speed.

3 Not attached the wood to the lathe properly.

4 Using the wrong tool for a job or presenting a tool in the wrong way.

5 Pushing too hard make a dull tool cut.

And your hat does not change any of them.

Walta

Re: Safety and the AAW

#6

Re: Safety and the AAW

Mark Wollschlager

There are a significant number of 'demonstrator grade' turners that use wood with defects, on purpose.

There are also those who have developed advanced techniques that, in the hands of a beginner or intermediate turner could prove suddenly dangerous.

I, for one, do not want to eliminate those demonstrations.

These might illustrate situations where a higher level of personal protection must be demonstrated along with the technique.

I really should not matter if the demonstrator does not regularly use a high level of protection in their own shop.

It must be made clear to them, that in a public venue, they will be expected to also demonstrate a safe way to perform the methods demonstrated.

I will gladly 'suffer' through the boilerplate safety statements.

The last thing I want to see at a symposium or public demo, is a lowest common denominator level of skill and technique all in the name of safety.

All levels of the craft should presented, in a manners appropriate to the method.

Safety wise, visually, and to challenge the creativity of the audience.

Re: Safety and the AAW

#7

Re: Safety and the AAW

robo hippy

Quoting Popeye, 'I's had enough, and enough is too much!. I hope to have a video clip up on You Tube next week some time. The one thing that Walta didn't mention, which is my first line of defense as a bowl turner with some 15,000 bowls under my belt is STAND OUT OF THE LINE OF FIRE! Like DUH!!!!! I don't care how big you are, or what kind of safety equipment you are wearing, if you take a direct hit from any chunk of wood much above base ball size, you are going down like a bag of wet sand! Learn to turn bowls while standing out of the line of fire, and impact risk is almost zero.

robo hippy

Re: Safety and the AAW

#8

Steven Antonucci

A point far more important than face shields...

steven antonucci

When I demo in some environments, there is nothing between me and the crowd except open air. Not every venue has "crowd shields". Knowing that not all demos are created equally, this is probably a good idea for all AAW backed events...unless someone realizes that putting "the good seats" right in the line of fire isn't really that great of an idea.

If I am turning at a public venue in front of a "non-turning" audience, I will often invite them to move to a spot that I know is safe, even if they do not. I have had numerous "safety experts" tell me that I should have a face shield on ... while standing directly opposite me on the other side of the lathe... in the line of fire (I am always out of the line of fire, or have the tool rest adjusted)

Last thing I'd mention is that I do things in my own shop that I would never demo. An example is taking a piece of firewood to round. Sometimes, larger bits of ragged split will disembark for points yonder (but I do not care, since I am out of the line of fire)... but there might be someone sitting in the audience who takes the hit. Demonstrators need to not only demonstrate safety techniques, but they also need to demonstrate techniques safely for the environment they are in.

If you've ever seen me demonstrate forging a hook tool, you'll know I take safety seriously. Safety is a function of experience, technique, and environment- change one thing, and you'd better think it over again.

Steve

Re: Safety and the AAW

#9

Re: Safety and the AAW

Stuart Johnson

STAND OUT OF THE LINE OF FIRE

This is often quoted but I don't recall ever seeing a diagram, video or demonstration showing just where the line of fire is located. I know this should be intuitive but this is not always the case.

Re: Safety and the AAW

#10

Steven Antonucci

A rule of thumb that should help

steven antonucci

If you are in faceplate orientation, with the tool rest anywhere between perpendicular to the way and 45 degrees to the ways, and you are standing behind the tool rest, you are out of the line of fire. Generally speaking, being "behind the gouge" is out of the line of fire (think push cut).

S

Re: Safety and the AAW

#11

Brad Vietje

Re: Safety and the AAW

Brad Vietje

Great Discussion!

Rob: great job coming up with these policies! These are all policies that can and should be enforced. Every demonstrator, including those in the trade show, should be required to wear a face shield if there's a spinning piece of wood present (or other hazard such as a router, saw, etc...).

Acoustics: I know that some demonstrators remove, or don't wear face shields all the time so they can be heard and understood by those in attendance. Most of us have probably omitted the face shield so we could be heard during a live demo -- I know I have. Video taping and archiving the presentation tends to increase this pressure toward better sound quality and more risky behavior. If the AAW (or our local chapter) supplies a cordless microphone that doesn't interfere with the demonstrator's vision or interfere with their safety gear, the face shields will be worn with much greater regularity.

For club demo's, if the AAW can negotiate a group purchase price for such equipment, it could be one way to use technology to help increase compliance and the adoption of better safety practices.

Bill T.: Excellent idea, which I fully support -- including the refundable deposit (though I'd make it $25). I know that every moment at the symposium is valuable, and there's never enough time to see all that you want to, so this might be addressed by sessions in the evenings, or a check-in orientation session before the official start of the symposium, a breakfast session, or even a DVD take-home that becomes part of one's local club lending library. The funds not returned go to a fund to help promote AAW safety.

