Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Cost of Carbide vs HSS

Posts

Cost of Carbide vs HSS

#1

Cost of Carbide vs HSS

jeff willaford

Has anyone determined the relative cost of using carbide vs HSS tools?

Since carbide turning tools on the market today are relatively new… has anyone projected, beyond the initial price of the tool, how many carbide cutters may be needed to match the life of a HSS tool and what the overall costs might be?

I’m not promoting anything either way but I am curious. You comments will be appreciated.

Re: Cost of Carbide vs HSS

#2

Re: Cost of Carbide vs HSS

Greg Haugen

The cost factor is relative; depends on how much you turn. If you're turning enough in a year to replace a gouge at $50-$60, a $20 (or even two) carbide tips are cheaper. To me the "cost factor," no matter how it is, gets out weighed with the "performance" factor when you look at the hollowing applications. An edged carbide cutter, like a Hunter Tip, will leave a better surface, more efficiently than a standard HSS scraper cutter. No pun intended, but I think we're just starting to scratch the surface of the capabilities of edged carbide cutters. They have multi-functional capabilities, more and more they're used in new ways by changing the rake angles and their orientations. They're more than just the shear scrapers, their applications are starting to pass into the realm of spindle and bowl turning, as well as blind hollowing with the negative rake tools.

Back to the original question.........any time you have a tool that you can replace the tip, the more you use it, the more the cost factor becomes in your favor.

Re: Cost of Carbide vs HSS

#3

Mike Stafford

Re: Cost of Carbide vs HSS

Mike Stafford

I don't have an answer for you Jeff.

I have been using Hunter carbide tools in a variety of configurations for a number of years now. Here are my observations:

First and foremost they are sharper than HSS and will leave a cleaner cut surface than HSS which results in less sanding time. This is particularly true on end grain.

There is a learning curve associated with almost any carbide tool as its cutter configuration determines whether it rides on the bevel and is a cutter or is used as a scraper. A carbide cutter used as a scraper will not provide a surface any better than a HSS scraper and in some instances the surface will not be as good.

Sharpening time is greatly reduced by using carbide tools i.e. you don't have to sharpen them.

Carbide cutters do have to be treated with care to make sure you don't bang them against each other so they will not chip. You can cut concrete with one but it will chip with the slightest bang against another carbide cutter. Keep them shielded with sections of poly tubing when not in use.

Carbide tools are not the best tool for rapid removal of wood. A gouge will usually remove material faster than a carbide tool but the carbide cutter controlled well will give a great finish cut.

Mike Hunter's new Osprey tools do a great job of mimicking a gouge and are by far the easiest tool for someone who can use a gouge to use. The surface left by a shearing cut with this tool on both end grain and side grain is truly excellent and is a real problem solver for torn end grain on bowls.

Carbide tools respond better, cut better at higher speeds. In general I do not recommend turning any faster than the speed at which a turner feels safe and in control. But as experience and tool control increases higher speeds can result in improved surfaces.

In my experience the carbide cutters on Hunter tools last a long, long time. Since I use them primarily as clean up tools for finish cuts the cutters don't get as much use as other tools in my inventory. But they definitely reduce sanding time.

I am friends with Mike Hunter but I have no financial interest in his company so you can take my comments for what they are worth but I use his carbide tools on virtually every project for my final cuts.

Here is a picture of end grain in tulipwood after cutting it with a Hunter tool. Not much sanding needed on that surface.


Re: Cost of Carbide vs HSS

#4

Re: Cost of Carbide vs HSS

Barry L Elder

And then I understand there is a new kid on the block: nanograin carbide!

Re: Cost of Carbide vs HSS

#5

Re: Cost of Carbide vs HSS

John Lucas

Barry The Hunter tools are what everyone is calling Nanograde. It's really just a smaller carbide particle.

I'm with Mike. I use the Hunter tools primarily for clean up. Mostly because I've just used the Bowl gouge for so long that it's hard grab the Hercules or Osprey and start with them.

I do have an EZ wood tool. In my opinion the edge doesn't last very long. At least not a sharp edge. The Hunter tool on the other had even when the edge chips it chips like napped flint on an arrow head so it still cuts. Not as cleanly as it did when new but still amazingly well.

If you use the proper sharpening techniques a bowl gouge will last much longer than a year. I use my Thompson gouge for almost every project and in 2 years only used 1". I still think the HSS tools are a better bargain. couple that with the need for spindle gouges and parting tools and other shapes you can't get in carbide HSS or better yet the powedered metal like Thompson's are a better choice.

Re: Cost of Carbide vs HSS

#6

Re: Cost of Carbide vs HSS

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Since carbide tools save you time, what is the value of your time? Life only gives you so much time to do your turning. Five minutes saved every hour equals how much money?

Re: Cost of Carbide vs HSS

#7

Steven Antonucci

Time-value of money and true cost

steven antonucci

This is an interesting question, because you ask for a comparison of just the tools and not the system. Tool vs. tool, carbide cutter tools are 2-3X HSS gouges upfront, and then another $20 every time you flip a new cutter in. HSS tools are "one and done".

Or are they?

To get the true cost of both tools, you have to look at all of the things associated with maintaining them. A hobby turner might not have a full shop, so sharpening might be a challenge for the occasional turner and a gouge. Adding in the cost of a wheel every 5 years, truing stones, jigs and fixtures needed to maintain the HSS tools change the true cost of HSS to someone who may only turn a couple of times a month.

In addition, for the casual turner, since there is no huge capital outlay for the tools needed to maintain the HSS, meaning that they can "leave" woodturning easily with very little capital tied up in an expensive shop. Odds are that they can also easily recoup 90% of their investment in the carbide tools since the consumables are readily available.

The last thing I'd offer has also been mentioned. The surfaces that are achievable with the Hunter cutters are easier for a hobby turner to get to with those tools than conventional HSS tools. If you do not turn often enough to be highly skilled, odds are that your HSS tools leave a surface that requires sanding, which means more consumables (more paper, and lower grits) have to be used to get you to a better surface. How much money can you save in sanding?

I am also friends with Mike Hunter, and I have no financial interest in his company. I think I have fairly and accurately represented both pros and cons of his tools vs. conventional HSS tools. I regularly use HSS tools in my shop, but I show people everywhere how the Hunters work because I know that not everyone will have the time to develop their capabilities. The Hunter cutters solve a ton of problems for new turners, and even a few problems for the more advanced turners.

All in all... I think they add expense to a well equipped shop, and could possibly save money for someone just starting out.

Steve

Re: Cost of Carbide vs HSS

#8

Re: Cost of Carbide vs HSS

Bill Jacksonville, NC

All turning tools need sharpening eventually. There is a learning curve to mastering turning tools we use regardless type of steel. Learning to sharpen you tools just another part of the craft. Besides mastering skills in tool use or sharpening your tools will run across that on piece of wood, metal, bone or stone that defies whatever tool used.

I have looked into many different brands and even homemade versions of carbide tools and cutters. Some folk touch up an edge on their cutters with diamond hone. Others have found less expensive carbide cutters from other than woodturning vendors as replacements. Be careful with buying in bulk not all carbide cutters the same.

While think there is definitely, a place for carbide tipped tools think trying to compare apples & oranges with HSS. So not sure how you can compare cost of one over the other. HSS, exotic steels conventional turning tools and carbide steel tools have their place.