Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Shop tip, not turning related...

Posts

Shop tip, not turning related...

#1

Steven Antonucci

Shop tip, not turning related...

steven antonucci

unless you use files to refine you work post lathe?

So I have a drawer full of old files, and I have read frequently that they can be sharpened with muriatic acid, so I bought a gallon...did a little reading... and then set about it last night while carving a spoon.

Firstly, muriatic acid is strong stuff, so don't screw around with it. Work outside in a well ventilated area. When the breeze picked up last night, both my son and I would notice it... and it is bad stuff. Aside from not wanting to breathe it, it will rust everything in your shop if you work inside.

I used a 5G bucket from HD tilted at an angle, with the bucket essentially laying sideways on the ground and a slight downhill slope. Placing the files in it first, I added enough acid to cover them. 30-40 minutes later, I went back to a greenish bubbling mess.

Once the files have been etched, you need to stop the chemistry. Using a couple of tablespoons of baking soda in water created a neutralizing solution. I removed one file at a time, and placed it in a similar bucket arrangement of the second solution. It fizzled violently for a second or two, and then I would go get another one. When they were all moved, I let them sit for 5 minutes.

Once the files are neutralized, I dried them and sprayed them with WD-40 to try to prevent rust. I can feel that the ones that were just a little dull feel like new files. The ones that were a lot dull could probably have used another few minutes in the acid bath.

To dispose of the acid, I simply pour (slowly) the acid into the baking soda solution, and then dilute with a couple of gallons of water before dumping.

Simple and effective. Now, I just need to do it 5 more time for the other 25 files I own...or get another container ;)

Steve

Re: Shop tip, not turning related...

#2

Mike Stafford

Re: Shop tip, not turning related...

Mike Stafford

Muriatic acid fumes will also turn purpleheart into a most beautiful plum color that seems to be a little more colorfast than the original color.

Steve, the only thing I can add to your cautionary statements is that heavy duty rubber gloves and a face shield should be worn. A rubber apron is not a bad idea if you have access to one. Acids are totally non-discriminatory and will etch steel, eat excess mortar off of masonry surfaces and remove skin and eyeballs with equal ease. Muriatic acid is the same material as hydrochloric acid which when used in chemistry class requires the same precautions.

Not to be trifled with!!!!!

Re: Shop tip, not turning related...

#3

Re: Shop tip, not turning related...

robo hippy

Great stuff for cleaning up the calcium leaching out of concrete, also called masonry cleaner. Used it a lot on exposed aggregate and sand finish slabs. There are various strengths. Resiprator helps if you are using a lot, or outside like you did with wind. I know that vinegar will do the same thing to concrete, but at a much slower rate. Don't know if it would work on the files.

robo hippy

Re: Shop tip, not turning related...

#4

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Shop tip, not turning related...

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Very important. DAMHIK. Don't store any left over acid in the shop even if you think the lid is tight. It will slowly rust every piece of steel in the shop.

Dennis

Re: Shop tip, not turning related...

#5

Steven Antonucci

Mike, Robo, Dennis (all valid points)

steven antonucci

I left those out on purpose (but covered them with the precaution to read A LOT)

...

This morning, my truck doors were a little sticky? No idea if it is related to being downwind from the etching, but I suppose I will know in a month if the front end falls off?

As usual, make sure you know what you are doing before you do it and make sure that the guy you learned it from know as much as you give him credit for knowing.

Steve

Re: Shop tip, not turning related...

#6

Re: Mike, Robo, Dennis (all valid points)

John Stegall

I have used vinegar and left it in over night. In a prior life we etched concrete floors before sealing them but I think we only used it at 10%, been too many years though. I have heard that citric acid does the same thing as far as file sharpening but I have not used it.

Do follow safety precautions and it will dissolve the case on a circular saw(aluminum) made in 1970, even though it was brand new. Only took a month in an enclosed cabinet. I won't reveal who left the lid loose on the muriatic.

Re: Shop tip, not turning related...

#7

Steven Antonucci

I have mine sitting outside...

steven antonucci

And I noticed a little rust on the firepit this AM...

Not for the faint of heart!

S

Re: Shop tip, not turning related...

#8

Re: Shop tip, not turning related...

John Leonard

That's also my experience. Couldn't figure out what weas causing tools to rust then it hit me the only thing different was the bottle of muric acid in the bottle tightly closed. Gave it to a friend with a swimming pool and the rusting stopped. John L.

Re: Shop tip, not turning related...

#9

Hey Seteven, do you sharpen sandpaper?

Jorge

What a coincidence! Yesterday I spent an hour sorting out a catch all corner and came out with more than 50 files, not counting the chain saw files. I am no friend of muriatic acid, from my mason days, so I may go the citric acid route, some of those files were used a lot when I was making furniture and it would be nice to sharpen them.

Thank you!

Re: Shop tip, not turning related...

#10

Re: Shop tip, not turning related...

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

You wrote:

To dispose of the acid, I simply pour (slowly) the acid into the baking soda solution, and then dilute with a couple of gallons of water before dumping.

Steve, in the situation you describe it probably won't make any difference as sodium bicarbonate is a weak alkali, but standard chemical practice is to pour a strong acid into a large volume of water FIRST. Never pour water into acid or acid into strong alkali. You want to dilute the acid to reduce the hazard of boiling and splattering.

So to dispose of your acid, dilute it by pouring into water then you can add your weak alkali for neutralization, if necessary.

Re: Shop tip, not turning related...

#11

Steven Antonucci

I'm not gonna lie to you

steven antonucci

Roughly equal parts acid and base, acid into the base... a lot of bubbling and fizzing! Definitely makes sense doing the dilution first... and AAA (Always Add ACID).

Good tip, and that will be how we deal with it in the future.

S

Re: Shop tip, not turning related...

#12

Steven Antonucci

sharpening sandpaper... have to think about that:)


Re: Shop tip, not turning related...

#13

SAFETY APRON

Don Evans

Warning on that apron, if you don't have one, MAKE one, just use clear 4 mil plastic from hardware store. Everyone should have a roll of this around anyway for storm or rain damage prevention. I don't recommend making a poncho but some holes in it and string to hold it up (strings goes over head and around mid section. Why no poncho? Because if you spill any on you getting it off over your head could cause it to end up on you anyway!

I try to keep at least a 25 ft roll at present have a 50, but we have those things call hurricanes to look out for and going through a tropical storm at this moment. thankfully it is a small one, just lot of rain and 45 mph wind.

Don

Re: Shop tip, not turning related...

#14

Citric acid

Alex Y

I, too, have heard of using citric acid for this purpose. But if my assumption is correct that you don't just soak it in a vat of orange juice ;) , where does one find more concentrated citric acid?

Re: Shop tip, not turning related...

#15

Re: Citric acid

John Stegall

I bought some in the canning section of a small general store. It is a powder.

The woodwork forum in Australia described in detail how to "sharpen" files using vinegar which is the first place I ever heard of rejuvenating a file.

I may have to go by the local pawn shop and grab a file or two and try substituting the citric acid. One thing I remember is the need to clean the old file of any grease that may be on it so whatever acid used can penetrate.

Re: Shop tip, not turning related...

#16

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Citric acid

Jack Guzman from Maine

I went looking for some yesterday. The hardware store was out of stock. I found it near the pectin,canning salt and mason jars in the supermarket. Now for the experiment.---Jack

Re: Shop tip, not turning related...

#17

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Citric acid

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Any place that sells winemaking supplies will stock citric acid in powder form. It is a very mild acid compared to muriatic acid so will probably take much longer to do its job.

Dennis