I need another and hopefully better wood ID book. I was given a gift card to a bookstore so I guess I'll use it that way. What do you all suggest. I have the Bruce Hoadley series and Terry Porter's book on Wood Identification. I also have The New England Encyclopedia of American trees, and a field guide to tree Identification.
John, the National Audubon Society has two tree guides; one for the eastern U.S. and one for the western U.S.
I have the one for the eastern U.S. and it identifies over 700 species of trees with images of bark, leaves (summer and fall), flowers and fruit. It is not terribly expensive as I picked up a copy for less than $15 if I remember correctly.
They are two completely (or nearly so) different processes.....
.....WOOD identification and TREE identification are very different topics, although related in what is being identified.
How you identify wood is through observation of cell structures of different kinds and in different arrangements (typically with the aid of magnification), and usually includes some logical way of going through these characters (using an identification key) to finally get to a determination. Hoadley's book is still the best for the beginning, hobbyist, and casual wood identifier, since the necessary terms and the structures they describe are well-presented and well-illustrated. There are several other books out there (some still published and available) which rely on many more technical distinctions in cellular structure that most hobbyists don't want to bother with. There are other "wood identification" books that are what I call a "match the picture" book, where a representative side grain (and maybe end grain) image is there for you to match the piece of unknown wood in front of you with the picture in the book. That, too, is matching and not necessarily identification (although it can get you close!). You'd still need to confirm the cellular characteristics for confirmation of a correct ID.
TREE identification books are plentiful, and are often delimited by region or within some logical boundary (e.g. Trees of Illinois; Trees of Yellowstone National park, etc.). Most of these books rely on characters such as leaf shape, branching (e.g. opposite vs. alternate), bark characters, overall tree form, and in some cases flowers and fruits. Some also include characters to identify trees based on leafless twigs, persistent fruits, or seeds. There may also be some ecological information associated with the descriptions, and the better guides have a geographic distribution map as part of the description of each species. Unfortunately most (all?) tree identification books rarely have any information on wood structure, or macro-images of the end-grain characteristics or other specific descriptors of wood structure specifically. Obviously if you have characters available to identify the tree (leaves, fruits, branching, bark, etc.) the ID of the wood "comes along for the ride...."
When you DON'T have these (macroscopic) characters of the tree available, (i.e. you only have the unknown wood) you need to rely almost entirely on cellular structures. The kind of book needed for this wood ID, as well as the kind of characters used, is very different. Most people break down at this point, and rely on wood recognition from past experiences of working with known wood they have used before, and call it "identification", without actually going through careful study of the cellular characters and doing an actual identification of the piece of wood.
You probably should have BOTH tree AND wood identification books if you are serious about identifying the wood you are working with. The most frequently asked question I get when I give my "Introduction to Wood Identification" demonstration is "Can you identify this piece of wood for me?" while handing me a small wood scrap they brought with them from some bowl blank. My response is "Probably...." which is followed by "Then what is it?" They generally do not understand that one can SOMETIMES recognize the wood, but to actually IDENTIFY the wood it takes a bit more of an analytical approach, some study of cellular characteristics, and going through a key, one of which involves just immediately blurting-out a name!
I gave my wood ID demo at the 2011 St. Paul AAW Symposium, and several people who attended at that time were interested in a longer, hands-on workshop at a future symposium to learn the basics of wood identification. I wonder how much interest there is in attending a wood ID workshop if we were to schedule one a future symposium?
As I mentioned I have Mr Hoadleys book and it's excellent but very limiting. I can go to my stash, particularly exotics and pull out lots of wood that apparently isn't in his book.
I thought Terry Martin's book would answer all the Hoadley's wouldn't and still come up short. Possibly a lot of the problem is woods are named something different in different places. (Ironwood is a good example here in the US) You can find that tree listed as all sorts of species and I know ironwood isn't correct but it's what we call that tree around here)
For example a turner had a piece of burl wood the other day. I thought it was Red Mallee and when I got home I tried to look it up. It wasn't in any of my books. What I found online called Red Mallee sure looks like his wood.
I checked my shelf for books on wood identification, and I have at least 25 different books on the topic - some are much more helpful than others!
If you are interested in trying to identify exotics as well as more common domestic woods you might try the following few books:
Bishop, P. 1999. "100 Woods: A Guide to popular Timbers of the World" The Crowood Press, Mamsbury, Marlborough, Wiltshire, UK
Flynn, JH and CD Holder (Eds.) 2001. "A Guide to Useful Woods of the World", 2nd ed. Forest Products Society, Madison, Wisconsin. (279 species illustrated)
if you are interested in identifying trees by their leaves there is a small booklet TREE FINDER by May Theilgaard Watts that is simple to use and quite effective.
It is organized like a flow chart. Answering one question directs you to another and then another and in no time you have identified the tree. And, there is another booklet WINTER TREE FINDER by May Theilgaard Watts and Tom Watts for identifying deciduous trees in winter.
I highly recommend these books. I purchased my copies on Amazon for about $5. Amazon also has other of her tree finder books.
I sometimes refer to " wood identification and use " by terry porter, has a lot of the exotics in and gives the different names the wood is also known as, though I doubt no one book will do it all (it would be as thick as my head, and that's THICK!!! ;-)