Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Size & Senses

Posts

Size & Senses

#1

Size & Senses

charlie belden

While in the "reading room", I came acrossed this quote in David Ellsworth's book, Ellsworth on Turning

"My pieces aren't as big as they were in the 1980s and 1990s - people seem to like big - but I'm not as young as I was then, either. I think my aesthetics has shifted from a sense of grandiosity that challenges the human scale to a more intimate relationship with that human scale."

That got me thinking.

You can turn BIG.

And you can turn for many decades.

But can you turn BIG for many decades?

Re: Size & Senses

#2

Re: Size & Senses

John Lucas

I would ask another question. Just because it's big is it good. I don't think so. My experience has been that many large turnings are just that, big. The don't necessarily have great form.

Also when you go to the symposium and see all the work I am often surprised how small it actually is. I think it's the illusion of the photo. We see it online and assume it's maybe 8, 10 or 12". When you see it in person it's 5 or 6". This is especially true if the piece is extremely well done with crisp fine details.

But to answer your question, I actually asked this a year or so. It suddenly occured to me one day the most turners are over 60 and even though I am strong enough now to hog a pretty good log p to the lathe I wanted to know how the older more feeble guys do it.

The answer was obvious. Leverage and hoists. If you couple that with a Captured bar system there isn't any reason you can't work as large as you want no matter what size and strength you are.

Re: Size & Senses

#3

Re: Size & Senses

John Veerkamp

I don't turn real big pieces- personal preference. I've seen many large pieces in shops and galleries. My general take on them is that they are impressive because of their size, not because of their quality. Probably an unfair generalization, but never the less.

I'm 70 and like John can still handle and turn as big a piece as I like. The largest blank I ever mount is about 35 lbs. Not huge but awkward to mount at times. Working smarter including using hoists and boring systems should extend my useful life.

I'm not sure whether my sensibilities have change as I mature(age) of my experiences in turning make me appreciate the extraordinary skill finely done pieces take. Counter intuitively, I think that imperfections and flaws show up more in smaller scale pieces.

My quick thoughts.

Re: Size & Senses

#4

Steven Antonucci

Why not?

steven antonucci

People define big differently, but sure.. why not?

John just said 35# was as big as he goes, and I think that would be a decent sized block of wood for most people, but is it big? I was thinking more like 100#...

Big is harder in every way (time, physical, cost, artistically), but more so, it creates issues with where to put the piece when you are done. If you made a big piece every month, you'd need to live in a museum!

Besides, who wants to clean this up every day?

S

Re: Size & Senses

#5

Rob Wallace

Just an observation.....

Rob Wallace

.....from working on the AAW EOG Auction Crew for the past 5-6 years or so.....

The pieces that recently brought the highest auction amounts have been among the SMALLEST being auctioned, or are of relatively small scale. Although big pieces sell too, the moderate-to-small scale items seem to sell better.

The collaborative pieces between Bonnie Klein and Jaques Vesery come to mind....Some of the small "top-boxes" (less than 5" in size) have brought selling prices of many thousands of dollars, far exceeding the physically larger items being sold at the same auction.

In this case "size doesn't matter" - In my opinion, what does matter is a well developed aesthetic concept for the piece, an obvious contribution by the artist(s) of their high level of technical and artistic abilities, and an impeccable attention to detail to be absolutely sure every part of the piece is finished to as high a level as possible.

In my own gallery sales, bigger pieces tend to "just sit there" while the "mid-size" pieces sell best. This may be attributable to the fact that most people just don't have the space to display larger pieces - my conclusion is also is supported based on comments from the gallery manager at one of the galleries I sell in. She says that identically-designed larger pieces of ceramics (which can be made as exact copies at different sizes) tend not to sell, even though the smaller pieces of the same shape, color, texture, etc. sell regularly to the point where replenishment requests for the pieces specify the size more than anything else. I generally don't make many large pieces very often, even though I have the ability to make them with the lathes I own. Larger pieces also take significantly longer to sand and finish, which does not necessarily translate into higher selling amounts for the piece, particularly given the economy and the general trends in buying mid-sized pieces.

Good thread Charlie!

Rob

Re: Size & Senses

#6

Re: Why not?

Don in Central Illinois

Do I see a live center point in there?

Re: Size & Senses

#7

Steven Antonucci

If you do, please circle it!


Re: Size & Senses

#8

Sure you can turn big for decades...

Dick Coers

You will be limited to physical endurance, but with proper bagging and caution to preserve the moisture in a wet piece during breaks, I think we can easily go for decades. I've gone almost 3 or those decades already. I'm just finishing an order for 8, 18" dia. x 6" bowls. It has been challenging at times to complete tasks before my hands get tired, especially the sanding. But with proper breaks, it has gone well. Another vote for large is based on some art shows I have been in. I'll do this 12" tall burl vessel, and then they place it on a pedestal in a cavernous hall with high ceilings. Get more than 8' away, and it looks like a dot over there. I'm going to go way bigger for a show in October, but can't decide if it will be wall art or a vessel. I better decide soon!

Re: Size & Senses

#9

Steven Antonucci

Nevermind 

steven antonucci


Re: Size & Senses

#10

Re: Just an observation.....

Wally Dickerman

My present lathe, which I've had for quite a few years, swings 24 inches. I have never turned anything larger than 12 inches on it. My previous lathe, a custom Nichols lathes had a swing of 38 inches. I turned a lot of big stuff on that. Not 38 inches however.

At my age handling big chunks of wood is limited to rolling them around on the floor to get then out of the way. Bigger is not necessarily better.

