Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Adrien is home

Posts

Adrien is home

#1

Steven Antonucci

Adrien is home

steven antonucci

Just got a note from one of our club members who spoke to Adrien. He is home and planning on getting back to the shop in a couple of days.

Sounds like he's going to be OK!

Steve

Re: Adrien is home

#2

That is great news!!  :-)


Re: Adrien is home

#3

Re: Adrien is home

Bill Howatt

Great news indeed!

Do you think we'll ever find out exactly what the "helmet" or other protection was?

Bill

Re: Adrien is home

#4

Re: Adrien is home

Roger Chandler

I am so glad to hear he seems to be recovering from this accident. I hope he will post at some point about the things he was doing and how he thinks the events unfolded........it could help others to perhaps be a little safer at the lathe.

I hope he will not overdo it too soon in the shop......from the sound of the injuries, he will need some recovery time.........super news, however!

Re: Adrien is home

#5

Be patient guys, he just got home

Dick Coers

We'll find out soon enough, we should be overjoyed that he made it out of the hospital.

Re: Adrien is home

#6

My thoughts and a proposal for AAW (long)

GaryG in MD

I think we are all very relieved to hear that his "helmet", whatever it was, and how badly damaged it may have become, did the job well enough to save him from more serious injuries. Bottom line, it was a nasty accident, but he had his safety gear in place, and it clearly saved his life. This is something we can take home with us.

I am a member of AAW and a member of three AAW chapters. I agree with Rob that they cannot become involved beyond education. In my position as self-proclaimed Safety Officer of Montgomery County Woodturners, I have brought this incident to the attention of our members at the last meeting, and our President is working to put a line item into our contracts with future demonstrators indicating that face shields WILL BE WORN whether they want to or not. I have to say that far too many of our professionals have demonstrated without same, generally in the guise of not being able to be heard. IMO, that is a terrible example for the members, and, frankly, one that is remembered probably more than many other aspects of the demonstrations (except, perhaps, for the joke about not moving the tool rest with the lathe on, which they all do).

No longer! AAW IS THE MEMBERS, and EDUCATION is the key. And that education begins in the meetings and at the demos. Rob, I feel that AAW CAN do more to encourage, and, indeed, to INSIST that demonstrators at ALL AAW demonstrations, in all 300+ clubs MUST wear full face protection.

When I started writing this, I had no idea all this was going to come out, but it flowed after being dammed up for a long time, I guess. I think it started with Lynne Yamaguchi's accident, and this ongoing discussion threw me over the edge.

Let's hope there are NO demos in Tampa without FULL FACE SHIELDS by ALL 165 (or whatever number of) demonstrators. Wouldn't it be nice to see the demonstrators who are just talking and not even turning wear a face shield to make the point? How about that one Rob? Have them at the SIGs! A little humor can help make the point!

Be safe out there, GG

Re: Adrien is home

#7

Re: My thoughts and a proposal for AAW (long)

John Lucas

Well I'm sorry to disagree but I just don't find it necessary to wear a face shield when turning Christmas ornaments or my hand mirrors. With 30 years of experience I think it should be left up to me to decide what I wear or don't wear.

I will wear a face shield when it's necessary for safety but feel that it's up to me to decide. When I demo I talk constantly telling you every little move my tool is doing so that hopefully you will learn more. It's just not feasible to flip the faceshield up every 2 seconds to explain what I'm doing. Then you have to stop the cut. It flows much better when I the camera can follow the action of the tool and I can explain exactly what I'm doing as it goes down. You can't stop and lift the face shield to explain.

Most places I demo don't have headset mikes and even then they don't fit my small head so it's hard to get the mike set at the right spot. Even harder when your trying to fit it under a face shield.

We should talk about safety, and discuss wearing faceshields but I still think it's up to the demonstrator to decide whether to wear one or not.

Re: Adrien is home

#8

Alan Zenreich

Re: My thoughts and a proposal for AAW (long)

Alan Zenreich

John,

There are ways of being heard clearly without flipping up a faceshield. The "they can't hear me" argument is easily and inexpensively death with.

In my demos, people hear me just fine, in large rooms, even when wearing my 3M Airstream helmet/shield/respirator.

This same equipment can also help turners who record videos for YouTube publication. There really is very little excuse for poor audio these days.

If people put the same level of care into the quality of their presentations

(this includes demos, video and photographs) that they put into the quality of their turning, everyone would benefit.

