Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Does the AAW track turning incidents?

Posts

Does the AAW track turning incidents?

#1

Steven Antonucci

Does the AAW track turning incidents?

steven antonucci

With all of the dialog on "safety", I was just wondering if there was any data to support any of the claims?

Interested in:

Last year, how may AAW sanctioned events had incidents where an injury was reported?

What types of injuries were reported? Were they to turners or viewers?

I know that there have been some minor injuries in one of my clubs (nicks on sharp edges, one guy WATCHING woodturning without safety glasses got a scratch on his eye from an errant chip). Is it dumb luck, or is it just not happening?

Does anyone have an injury at an AAW event to report?

Steve

P.S. My only accident at a demo was kicking over my bucket of water that I used to quench hot steel. I had to finish the demo in a wet pair of pants.

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

#2

AAW

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Steve,

I'm quite sure that you can get that information from the AAW in Minneapolis faster and more accurately than on this forum which, all due respect to its members/denizens, will be second or third hand, at best.

If you need contact numbers, go to the AAW website.

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

#3

Steven Antonucci

I asked a general question and a specific one

steven antonucci

The general question was:

Has anyone on this specific forum ever been at an AAW sanctioned event and seen a demonstrator or attendee hurt as a result of a "lathe accident?"

I have probably been to over 100 demos, meetings, classes and such... and outside of minor nicks and the occasional chip of wood, I've never seen one? I am not saying that there haven't been any... only that I suspect that they are rare, even given the lack of any standardized and practiced safety precautions.

My specific question about tracking issues was:

Does the AAW count incidents? If I was looking to instill change in behavior in an organization whereby I didn't actually have control over what happened, I would try to approach it via education (I've mentioned this once or twice :D) Good solid data across the breadth of membership can tell you what works and what doesn't. Both of the deaths that I have heard about involving lathes were rumored to have had turners who were wearing face shields. It would be great if there was some measurement of the lives that were save (or catastrophic injuries that were prevented) by face shield.

Data> opinion.

S

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

#4

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

Dick Coers

In the insurance hoopla, didn't they say that a claim had never been made?

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

#5

Generally Speaking

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

AAW would be the place for that information.

Specifically Speaking, the only symposium accident that I'm aware of was the one in San Jose where David Ellsworth got face-whacked by a loose chunk during his demo. He wasn't hurt, however, being that he was wearing a shield.

Predictively Speaking, I will posit that you won't find any evidence, other than random anecdotal single stories, of people who were saved by safety equipment as people would tend to report only injuries.

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

#6

Steven Antonucci

Precisely my point

steven antonucci

While I do not dispute that wearing a face shield is good practice for beginners and certain activities like roughing out, I'd also suspect that those are the areas that most accidents occur and that wearing a face shield after one has developed their skills or roughed to round has little effect on whether or not one will be injured.

If you think about all of the demos that have ever gone on in all of the events ever thrown, statistically, if accidents were common, we'd have turners bleeding all over and nobody would debate the effect. However, I will contend that most of the accidents are avoided by demo turners being out of the line of fire, because we all know that wood and bark flying is common. Even then, still haven't heard of a single case of a spectator.

I know that the only time a face shield ever saved me should have never happened, because I was standing directly in the line of fire turning a platter that I knew had a big split in it. I might as well have tattooed a bulls eye on my forehead.

Without the data to prove that face shields save turners, I still submit that it is an old wives tale. I would bet that in some cases, they provide a false sense of security that encourages people to stand in the line of fire (I've actually seen this too many timed to count.)

S

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

#7

Steven Antonucci

I agree...but root cause analysis would show...

steven antonucci

that most of the accidents that are prevented by wearing a face shield are caused by something avoidable in the first place. Rather than focusing on what type of head gear, why not focus on where the line of fire is and basic physics?

Personally, I'd rather not get hit at all than hit wearing a face shield. I wear a face shield if I have used CA glue, because it does protect me against the glue getting in my eye (again) or sprayed against my face, but face shields (notably, the cheap ones) are really designed for much more than that, yet we keep hearing that "you need a face shield to be safe!"

Rather than repeating this mantra, why not look at something that might actually be useful and protect a turner? $10 at Home Depot flip down check-the-box face shield is nothing more than lip service.

