Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Sharpen a Skew with Acid ???

Posts

Sharpen a Skew with Acid ???

#1

Sharpen a Skew with Acid ???

Doc Green

If muriatic acid will sharpen a file, why wouldn't it work to sharpen other cutting tools such as a bowl gouge or a skew?

Just think about the possibilities here. You could get rid of all the grinders, jigs, CBN wheels, and so forth and replace them with a container that would hold the tool securely with the tip submerged in the acid. By having two identical gouges, for example, one could be sharpening in the acid while you are turning with the other.

Crazy, right? OK, I think so too.

This is just a round-about way for me to express an opinion that the acid will NOT sharpen a file. It may clean gunk or debris out of the grooves, but there is no way I can imagine that etching the surface will restore the sharpness of a cutting edge.

I've never tried it because I know in advance that it will not work.

So, to prove me wrong, what evidence can you offer that the acid really does sharpen a file? Can you explain why the acid will not simply eat the cutting edge away and leave an irregular but more rounded surface?

The acid test (pun ! ) is whether or not a file sharpened with acid will remove metal more efficiently than it did prior to putting it in the acid. Simply feeling sharper or looking different doesn't count.

--Skeptical in North Carolina

Re: Sharpen a Skew with Acid ???

#2

Re: Sharpen a Skew with Acid ???

art demers

I totally agree with Doc no doubt it will clean the groves and teeth give you the impression that it's sharper but there is no way that it is sharper. Plus it has to erode the steel it's made of, and make it rusty.Call me Thomas the doubter I guess.

Re: Sharpen a Skew with Acid ???

#3

Way back when....

Ray

I worked as a general laborer at Nicholson File in the late 50's. They stored the files in vats of water between operations and just before packaging they were sand blasted to remove the scale and sharpen the files. Never heard of acid sharpening. I keep thinking I should try sand blasting some of my old files to see if I can restore the cutting edge.

Ray

Re: Sharpen a Skew with Acid ???

#4

Re: Way back when....

Dale Miner

The machine shop in the steel mill I worked at routinely sent out files for resharpening. They came back clean of course, but a close visual inspection found them sharper than a used dull file. The shop floor explanation of the process sounded like reverse electrolosis.

Re: Sharpen a Skew with Acid ???

#5

Re: Sharpen a Skew with Acid ???

Doug Turner

There is a facilty here in Southern CA that sharpens files with liquid grit abrasive and they are as sharp as new. I have heard of using acid to remove rust and restore the teeth of a file, but not to sharpen.

Re: Sharpen a Skew with Acid ???

#6

Steven Antonucci

Rather than guessing, why not try it?

steven antonucci

I tried it, and I can tell you categorically that it worked in my shop on my files (to varying degrees) without a shadow of a doubt. Even if you do not believe that it will remove "dull metal", I don't think you doubt that it will remove iron oxide? Ever try to sharpen rust? Do you doubt that rust on a tooth reduces its sharpness?

There is no question in reading COUNTLESS blacksmithing forums that this is an accepted means of restoring a file. The before and after results on the rasp I put in the bath are astounding. I will be trying other heavily rusted files later on if the weather permits this weekend (I have a box full).

Steve

Re: Sharpen a Skew with Acid ???

#7

OK.  Backtracking!  Steve is correct.

Doc Green

OK, Folks. Time for me to back up and eat a little crow. I sat down and drew a quick sketch to show how the cutting edge would be rounded as layers of equal thickness were etched away. And to my surprise, the edge got sharper!

"Dang," says I. "Maybe it will work after all !"

Then I did a bit of Googling "file sharpen with acid", and found a ton of hits showing how to do it, etc. etc. etc.

"Too late to remove that post?"

So, here I am, eating crow. Should have drawn the sketch and done the Googling before I made my post.

The attached sketch shows how it works.

Oh well, never too old to learn, I suppose, but I think I'm getting close.

~Doc ... red-faced in North Carolina

Re: Sharpen a Skew with Acid ???

#8

Re: OK.  Backtracking!  Steve is correct.

Don Evans

Hey Doc, guess you could say it is FRIABLE, like a white grinding stone.

Re: Sharpen a Skew with Acid ???

#9

Re: OK.  Backtracking!  Steve is correct.

Stuart Johnson

There was a long discussion on the Segmented Woodturners site about sharpening bandsaw blades using this method. In that case vinegar is used rather than acid.

Doc, is it okay if I copy your photo and post it over there?

Re: Sharpen a Skew with Acid ???

#10

Stuart, post the photo if you wish.


Re: Sharpen a Skew with Acid ???

#11

Steven Antonucci

I have a good crow recipe

steven antonucci

Doc-

No crow necessary.

I did a little research, which I always consider the source (if it is on the internet, it must be true?) It was in so many reputable places, that I figured it had to at least have some merit? The barrier to entry was low (muriatic acid was maybe $10?), and I had an endless supply of "beat" files.

I have no idea how long it takes to get the best effect, or if it is a function of how rusted they are, or how much acid per ounce of metal is the optimum ratio. I know from chemistry (25 + years ago) that the iron and oxides are reacting with the acid to create other chemicals and that the acid is weakening over time (so perhaps changing the bath would improve results, or shorten etch times)

Qualitatively, sharper. Quantitatively, cannot say... but it does so without affecting the hardness of the steel. I didn't invent the process, nor do I have a full understanding of what happens at a molecular level. All I know is that I end up in a better place than I started (assuming I take the proper precautions with the acid.)

BTW- I think you hit another "soft point" on why it works? I suspect that if you could somehow agitate the acid, it would work better. It forms bubbles on the surface of the file (oxygen from the oxides being released?) and turns the liquid green (no idea?)

Steve

Re: Sharpen a Skew with Acid ???

#12

Electro Stripping

charlie belden

It's called Electro Stripping. Make the file the Anode in a slightly acidic water bath, stick a stainless steel cathode in with the file - bit not touching it. Apply DC current between the file and the SS plate and ions will come off the file and ions will be deposited on the SS cathode. AND, you'll generate LOT if very tiny hydrogen bubbles on the surface of the file - that'll bubble off gunk. (UltraSonic cleaning does something similar, generating small bubbles on the surface of a piece that dislodge oxidation on thesurface of an item, though the bubbles are cause by cavitation)

Rinse the flle in clean water, paper towel off the water then dip in denatured alcohol and let air dry. The alcohol will get any water left on the piece. After it's dried, don't touch the working surface or you'll get oil from you hands on it - which will cause that area to oxidize more quickly than a clean surface (this is an old jeweler's trick used to keep sterling silver shiny)

Re: Sharpen a Skew with Acid ???

#13

Re: OK.  Backtracking!  Steve is correct.

John Veerkamp

Vinegar is an acid, ableit weak.