Walta: you are right that we can't legislate good behavior in our own shops, but I believe we can and should demand it at symposium-type events.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Safety and the AAW

#12

Rob Wallace

Re: Safety and the AAW

Rob Wallace

Walta commented:

Of course every demo needs a face shield.

No, only those in which the lathe is being used, or when other equipment or supplies are used that might involve injury.

Then the facetiousness began:

I think every member of the live audience should be required to wear a hard had with face shield.

After we get use to that next year we can require body armor with ceramic inserts.

Better yet we can move the audience to a separate venue and they can watch the jumbotron.

Maybe I will stay home and watch a video.

No comment!

My point is the more you separate the demonstrator from the audience the less fun the event becomes.

I don't see how one becomes "separated" from the demonstrator simply because they are wearing a protective device. Of all of the reasons I've heard for not wearing a face shield, the "not fun" reason certainly is among the weakest....

Wearing a face shield does not make you safe.

I AGREE COMPLETELY! - (I never said it made anyone safe.)

He continued:

The safety issues are

1 Turning wood with known defects

2 Turning at to high a speed.

3 Not attached the wood to the lathe properly.

4 Using the wrong tool for a job or presenting a tool in the wrong way.

5 Pushing too hard make a dull tool cut.

And your hat does not change any of them.

I am not sure these are "The" safety issues, but are certainly among those that need to to be considered when woodturning - it is not a complete list by any means. And you are correct that the "hat" doesn't change them - this is part of safety education that we are trying to promote.

However, you seem to be completely missing the point why face shields are used.....

In most states or other jurisdictions, to drive an automobile it is the law that the operator and passengers are required to wear seat belts. Wearing seat belts does not make you a better driver, allow you to make split-second decisions any better, nor does it protect you from other drivers or getting T-boned in an intersection by a drunk in the other vehicle. What seat belts do is increase the chances for survival of an impact of any kind, and lessen the bodily injury when it happens. It is currently 'the law' to wear them, which most people now do as a matter of routine; many people bitched and moaned since 1968 when the first federal seat belt law was put in place, and today we see compliance with the seat belt laws of over 80% in most states, some well above 90%.

Face shields are the woodturner's seat belts - using a face shield will not make you any more (or less) safe, it will not improve your turning skill, it likely won't make you any more creative, and it probably won't improve your appearance. What it does is provide a measure of protection against an accident that will allow you to survive the incident with minimal injury. There are people alive today because they wore a face shield while turning while suffering a major accident - just like the thousands of cases where seat belts have saved lives. It may not be as much "fun" (in your definition) for the audience, but in my book, safety of the operator trumps fun in any situation, location, or time - end of story.

The AAW Symposium is our "jurisdiction" and we require face shields (our seat belts) to be worn by lathe operators while demonstrating. It is a simple, easily met requirement, and if they have not worn them before while demonstrating, it is incumbent on the demonstrator to adapt to the safety requirements at the venue where they are demonstrating. I hope all chapters follow suit by requiring face shields for all demonstrators, and (hopefully, after much less than 40 years) we will see over 90% compliance, as we now have with seat belt use. It is a matter of incorporating this practice into the standard procedures used, and normal expectations of all turners. It needs to be part of the 'woodturning culture', and we will continue to work toward that end.

Unfortunately, Walta, you have said nothing to convince me that there is any acceptable reason to NOT wear a face shield while turning.

Rob Wallace

Re: Safety and the AAW

#13

Re: Safety and the AAW

Dale Bonertz

Stuart,

There was a diagram a while back in the AAW journal of where the line of fire is. They used a donut shape to illustrate it. In one of Raffin's books he illustrates it also.

Dale

Re: Safety and the AAW

#14

Crowd Shields

Dale Bonertz

Speaking of crowd shields does anyone have a good design for one. I have heard, but I do not have first hand experience, that most of them get dust all over them making it difficult for viewers to see. Is there a design where someone has alleviated this problem. I would like to consider these for our meetings and our symposium Rocky Mountain Woodturning Symposium. Sorry I had to through in that shameless plug. Great symposium though.

Re: Safety and the AAW

#15

Dale, ask your golfing buddies if.......

JamieDonaldson

....any of them have connections with the maintenance staff at local golf courses. I have made several such safety shields from "excess" cart windshields, most are shatter resistant Lexan, and most courses have a pile of discards each time the cart fleet is changed out on lease. A good washing and coat of Armor All reduces static charges and fills in most of the scratches.

Re: Safety and the AAW

#16

Re: Crowd Shields

Dale Gillaspy

We just built one for our club. We used square aluminum tubing and Lexan for the shield. As for the dust, if you wipe it down with dryer sheets, it will help repel dust that would normally stick to it.