As a member of NJ Woodturners, we received the following e-mail from Adrien Coblentz's wife today:
This is Mary Ellen, Adrien's wife. I just wanted to let the group know that Adrien was badly injured when a plate he was turning flew off of the lathe and hit him in the head. (at least this is what the police and I were able to reconstruct. We found a few pieces of the plate but not all of them) Fractured skull, eye orbit fracture. He had facial reconstructive surgery and a plate in the frontal skull bone as the bone was shattered) on Saturday and had been in a drug induced coma until Sunday. He improved tremendously yesterday, but doesn't remember anything about the accident, except the fact that the plate he was turning was beautiful wood!
He had his helmet on and it was broken as we found pieces in the shop.
Please reiterate to the group the importance of wearing their helmets!!!!
He will be in the hospital for awhile, but sure he will be in touch when he is able.
Kind Regards,
Mary Ellen
Adrien posts here from time to time, and he could certainly use your thoughts and well wishes. Not trying to politicize this, but apparently, he was wearing a faceshield when the accident happened. Stay out of the line of fire, people!
Thanks for the notice Steve. Sure hope he recovers well and quickly. Must have been a terrible thing for his wife to discover. I hope she is OK too. Must have been quite an impact to have done so much damage even with his helmet on. I'm a little curious what exactly he was using for face protection.
Hang in there Adrien-we're all pulling for you. Hope you're back on your feet soon.
There should be a national clearinghouse for woodturning accidents and it seems logical that the AAW should assume that responsibility through their network of chapters.
For each significant accident (to be defined) a form (to be designed) should be filled out and submitted to the AAW. The information collected could be critical in the development of better safety equipment and procedures.
Were the AAW to embark upon such an effort, especially in the context of actually designing or "approving" safety equipment, the potential legal issues would quickly become too great for a not-for-profit to handle.
The most a charitable organization can do is advocate and recommend general things to do or not do. They are already doing that.
Let's remember that Adrian was wearing a face shield and a helmet and both were overwhelmed by the impact. Everyone should therefore take note that even if we take all the recommended precautions, there is no guarantee that we still won't get hurt or killed when something goes wrong at the lathe.
There was a resent thread on the AAW forum about publishing reports of accidents in the AAW Journal to raise awareness of the dangers and push turners to use more safe practices. Keeping potential responsibility in mind, what more would you wish the AAW to do?
I think the AAW should concentrate on spreading the safety message in word and deed.
Even if the AAW tried to collect accident statistics from chapters the picture would remain incomplete.
Inconsistent or overly reported stats would skew the numbers.
A club with many members and a high reporting threshold may seem to be less accident prone than a smaller club with a lower threshold. Or the reverse may be true.
Many turners are not members of turning clubs and/or may not self report.
At what point do you declare an accident reportable?
A shop accident or a lathe accident?
Quite honestly I think a lot of people would find it intrusive.
Clubs should do what they have to to ensure that safe turning/shop practices are in force at Club activities.
It would basically be a spreadsheet of information. Type of accident, what personal safety equipment was used or not used, what failed, and what they will do in the future to reduce the odds of it happening again. Maybe not even the last thought because that introduces opinion. Just data that will reinforce PROPER safety equipment useage. I'm shopping for a riot helmet now. I had a scare when I had emergency laser surgery on my eye to repair a tear. I don't want to loose the use of either one of my eyes.
Since this topic is coming around again, I'll repeat my stance.
The AAW cannot control the individuals behavior in their own shop, but they can control the people that they hire at their own events. I made a suggestion to Phil McDonald the other day that EVERY symposium should have some kind of dedicated sessions for safety and beginner behavior, stressing the basics over the artistic.
I also think that the AAW can better collaborate with industry to reduce the injuries by consulting with the manufacturers about what equipment best fits a turner's requirements. Too often, people are repurposing hockey masks, goggles, and thin cheap face shield thinking that they've somehow protected themselves, and people are getting hurt.
They have a POP committee. Why isn't there a Safety Committee or a Best Practices Committee?
..exactly what "helmet" means in this situation? Specifics about type and brand would be beneficial for other turners when considering purchase or use of this type equipment.
If my facts are accurate, I don't think that he owns an overly large capacity lathe? No idea how big the piece was, but I wouldn't think larger than 12"... as I cannot recall him ever bringing something larger to a meeting.
In addition, I think he's 86 or 87 years old? If I had to guess, his lathe was set at a higher RPM than he intended, but I am speculating.
Every turner's helmet I've seen incorporates face protection as well. I may be confusing Adrian with another, but I recall him posting about using one of those Stihl or Husky chainsawer rigs with the integrated face shield. As the post stated that the helmet was "broken", it appears that he took a hellava whack and the rig, whatever it was, unquestionably saved his life.
If you were a member of the AAW and was active in a local chapter you might already know that the AAW HAS a safety committee, and the role of the committee has expanded over the past year. The Safety Committee does exactly what you usuggest and performs no "police" functions; its role is to promotewoodurning education and evaluatesafetystandards in our own publications and productions.
I do not feel that it would be a very good use of volunteer time to try to have of an accident registry, or as some have previously called it, a "hall of shame". Remember that "The AAW" is not some business, but is an association of volunteers with a small paid staff to make an organization of ca. 15,000+ members function. Who will record this data, and Sas as others havealready said, the product will be in incomplete at best. Every time anaccidenhappens, who will be responsible to report the details? The victim? The chapter? What are the legal ramifications of establishing such a registry? In my opinion, the AAW can better serve its membership by increasing efforts in education, and perhaps by providing analysis and communication of the circumstances in which accidents happened when there is reliable information available.
The first response from many is that "the AAW should do something!", and we are. We cannot be safety police, nor can we prevent turning accidents. All we can hope for is to raise awareness of how to turn safely, encourage chapters and instructors to stress safe turning practices, and to support a 'safe turning' culture ads best we can.
My best to Adrian for a speedy recovery, and for his wife, that had to be heart-stopping for her to find him like that.
Something that no one has mentioned that has me thinking.
It is said he was turning a plate, some think he had the lathe set too fast.
How was the plate being held to the lathe?
Could it have been a tenon failure, broken screw on a faceplate.
Hard to answer right now, but if AAW is going to start trying to aquire information on accidents at the lathe, this is a good place to start. Not a "good" place, but a place to start compiling information.
Double the RPMS and you QUADRUPLE the kinetic energy.
It's odd that washing machines have a shut off switch that shuts the motor off if the wash load is too far out of balance - but lathes don't.
There's a lot of electronics being used in lathes like the NOVA line. Accelerometers that sense and can measure vibration could be incorporated and used to cut power to the motor - or even apply a braking feature - like that found on newer miter saws that stop the blade much quicker than just letting it spin down when the power is stopped.
Another feature that's found in modern wood routers is Soft Start - where the motor winds up to speed relatively slowly to avoid torque rotation laterally.
Combine an accelerometer with Soft Start and a micro computer programmed to sense a potentially dangerous condition and cut power to the motor seems quite doable - and probably wouldn't add a lot to the price tag of a lathe. There is of course a liability issue.
NOTHING is 100% safe (and fool proof)- that's the nature of living. But we can significantly reduce the risk by using our built in safety device - our brain. If it doesn't feel right - don't do it - at least not the way that doesn't feel right.
I wish the gentleman a speedy and complete recovery and hope he returns to the lathe when he's healed.