Re: Size & Senses

#11

Can you? YES, SHOULD you???

George Guadiane

I have a Powermatic 3520a. I turn larger pieces from time to time, but mostly "for fun," I don't expect to sell them. It seems (to me) that anything over about 16 inches in diameter SITS.

I'm sure that truly grand sized pieces will find homes, but those seem to be segmented vases that I LOVE to see, but doubt I will ever do the labor to produce.

It might seem "convenient" to switch to more intimate pieces, but I'm finding that people seem to enjoy picking the finished products up to examine them from more perspectives. Too big and they will rub the surface and move on to the pieces they can pick up. I have encouraged people to pick up a couple of my thin walled ogee shaped bowls, which have helped to get them sold.

For myself, I'm moving more toward embellishment and using "found objects" to make my pieces more distinctive.

I DO have a few BIG burl pieces that I'm certainly going to turn as large as I can, just because it is so uncommon to get them in these sizes, but otherwise? I'm content to make smaller things.

Re: Size & Senses

#12

Not Feeble - Smart

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

How to put 26x16x12 on the lathe so you can get knee-deep in curlies?


Easy! Drop the hook and hit the "up" button


[Harbor Freight - $60 + track & trolly = way cheaper than double-hernia surgery :D ]

Eventually it does get lighter but finding a table to hold it can be a lost cause:


Re: Size & Senses

#13

Steven Antonucci

Or cole jaws big enough to reverse it...


Re: Size & Senses

#14

Actually

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

an 8" vacuum chuck + 25 lbs of Hg ;)

Re: Size & Senses

#15

Jim Evans

Re: Actually

Jim Evans

Hg comes in inches not pounds.

Re: Size & Senses

#16

Rob Wallace

Re: Not Feeble - Smart

Rob Wallace

What are the details of the 'track and trolly' - cost and source.

Looks like a nice rig....

Rob

Re: Size & Senses

#17

B-F

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Thanks for the get.

Re: Size & Senses

#18

Specs

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

winch - Harbor Freight Special 880lbs. model on sale . . $60.

1 7' section barn door round track from Agway . . $25

2 track end-caps +2 3" 1/4x20 bolts . . $3.00

2 barn door track trolly sets @ $18 . . $36

2 # 10x2 flat-head screws for each overhead joist.

Re: Size & Senses

#19

Rob Wallace

Thanks!!

Rob Wallace

I printed everything you posted and will probably add this to my summer shop improvement projects.... we have a Harbor Freight in Des Moines and our Theisen's in town sells barn door hardware. All local places and easy to obtain stuff.

Much appreciated Mark!

Rob

Re: Size & Senses

#20

Keith Tompkins

Re: Not Feeble - Smart

Keith Tompkins

Mark...I like!

Re: Size & Senses

#21

Re: Actually

charlie belden

Unless you're buying Hg, in which case it's sold by weight or sometimes by volume. But in the case of measuring atmospheric pressure it's inches or mm of Hg.

Let's see - 30" of Hg supported by the atmosphere is about 14.7 lb/sq in.. So 25" of Hg works out to about 12 1/4 PSI.

The fact that we take breathing for granted. . . It's actually pretty amazing when you think about it.

Re: Size & Senses

#22

Re: Just an observation.....

Keith Newton

Rob, I think your last paragraph sums it up well. I can turn 7' diameter on my big lathe, if I could find wood of that dimensions worth the effort, but just have a hard time selling the larger works. When you get into that scale, you need a Artist rep, or interior designer to double your price for two minutes of his or her time to insist that the client needs it.

As for handling the rough blanks, I bought a HF shop engine crane back when I built my lathe, just to manage lifting the parts. It weighs 3000 #, and the crane also comes in handy for large blanks, or moving other large equipment pieces which need moving. Being on casters, it can go anywhere in the shop, lift almost anything, then let it down onto beans across the legs, to steady, then rolled around, to lift or let down. Under $200 at HF also.We have even pulled 3 truck engines, as a side benefit.

One thing the buying public doesn't seem to understand, is the physics shift as you increase size. While it is true that with each doubling of diameter, there is a doubling of circumference, but there is a quadrupling of area in that circle. Then if there is a doubling of height, then that is double that.

Then as you get on up, with each doubling, I think the centrifugal force quadruples also, so the RPM's need to drop, because the tensile strength of wood is the weakest, so flinging it apart is a huge risk. Halving the RPM's may be fine out from the middle for pretrial speed, but really sucks for clearing out the middle. Then add to that voids in a large piece, which can through a large blank out of balance, and the RPM's need to be reduced even more. These things get painful up around 36" diameter, and when you consider the risk of loosing 1/4 of a 300# sphere at any RPM, makes one question their sanity.

Not only that, but I require 4 parts leverage on my side of the tool rest for one part on the other, so the tools need to be larger. Then inertia is a major player when you start getting on up there. A major snag has a different meaning on that scale. You realize, that when something goes wrong, instead of going OH S**�� , that was scary, it is a lot worse than just scary.

Re: Size & Senses

#23

Steven Antonucci

Finally, someone that big means big!


Re: Size & Senses

#24

Engine Hoist?

George Van Beynen

I use a Harbor Freight engine hoist. It also serves as an adjustable vacuum arm. I use it for lifting a lot of items, engines to loading heavy blanks into the truck, especially when the Bobcat can't get there. The hoist is not very expensive on sale.








Re: Size & Senses

#25

Leo Cuellar

Re: Engine Hoist?

Leo Cuellar

I love the tire chain cradle! Might get some use out of those chains yet, as it never snows too heavily around here any more. :D