S

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

#8

Re: Precisely my point

Dale Bonertz

With this last paragraph I have to comment.

"Without the data to prove that face shields save turners, I still submit that it is an old wives tale. I would bet that in some cases, they provide a false sense of security that encourages people to stand in the line of fire (I've actually seen this too many timed to count.)"

Steve, I rough turn an awful lot of bowl blanks. My face shield has saved me many times from flying piece of bark or weak (small) chunk of wood that separated from an unseen defect such as bark inclusion. I turn left handed when roughing and I stand well out of the line of fire. This idea that wood, bark and etc. only travels in the line of fire is BS. Nine out of ten times it does but the tenth time it may ricochet and hit you. I think turners stand in the line of fire because they have not taught themselves how turn left handed or turn without being in the line rather then I am wearing a face shield so I am safe attitude.

I worked in wood window and door manufacturing for 11 years. I saw some pretty horrific accidents and not all were due to operator error. There are things as equipment error, parts defect while fabricating and etc. I have first hand witnessed face shields on several occasions save peoples faces while in this business. 20 to 30 years ago, when I was in this business, face shields were not even as good as what you can get today. Yes I believe in face shields, yes I believe a cheap face shield is better than nothing, yes I believe one stands a better chance of surviving and accident with one than without and yes I believe with even a heavier object you stand a better chance of survival and the piece deflecting with a curved surface covering your face than none. These beliefs are based on actual experience in manufacturing and not just some guy who wants to think he has analyzed it and comes to the conclusion there is no way they will help.

Sorry for the mini rant but the face shield issue should not even be an issue - wear them. Having said that I understand when people like Mr. Lucas says he can't wear them because they give him head aches. I don't however buy the lines they get dirty, so do safety glasses if you're wearing them. I don't think that wood juice is discriminate to face shields and not glasses and it is probably easier to clean a larger shield surface than the safety glasses. I am compassionate with him getting head aches, I can't wear powered respirators because I have neck issues and the pain. I also have something with my eyes that when I wear safety glasses they fog up and I can't see. I have tried several brands and styles with the same issues. I think it is because of the side shields trap moisture, which my eyes evidently produce a lot. So in conclusion the only thing worse than NOT wearing safety glasses or face shields is wearing them and having them become more of a danger than without. In other words use them unless they make things more dangerous.

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

#9

Re: Precisely my point

Barry L Elder

I don't understand why you haven't inquired of the Insurance Company involved with the AAW as to the prevalence of claims filed.

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

#10

Betty Scarpino

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

Betty Scarpino

As far as I know, the AAW does not keep records of woodturning injuries.

Do you think they should? And, if so, why?

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

#11

Re: Precisely my point

Dale Gillaspy

To my knowledge, there is no accurate count for several reasons.

1. Individual clubs would have to report each incident including "near misses" which are much more prevalent than actual injuries. I doubt that is happening. There would also have to be someone to collect and collate that information.

2. The insurance company would only have a list of claims filed, not the near misses or minor injuries that are more common.

Another point to make is that face shields are face protection, not eye protection. Eye and respiratory protection still need to be worn, and I would submit take priority, over face shields, unless you are wearing a system that is sealed around the face and also provides a filter/clean air supply.

The bottom line is that the AWA can mandate safety equipment if you are turning at one of their sanctioned events. Beyond that, it is a personal choice, much like motorcycle helmets (at least in my state). The only other time safety equipment can be mandated is in the case of an employer/employee relationship because federal law (OSHA) gets involved.

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

#12

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

Dale Gillaspy

It would be an interesting statistic to have to see where people are getting in trouble and where more education in safety is needed.

However, it would be a very difficult one to track for several reasons that I outlined in my other message.

You would be relying on volunteer clubs, some with very small memberships, to volunteer information to convey that information. Many will interpret "near miss" differently, and many clubs will be hesitant to relay the information, or just won't see the need. With out any fear of reprisals, there is no compelling reason for them to do so.

OSHA has very strict regulations on what has to be reported, and things still go unreported and swept under the table.

As a firefighter with a 20 year career in safety and OSHA compliance, I have been working on an article on shop fire safety to submit to the journal, but have stalled because it is very difficult to find accurate statistical information.

