Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Munro 3/4" Shaft hollower (?s)

Posts

Munro 3/4" Shaft hollower (?s)

#1

Munro 3/4" Shaft hollower  (?s)

Jorge

I am making a vase using for the first time my new toy, :D a 3/4" shaft Munro hollower, it started easy but has gotten progressively harder when I get to the bottom of the cavity.


The closer I get to the axis, the more it shatters.

The piece is 14" and over 5" at the widest point and I am already 12" deep into it.

Could it be I am presenting the tool wrong? or 12" is already too much over hang?

I would like to go down one more inch just for the experience. At the center there, is a nib, maybe 3/16" at the tip and then it flares out to 3/4" about 3/4" tall.

I want to get rid of it and learn to get to the center without shatter.

I have been presenting the tool at about 45* angle then when I am getting close to the bottom, rotate the tool to horizontal and as I approach the center, rotate it further to the right.

Re: Munro 3/4" Shaft hollower (?s)

#2

Re: Munro 3/4" Shaft hollower  (?s)

John Lucas

I'm not familiar with that particular hollower but I have several that are on 3/4" bars. I get chatter starting about 10 to 12" on all of them. Light cuts and trying to cut either across or down hill with the grain helps a lot. When pushing straight into the end grain you will get maximum chatter. Use freshly sharpened tools and a light cut if you have to cut in that direction.

Getting rid of the nub in the center is just a matter of cutting exactly dead center and then move to the left or start off center and move back but the important thing is having the tip of the cutter at center height.

I did a hollow lamp that had to be 14" deep so I had to hollow to about 14 l1/2". That last 2 inches was painstakingly slow. When I took the class with Frank Sudol we used his big boring bars like the one Josh Bowman just bought. The were about 1 1/4" at the skinny end. I hollowed 14" vessels to less than 1/8" wall thickness almost effortlessly with those bars. Been wanting one ever since.

Re: Munro 3/4" Shaft hollower (?s)

#3

Dick Hines

Re: Munro 3/4" Shaft hollower  (?s)

Dick Hines

On a hollow form that deep a steady rest would help with the chatter. That is a deep hollow form so it would make no differance how big the bard was.

Re: Munro 3/4" Shaft hollower (?s)

#4

Re: Munro 3/4" Shaft hollower  (?s)

Jorge

Thanks John,

I have a 1" bar and have no trouble going 14" deep, once in a pinch had to make it go to 16" but same as you, it was painfully slow. Maybe I will some time get my friend the machinist to make me a thicker bar with a taper and provision to attach the Munro articulated cutter, a compromise but I will be making urns again.

It also cross my mind that a Forstner bit with a long shaft and a #2 Morse taper could save a lot of time and set the desired depth.

I should have started shaping the outside with it to learn how it cuts, but I went with my comfort zone, the skew...

Re: Munro 3/4" Shaft hollower (?s)

#5

Re: Munro 3/4" Shaft hollower  (?s)

Jorge

Thanks Dick,

Agree, it is a deep one and I do have a steady and use it, when doing the neck the steady is at the widest point, as soon as the neck is done the steady goes to the neck, it is steadier there and I can see the laser dot...

Re: Munro 3/4" Shaft hollower (?s)

#6

Re: Munro 3/4" Shaft hollower  (?s)

Josh Bowman

Jorge, I hollow a lot with a 3/4" bar and find it's hard to control at that depth. You may be ready to move to a bigger bar.

Re: Munro 3/4" Shaft hollower (?s)

#7

What lathe speed?

Dick Coers

When I use my Pro-Forme, I found that I wanted to turn MUCH slower than with the small scraper bits. Maybe 1/2 the speed. You still remove as much wood since the Pro-Forme makes a big chip. Try that and see if you like it better.

Re: Munro 3/4" Shaft hollower (?s)

#8

Re: Munro 3/4" Shaft hollower  (?s)

Jorge

You are right Josh,

After reading John's post I figured out that it flexes about 3/8" at 12"".

I did cheat and cleaned the bottom with my 1"" bar. Nice tool otherwise!

Re: Munro 3/4" Shaft hollower (?s)

#9

Re: What lathe speed?

Jorge

Dick,

I was using 700 rpm when I shaped the outside with the skew.

When I started hollowing it was too fast, the Munro tool has a cap over the cutter, so only a tiny sliver of the cutter is exposed, it does not self feeds into the work, it makes fine ribbons, seems happy at 300 rpm. I'll experiment and try even lower, say 200 rpm.

The Pro-Forme is a hook right? what speed are you using?

Re: Munro 3/4" Shaft hollower (?s)

#10

Re: What lathe speed?

Dick Coers

The Pro-Forme is a hook style, but it has a hood just like the Munro. I've never really checked what speed I turn, but I'm guessing 400-500. Your speed should be okay. I don't have mine set really fine, it takes a really nice curl. A lot of the time I have to use a hook to clear and break up the curls to clear them out of a hollow form.

Re: Munro 3/4" Shaft hollower (?s)

#11

May I Add:

George Guadiane

I have several Munro hollowers, including one I had put on a 3/4 inch shaft.

Rolly told me that chatter can be overcome to a large degree by changing the RPM.

Changing the rotational speed changes where the cutter hits the form. Using the same cutter at the same angle at the same speed makes the bumps we create bigger. Just changing the speed helps remove them

Go SLOWER and use lighter cuts. Close the guard down to make finer cuts then be patient. Once you have a smooth surface, keep the closed hood position and turn up the RPMs, I get good results doing this.

And lastly, adjust the cutter height, usually UP a bit as you get further in. As the shaft is extended over the rest, the downward flex becomes more significant. Less of a cut reduces the torque, slower rotational speed reduces the flex, combined (speaking for myself), I get smoother cuts at a greater depth.

With larger pieces with larger openings, I have one offset tool rest with a "J" curve on the end that I can insert inside the vessel. Doing that shortens the length over the tool rest and firms up/smooths out the cut.

I have also used my box tool rest to shorten the shaft distance over the rest.

I hope this helps