Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

John Lucas - Threading jig?

Posts

John Lucas - Threading jig?

#1

John Lucas - Threading jig?

Galen Vetterick

John, on your 4/28 posting on a "Box Saved you made comments about trying a new threading jig. Did I miss a posting of what this new jig was? I'd be interested in learning what this was. I read Mike Peace's article in the American Woodturner issue on his home made jig and got excited till I read on his web site you may spend a lot of time and still not have a good rig. Looks like a lot of potential for too much runout to be effective. I'd sure like to find some reasonably priced unit for small boxes. Did you happen to do another fine Lucas production I could view? Hint Hint

Re: John Lucas - Threading jig?

#2

Re: John Lucas - Threading jig?

John Lucas

I have been playing with new threader from https://www.chefwarekits.com/ It's called the EZ-threader. Not ready to give a really full evaluation yet but will shortly. It is not the same quality as the Baxter threader. However it's half the price or more and has some interesting features. The first one I tested had some quality issues but he's working on those and seems eager to make it right.

The second one I got really seems like a decent machine although I just got it and haven't had time to actually use it yet.

The features I like. It fits in your tool post so with a very inexpensive change of tool post for length and size it will fit any lathe. Well I didn't ask him about the really oddball sizes of 3/4 and 1 1 /2 in tool posts but it can fit 1" and 5/8" which covers most lathes.

The second feature. You can swing it away from the cutter to test fit the mating lid or body. this I like a lot.

Then new one seems to have answered some of the issues with the first one so I won't mention them. It does have one minor draw back. The knob that feeds the box in to make the thread depth isn't marked. Not a big problem. Most of us have a permanant marker so we can add our own marks. I asked him to add these so we'll see if it's done.

I'll try to take the time to use it this weekend and take a photo to show how it works.

One thing I'm concerned about would be a major issue in metal working but so far it doesn't seem to be much of one if at all on the short section of threads we are doing. You have to align the tool parallel to the bed by eye. There isn't anything on the tool to help you. I put a contractors square (small one) against the back of the chuck and aligned the extended rule parallel to the bed by eye. It seemed to work. I got a great thread that mated well with the other thread.

I talked at length with Micheal Peace about this tool because he has one also. We've both given our input to the dealer. The changes would be very minor but would make it much easier to use. Mike and I have both threaded so many things it was easy to figure out fixes to the minor nits but someone who has never used one might have difficulty.

I did completely rewrite the instructions which were almost useless. Following my instructions you should be able to successfully make a threaded box.

Anyway stay tuned. He also has a very unique sphere turning jig that I just got to test as well. Will do that shortly also.

Re: John Lucas - Threading jig?

#3

Thanks John

Galen Vetterick

I had followed the link on Peace's site to this rig but it looked like alignment would always be a task. I thought if the threading screw had a machined center on both ends it would allow to set the post collar to center height by putting it between centers points in the headstock and tailstock. This would set it parrallel to the bed as well. If I made a lockable T-square that fit in the bed ways it would then allow me to move the bango in or out on the T face and always keep the screw parrallel. Moving any point along the bed would not change this either as long as it was always set tight to the T face.

I thought at one point it talked of putting the cutter in a Jacobs chuck but not sure mine would run as true as a, collet which I don't have.

I'll see how this developes.

Thanks

Re: John Lucas - Threading jig?

#4

Re: Thanks John

John Lucas

Galen You set the center height quite easily with a locking collar on the tool post. I just moved the banjo and EZ- threader up until the threaded block on the threader and my threaded spindle matched. Then I adjusted the locking collar on the tool post. This never changes.

What I was talking about was aligning the threads parallel to the ways. Once you move the tool rest you throw this off. I screw the chuck with the wood in it on the EZ-threader. Move it up so it touches or almost touches the cutter. Then I put the framing square on the back of the chuck and try to fine tune the alignemt so the back of the chuck perpendicular to the bed and the axis is aligned parallel to the bed ways. This should make your threads parallel to each other which is pretty essential if you want a good fitting lid.

Re: John Lucas - Threading jig?

#5

Swing away feature

Galen Vetterick

You noted the ability to swing the piece away to check the thread fit as a feature. Seemed like it is not a good feature if you need to recut threads for better fit cause by then you lost all the alignment haven't you? I know having one in hand is a lot better than me second guessing!

Is the threading spindle and the housing it runs in a good close thread fit and the chuck adapter once mounted true?

I guess if you made a lot of fancy adds or close tolerance fit it would end up at Baxter prices and don't think it is intended to be an equal is it.