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

#13

Mike Stafford

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

Mike Stafford

First of all those injured would have to report the injuries and just how many of us do that. We all occasionally see someone who posts a battered finger or a bloodied bump on the head. We also hear of the very worst injuries where things go terribly wrong and loss of life results. It seems most of the horrific injuries are as a result of wood defects or poor wood selection. When you see these pieces posted on every forum with huge voids it makes you wonder what a novice is going to do when they try to turn such a piece of wood without all the safety equipment and facts needed.

Generally woodturning is a safe aspect of the woodworking hobby. If it were not it would not be growing as it is.

I don't believe the AAW should keep these statistics. If they are available in some centralized location the government or some insurance institute will grab hold of them and OSHA will show up at every demo. Trust me you don't want that. We will be out of the symposium and demonstration business when they do.

The best thing the AAW, every demonstrator and every woodturning teacher can do is to teach and model good woodturning safety. Magazines should be careful to examine photos and the description of techniques to assure that no dangerous habits or methods are portrayed.

There is nothing that can be done to protect everyone from everything that can happen to them.

What did the old sargeant say to his officers as they were about to hit the streets on Hill Street Blues: "Let's be careful out there!"

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

#14

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

Dale Gillaspy

Well, I disagree on a few issues...

First, OSHA has no authority over demo issues. OSHA (and any state entity thereof) only has authority where an employer/employee relationship exists. It does not have authority in your home shop, (Unless you hire someone to work or finish for you, then it is a whole different story). It does not have authority when you are turning at a club event or symposium. You are not an employee, you are an independent contractor.

An exception might exist if, for example, Linda Ferber, who is on staff for the AWA, were to turn at an exhibition as a part of her job. Anyone else who demos at a symposium does so as an independent contractor, not an employee. If the AWA or it's insurance provider sets a requirement to use certain safety equipment, it is a private matter between them and the demonstrator.

As far as insurance companies are concerned, they are private entities and do not have the right to statistical data compiled by private entities like the AWA.

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

#15

Mike Stafford

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

Mike Stafford

Dale, you say all that with such certainty but it has been my experience that the government can find a way to get involved in anything it wishes to stick its overly large nose.

Just a few years ago they got involved in table saw safety so there is nothing to prohibit them from doing what they wish to do.

Insurance companies who insure the venues where these activities take place might decide they will not provide liability coverage for such an event. If an accident were to occur during such an event the venue can become part of the suit.

This actually happened at an event that I attended. A woman lost her footing on some loose gravel that was on the parking area, fell and broke her hip. Guess who was sued? The folks putting on the event and the building owners where the event was held. It was settled out of court much as Mark Mandell suggested most suits are but the owner of the building which we had used for many years to hold the event would no longer allow us to use the facility. The accident was not related in any way to our event except the woman was there to see it. Nevertheless she sued all parties and won and we lost our event site. Not only did we lose that one building but it became nearly impossible for us to rent another site because of the stigma attached to us by the lawsuit.

All it would take is for an accident to occur at some coliseum where a symposium is being held that resulted in grievous injury and a lawsuit and before long the word would be out that there was too much risk for the owners of the facility.

I know it seem crazy that these things can happen but they do.

P.S. Insurance companies do share liability information. They might not march into AAW headquarters and take it but it could be subpoenaed during a law suit if it thought to exist.

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

#16

Common sense over statistics

Mike Brazeau

I have seen enough facial accidents posted on the various WT forums and club newsletters over the last ten years that I don't need any statistical report to convince me. When the fellow in Waterdown, Ontario which is 15 minutes from where I live, died 4 years ago from an undisclosed woodturning accident, that was the wakeup call for me to wear the faceshield virtually 100% of the time. Prior to that I will admit that many times I did not. I find the old AO Safety, now 3M, blue helmet with polycarbonate shield an effective and reasonably priced version. Sold by Industrial suppliers I am sure in most cities. You buy insurance because you hope you never need it. Same thing for a faceshield, you wear it because you hope you will never have the biggy. Every time a chip or piece of bark hits it and not my face I am thankful for it.

