Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Threading Boxes - help long

Posts

Threading Boxes - help long

#1

Threading Boxes - help long

Galen Vetterick

Well I purchased the EZ Threading Jig and after reivew of the device I decided to cut my first sample threads on a box. No instructions yah know.

Well the female threads I cut in the lid went well. Tuned thread on the box tenon went well to and the two fit perfect the first cut. This is for 16 threads per inch and the 3/16" wide 60 degree cutter. What is the suggested depth to cut 16 thread back into he lid? 3/16 plus half the cutter width minimum?

Now the lid: I probably guessed wrong on how many thread to cut. Do you just cut more threads depth than you will ever need? I see no reson to undercut the inside of the lid if you just have enough threads. Is it better to undercut so you know a better point to stop cutting in? Is it best to undercut the threads on the outer edge of the box lid so they cover over the area you cannot thread to the shoulder of the box. One way to make sure they close with no gap. Rather than cut thread recese in the lid is it better to undercut the tenon back to the shoulder so the lid can close on down?

I should probably make a drawing but I did not find a helpful video really giving details of thread deaths into the lid or how to handle not being able to cut thread to the box shoulder on the tenon. Hope I don't have you all lost.

The only problem I have with the EZ threader jig is the threading spidle is sloped 2 degrees off from centers of lathe. Height set collar is going to vary on box lenghts. Craig is sending me a new one to see if it is better. Thanks to those that can comment on proper thread engagement and any undercuts.

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

#2

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

John Lucas

Whew too many questions. You can easily cut the female threads as far into the box as needed. However it looks better if there is a definite end. The male threads are the same. You can run them all the way up to the shoulder ( I grind the end of my cutter back so it will cut very close to the shoulder). Again it looks nicer to have a relief because it gives the threads an ending point.

Now here's the problem. Lets say you make 3 threads on the female thread. Now you make 3 threads on the male side but leave a relief that equals 3 threads behind the male threads. Your box screws on and the male thread go past the female threads and the lid just spins. How do I know that? you don't have to ask. So when you plan your threads leave enough for both to engage.

So up to this point you just design the two mating parts. A quick sketch helps. But here's where it gets interesting. Up to this point your concerned with the lid fitting the base. However you haven't mentioned grain alignment. You will usually have to cut back the shoulder of one or the other to get the lid to rotate far enough so the grain matches. on a 16TPI 1/16" will give you one full revolution so you have to really sneak up on this fit 1/32 = 1/2 revolution 1/64th 1/4 etc. Then seasonally the lid will fit differently anyway but that's wood.

Typically on a box designed for storage I put the male threads on the bottom so whatever is in it will not get caught in the threads. However on my cupcakes it just worked out better to do it backwards. When you design your box take this into consideration along with the thread depth.

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

#3

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

robo hippy

My experience has been with the Klein jig, but at 16 tpi I would think they would be very similar.

The cutter has a tooth profile like a V. You grind off almost all of one half. This allows you to cut almost all the way down to the shoulder on the bottom/male box part. To get the grain to line up, you have to adjust that shoulder down max 1/16 inch, and if the threads don't go all the way down, or you over correct, you have to remount and cut more threads. Royal pain.

The male threads are cut on a tenon 1/4 inch exactly. The female threads are cut 3/8 inch. Again, the difference is to allow for adjusting the shoulder.

It is very important to have both tenon and recess exactly parallel to the ways of the lathe. Mostly so you have threads engaged for the whole way, rather than tapered to where you push the lid past some threads before they engage. You can eyeball against the ways. Close. You can use calipers, again close. Or, like Bonnie does, use a 6 inch straight edge ruler, machinist type reads in 1/64 inch and light weight. You hold this up against the tenon or recess, and then eyeball that against the ways of the lathe. This gets you almost perfect.