I'll try to keep quiet till you do more review. ;)

Re: John Lucas - Threading jig?

#6

Re: Swing away feature

John Lucas

No you haven't lost the alignment. You just rotate it back into the cutter. you might need to rotate the 16TPI thread a little to get it to drop all the way to the bottom of the cutter but I was quite successful in taking a thread that fit a little snug and making it fit just right.

In theory if you do all your measurements very accurate, cut the wood very accurate, and align the cutter accurately you could simply make one pass with the threader and your threads will fit perfectly. OK, in the real world I find I like to test fit. You end up with a better fitting lid.

You can do test fits without rotating to the assembly but you have to screw the 16TPI lead screw way back and your limited in the size of the lid. You can do the same with the Baxter threader, the lead screw is much longer but you still have a limit. I understand that the new Baxter threader has the swing away option but I'll have to go visit Vic to see one to tell you for sure.

Re: John Lucas - Threading jig?

#7

Mike Peace

Re: John Lucas - Threading jig?

Mike Peace

I have not had a problem with visually lining up the EZ Threading jig. Seems like lining up this way would tend to cause problems but I have not found that to be the case. I tried your solution with the square, John, but for me I found it to be an unnecessary step.

When I bought the EZ Threading Jig direct from the manufacturer, it had an inferior cutter and you had to supply your own cutter. The US distributor solved this problem by including a commercial rotary cutter and a collet.

Re: John Lucas - Threading jig?

#8

Threading jigs *LINK*

Galen Vetterick

Mike I really enjoyed the AW article on your shop made jig or I would not still be wound up on threading. I just probably do not have the patience or equipment setups to make an accurate wood and metal unit on my own.

Based on this video I did not see any critical alignment setup for sure. But then I could not really see much. When he cut the box male threads it seems the video jumped over the cleanup of the threads to really make it fit.

I'd never try using the Jacobs chuck without a draw bar cause I know it would come loose on me for sure!

If I use it for small boxes and keep the thread fit loose then even if the mating pieces have tapers in the opposite directions for just a few threads it probably will fit. Woods used or fiber support on softer is probably a biger factor.

The only threads I have cut was with the help of two good friends using the Baxter for my burial urn. With their help I got a perfect fit first try. Helps when you have two experts showing me. :D


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N61K4OlwHCU&feature=player_embedded

Re: John Lucas - Threading jig?

#9

Re: Threading jigs

John Lucas

Ditto, do not use the jacobs chuck or #2 morse collets without a draw bar.

I wasn't happy with guessing at the thread depth. Obviously it worked for him but I found the feed screw to be .040" for one full turn. The proper thread depth for 16TPI is .035". If you adjust the cuttter until it just touches the wood and then crank the screw in or out about 7/8th of a turn ( or if you look at a clock face from 12 around to about 10, that's pretty darn close.

However that's why I like the swing out option. Again because we aren't machinist we aren't that accurate. Using my Baxter jig which is graduated in Thousandths, I find that a good fitting mating thread will be anywhere from .025" to about .035" So I like to cut it .025" check it and sneak up on a good fit. You can do this with the EZ threader by adjusting the knob about 3/4 of a turn and make a cut, swing it out and check the fit, adjust the cutter in from say 9 oclock to 10 oclock and make another pass. It works great and you get a reallly good fitting thread.

One of my complaints on the original unit was the slop in the dovetail. If you notice on the video every time he losens the top locking knob the chuck sinks a fair amount. So your guessing on the adjustment needed because you have to tighten the lock knob each time to bring the chuck back up and check it. It works, he made a good thread and so did I. It's just a little disconcerting after using the Baxter jig which is so precise. Of course comparing the two is a little unfair since the Baxter is twice as expensive but if you want quality then you pay for it. The EZ-threader is a very good value and does work.

Re: John Lucas - Threading jig?

#10

Mike Peace

Re: Threading jig video

Mike Peace

Looks like Allan got one of the early models as he was using one of the original shop made cutters. As I mentioned earlier it now comes with a 3/8" collet and a better rotary cutter.

I am with you, John, on the no need for that kind of approximate eyeball measuring on setting thread depth. It was an entertaining video, but I think it shows how weak the original instructions were. Instead of making the tenon "a little larger" than the recess, you make the tenon = female recess plus twice the thread depth. Barely touch the wood with the cutter, back the piece away and move the piece into the cutter one revolution of the cross slide and you should be right on the money!

I agree the Baxter (and Klein jig) is more refined. The analogy I would make is I wish I could afford a Robust but am quite happy with my PM3520 for what it cost me.