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

#17

A polling might shed some light

mjonesrdg

Other forums that I visit have a "Poll" function. Here, a well thought out poll might shed a bit of light, though it would not be conclusive, regarding the prevalence and type of injury sustained while at the lathe. For example: How many hours spent at the lathe...per week/month....total lifetime estimate.

How many hours lost to lathe associated injuries....estimate lifetime?

What percent of your lathe-hours is spent with face shield in place?

Could be interesting!

I'd be interested to know: How many time have you spat.... forgetting that your face shield was covering your spitter? (I hope I'm not the only one!)

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

#18

Y'all Might

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

wanna take a break from "chew" whilst yer a'turnin' wood, wuddiyathank? :D

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

#19

A face shied is cheap insurance

Ron Sardo

One day while you are turning, its gonna hit you why you should be wearing one.

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

#20

Alan Zenreich

Re: Common sense over statistics

Alan Zenreich

I don't know why anyone would want to know the numbers of accidents.

There are those of us who don't care about the numbers, because we know that it's our obligation to protect ourselves and our loved ones as best we can.

There are those whose behavior would not change, regardless of the numbers or horrific photos, because they consider themselves to be so skilled as to avoid accidents. The "it won't happen to me, because I'm soooo good" attitude is not likely to be swayed by the statistics, old wives tales... and often not by first hand experience.

So it's just an argument for argument's sake.

I find it odd that so many parents require their kids to wear bicycle helmets, but the parents don't wear them.

Professional bicyclists wear helmets... they know what's at stake.

I envy those people who can predict when an accident won't happen to them. I'm not one of them, so it's ATGATT for me when working around machinery.

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

#21

Mike Stafford

Only one reminder for me......that was enough!


Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

#22

Steven Antonucci

Changing culture starts with education

steven antonucci

I used to sell corporate change management solutions, and all of our experts used to tell me that change was the hardest thing to deal with for most organizations, but there was an easy way to assure a win. The following formula will get you there:

1.) Executive Sponsorship. If the people leading the change are not truly behind it, change will never happen. In AAW parlance, if I can go to YouTube and point to 10 well known turners in various AAW sponsored events not wearing a face shield, why the heck should I wear one? AAW needs to get it's leaders to adopt the change first... and then

2.) Build a communication plan that begins with education. If people do not understand why the change is important (to them), they will not adopt it. If people hear a message enough, and from the right people (the ones that influence them), they start to believe it.

3.) Lastly, make sure that change is measured and communication continues. If you do not sustain, people will revert back to old habits.

The AAW has been saying that "turning without a face shield is dangerous" for years, but then having events with well known though leaders in the field undermining the message. While I personally believe that most face shields are more protection against nuisance chips than more serious injury, I am also very data driven.

If there was data that said there were 200 injuries reported to the AAW last year where turners required stitches, perhaps someone could present the data at the annual symposium in the safety session. It would be interesting to see how many people would be interested in such a dry topic, but it could certainly be broadened and repeated annually as a service to the membership.

Steve

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

#23

Betty Scarpino

Re: Changing culture starts with education

Betty Scarpino

Steve, is it really true that you are not a member of the AAW?

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

#24

Steven Antonucci

I agree with you

steven antonucci

There is a line that you cross when a face shield is no longer protection, but damage control.

I will put a shield on for roughing out bowls because bark does behave differently than wood, and a face shield is an effect method for keeping nuisance chips out of your face. I never am cutting off "big chunks" nor roughing at a speed that would cause me concern even if I did take a direct hit. I may get a nick or a bruise, but nothing lethal.

A face shield does distribute impact across a broader area, which will lessen the localized injury. It still hurts like hell, but rather than getting cut, it is more like a slap in the face. You should never throw a chunk of wood off the lathe that "slaps" you hard enough to knock you unconscious, and a face shield offer almost no protection in this scenario, since the blunt force impact may do damage, but you also now have the issue of falling to the ground and potentially hitting your head against the lathe, the floor, etc.

So, I agree with you that face shields do provide an additional layer of protection against some injury types, but I am not convinced that they are saving lives.

I am not anti-face shield. I just do not use them all of the time. To your credit, I see that you practice what you preach and I commend you for that:


Steve

Re: Does the AAW track turning incidents?

#25

Steven Antonucci

yeah...

steven antonucci

Some good things, but too much drama for my taste.

Steve