Sharpen a Skew with Acid ???
Doc Green
If muriatic acid will sharpen a file, why wouldn't it work to sharpen other cutting tools such as a bowl gouge or a skew?
Just think about the possibilities here. You could get rid of all the grinders, jigs, CBN wheels, and so forth and replace them with a container that would hold the tool securely with the tip submerged in the acid. By having two identical gouges, for example, one could be sharpening in the acid while you are turning with the other.
Crazy, right? OK, I think so too.
This is just a round-about way for me to express an opinion that the acid will NOT sharpen a file. It may clean gunk or debris out of the grooves, but there is no way I can imagine that etching the surface will restore the sharpness of a cutting edge.
I've never tried it because I know in advance that it will not work.
So, to prove me wrong, what evidence can you offer that the acid really does sharpen a file? Can you explain why the acid will not simply eat the cutting edge away and leave an irregular but more rounded surface?
The acid test (pun ! ) is whether or not a file sharpened with acid will remove metal more efficiently than it did prior to putting it in the acid. Simply feeling sharper or looking different doesn't count.
--Skeptical in North Carolina