Re: Adrien is home

#9

Alan Zenreich

Re: My thoughts and a proposal for AAW (long)

Alan Zenreich

By the way, because as you mentioned, not all clubs have microphones that fit under my face shield (or any sound system at all), Lauren and I bring our own audio gear.

It works with my safety equipment, fits me well, and I am comfortable with its use. I can use it standalone, or plug into an existing audio system.

It's up to ME to make sure Lauren and I can be heard. I bring my own audio gear for the same reasons I bring my own tools to a demo.

Re: Adrien is home

#10

Re: My thoughts and a proposal for AAW (long)

Dale Bonertz

John,

Although I agree with some of your points I feel that clubs have a right to a few demands of their own for liability reasons. You may just be limiting who you can demo for if you refuse to wear a face shield. If the AAW is going to publish a series of books, one on safety, they should follow their own printed example. Note: I have not read them or even own them but from what I heard they say wear a face shield. Even the best turners make mistakes and cause an accident.

Re: Adrien is home

#11

Re: My thoughts and a proposal for AAW (long)

John Lucas

Not all of us have lots of money to spend and it seems like many clubs are in the same boat. I do the best I can with what I have. seriously though if your turning a ornament finial that is 3/4" thick and 5" long is it going to hurt you or anyone else. Same with my mirror handles.

It seems to me that most accidents happen because people aren't using sound wood, turning too fast, or poor tool techniques. Todays lathes are also bigger, heavier with more horsepower so people are trying to turn big things, which are dangerous. I'm not going to keep arguing this because it's like arguing politics. Can't sway each other either way.

I don't wear a faceshield because I find them uncomfortable and the type of turnings I do simply don't need it. Personal choice and I've been turning for a very long time. I do advocate them for beginners because as I stated above they often select wood with crack, or other defects and they don't have the tool skills.

Re: Adrien is home

#12

Good to hear-thanks!


Re: Adrien is home

#13

Steven Antonucci

It is the mixed message problem

steven antonucci

Gary-

Not looking to politicize the good news (Adrien seems to be OK), but I think you underscore the issue with "safety" and the AAW.

For starters, in my own shop, I control what I do and I am completely accountable for the results of my own actions. Wearing any protection is situational (and I agree with John about some items being low risk), but I also agree that AAW "events" should have a mandate in their contracts about a minimum level of protection to be at an AAW event (if the AAW is going to formulate an official stance on safety). If you have a position, you back it up with actions.

However, I think that the problem is even bigger than the "face shield" question. Where is the "safety seminar" at every national symposium? Why isn't there a dedicated area at every one of these events to discuss proper chainsawing techniques, lathe set-up (to avoid being in the line of fire), grinder maintenance to keep wheels from exploding, and overcoming catches for beginners? A lot of the "issues" that require a face shield for protection can be overcome from improving technique or getting out of the line of fire (I am betting 99% or more?)

Far too much "Sexy After Turning Process" demos for people who are still struggling to get things safely off the lathe... Go count the number of sessions dedicated to one vs. the other.

If you want to preach safety, you have to act safety...

Steve

Re: Adrien is home

#14

Re: My thoughts and a proposal for AAW (long)

Barry L Elder

As my grandfather used to say, " Safety is always better than a sharp stick in the eye!"

Re: Adrien is home

#15

Rob Wallace

MOVING THIS DISCUSSION TO ITS OWN THREAD

Rob Wallace

As much as I am happy that Adrien is home from the hospital, I think the topic of safety is important enough to warrant its own thread, and should not hijack the thread of the good news that he has recovered enough from the accident to be released.

I am responding in a new thread, "Safety and the AAW" to Gary's (and others') comments.

Go to: http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/turning.pl/page/1/md/read/id/468647/sbj/safety-and-the-aaw/

Rob Wallace

Re: Adrien is home

#16

Re: My thoughts and a proposal for AAW (long)

Glen Key

Glad to hear Adrian is home and on the mend.

One of the member's of my local club did a demo a couple of years back. Getting ready for the demo, he was wiping down his face shield when someone said something along the lines of "people would not be able to hear him with the shield on".

He wore his face shield, and everyone was able to hear and understand him very well.

The not being heard excuse is just that, an excuse.

Being safe is the main thing here.

Re: Adrien is home

#17

I apologize...

GaryG in MD

for unthinkingly hijacking the good news about Adrien.

I'm sure we're all relieved and happy for him. ...GG