Timing the threads: A machinist gave me this term. This is where you get the grain to line up. It does not have to be hit or miss. First, the tenon has to be cut as close to EXACTLY 1/4 inch deep as is humanly possible. Then, before cutting the threads, line up the top and bottom pieces and make a pencil line on the pieces where the grain lines up. When mounted on the jig, advance/rotate the piece till the pencil mark is at 12 o'clock. Then, using a piece of 1/2 inch plywood, advance the whole jig up till it just touches the cutter. This gives you exact and repeatable spacing, which can be handy if you have to remount. Cut the threads. I cut the lid/female part first. Next, when cutting the male threads, use the same method for mounting and moving the cutting jig to like it up and position it for cutting the male threads. With my set up, if I have the male part with the pencil line at 12 o'clock, it ends up with the lines just a bit past the desired mark. If I rotate the male piece so the pencil line is at 10:30, then it always comes out to needing 1/4 or less of a rotation to get the grain to line up. You may have to experiment to see what works for you, but the main point is you can get it close rather than having some that have to be adjusted almost the full 1/16 inch and others that need only minimal adjusting.

I use a convex grind skew as a negative rake scraper to get the lines very close, and some times even perfect. 220 or 320 will finish the job.

Another note, the shoulders need to be square. If they are not, then you run into more adjusting than you really want to do.

robo hippy

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

#4

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

John Lucas

That's one of the many nice features of the Baxter threader. It stays parallel the the lathe ways so your box threads will be square. That is assuming you made the box square to the bed.

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

#5

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

robo hippy

I did get to see the Baxter jig in action at our last club meeting, a demo by Mike Meridith of the Doctor's Woodshop (you should try his walnut oil finishes). The biggest advantage that it has over Bonnie's jig is that there is a clamp release to slid the jig side ways, then lock and fine tune with the micro adjusters rather than having to crank it all the way by hand. It does cut the threads square to the lathe ways. Having the recess and tenon parallel to the lathes is still critical for a good fitting thread.

robo hippy

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

#6

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

John Lucas

It's also built so fit specific lathes.

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

#7

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

Galen Vetterick

Thanks for your replies. It seems grinding the cutter face is a common idea to be able to cut threads closer to a shoulder. It was done by a local club member with the Baxter too.

Knowing now how much tenon to cut I need to always cut more female threads to give room for even grain adjustments if I need to face the lid some.

It does seem like a 1/4" tenon is minimum for 16 TPI even if I grind the cutter.

Still seems with even a slight incomplete thread on the tenon you may need to undercut past it or bevel into the lid thread. I will learn.

John: Craig sent me your instruction version but it says to add 0.035 to make tenon. Doesn't that need to be 0.07 over inside female thread?

I put the EZ Threading spindle between centers to set the post collar. I set the banjo square to the bed ways with a machinist square before I lock the post. Then when I move the along the bed or away from the bed I always set the banjo to the bed with the square again. Seems to always then cut true to the lathe centers and box. I used a depth gauge on the cutter body to the fine adjust plate as a double check, over turn of nut method.

A short stay in the hospital stopped me from turning again and making reply.

Thanks again. Yes, the Baxter would be nice but my budget is shrinking and this jig does seem to work for the amount I will use it,(maybe).

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

#8

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

John Lucas

to make the threads fit the mating part must be .035" larger or smaller that part. For example if you make the female threads first the tenon for the male thread should be .035" larger than the measurement of the inside of the female thread.

If you make the male thread first then measure the outside diameter and subtract .035" to make the opening for the female thread.

What I like about the Baxter is the adjustment knob for this is marked in thousandths. It allows me to sneak up on a perfect fit. It may or may not be .035". This is because dial calipers aren't always dead on, our measuring isn't dead on (we weren't trained as machinists). We are turning with hand held tools and turning a material that moves. consequently .035 is what it should be for metal with very accurate measurments but I've found that to get a really good fitting thread in wood I often have to start at .025" and sneak up on the best fit. Even then the lid doesn't always fit like a Swiss watch. However the precision of the Baxter threader seems to give me the best chance of getting a really good fit.

Part of the fun of making threaded boxes is playing with the lid fit. I've certainly screwed up a few. Fortunately most customers never know as long as the lid unscrews and screws back.

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

#9

Mike Peace

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

Mike Peace

John, I don't understand how you can get your threads to fit by only adding .035". What works for me with the EZ Threading Jig is to make the tenon equal to the female size plus two times the thread depth. For 16 TPI that would be adding 0.070".

If we set .035" for the correct thread depth when cutting the female threads, don't we need to add that on both sides of the male tenon? ;)

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

#10

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

Dale Miner

Same here. I make the male .070” larger than the ID of the female for 16 tpi.

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

#11

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

John Lucas

I've always done 35 thousandths and it's worked perfectly

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

#12

Are we talking on the radius or the diameter?

Dick Coers

If you advance a feed by .035, isn't that moving it .07 on the diameter?

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

#13

Mike Peace

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

Mike Peace

John, I will have to experiment with that smaller number. I note that Bonnie Klein's lidded box handout says measure across female threads and add 2/64" to 3/64" (.031 to .047) which is close to your number of .035". Like you, she sneaks up on the fit with an initial pass of .025" thread depth on the male tenon and then trial fits. Looks like there may be more latitude in good threads than one might expect.

I suspect you have used .070 in the past at least once since that is what is in the Baxter jig instructions you edited. :D Like everything else in turning, there is more than one way to get there successfully.

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

#14

Re: Are we talking on the radius or the diameter?

John Lucas

That may be how they are looking at it. what I do is measure the female thread diameter. Add .035" to the reading and make my male tenon that size. Works every time for me. I've probably made 50 to 75 screw thread boxes if not more than that.

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

#15

Mike Peace

Re: Are we talking on the radius or the diameter?

Mike Peace

Ok, John, I am convinced. I just tried it being very careful with all of my measurements and .035" worked just fine.

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

#16

Thanks Guys

Galen Vetterick

Now what I thought I did worked for thread fit. Measured the inside diameter of the female thread as I had set cutter 0.035 into wood to cut. Cut the tenon .070 larger and then to cut threads set the cutter to touch the tennon and then went 0.035 for depth of cut. Damn it seemed to fit just fine.

Now I'm even more confused. I guess if I only go 0.035 larger I just will have loose threads, I think. Maybe not, maybe so. Hum???

Anyway thanks guys. Guess I'll cut off both threads and start over as it is only scrape test anyway. Ground my cutter face so it will come out differnt by a little anyway, or manybe a lot. :D

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

#17



Galen Vetterick

Maybe I should stick with threadless boxes? Anybody want a cheap EZ Threader? ;)

I think maybe my best investment would have been into one larger tap and die and made all boxes the same. :b

Time for a John Lucas production on threaded boxes and no hand chase please my lathe runs too fast for that and more tooling required! :)

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

#18

Re: Thanks Guys

John Lucas

I think what confused people is if you are using a regular cutter and you take off 35 thousandths you are reducing the size by 70 thousandths. With a threading cutter you aren't actually reducing the size of the tenon your just making a V cut. The top of the V has to fit into the bottom of the V on the mating thread. This is about 35 thousandths. On the older EZ threader a full turn of the screw feed was .040". I think Craig said he changed the thread to 1/4 x20. I would have to do the math to figure out how much that would be and it's too early in the morning for math. :)

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

#19

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

John Lucas

Mike The original Baxter instructions were written by another turner. When I redid them just recently for Vic I put 35 thous. in there (unless he changed it, I haven't looked).

Re: Threading Boxes - help long

#20

Re: Are we talking on the radius or the diameter?

robo hippy

This makes my head hurt. I am an old concrete construction worker. Most of us can't measure less than 1/4 inch. Now you are talking thousandths...... I just used the inside/outside caliper thingies, measured it and added a hair. If I was too big, I would just keep cutting.

robo hippy