Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

How thin to turn a lid

Posts

How thin to turn a lid

#1

How thin to turn a lid

John Lucas

I think I got this one a little too thin. It was fine until I hit it lightly with 220 grit sandpaper. Then I heard something funny and saw a streak of color. Bummer. Oh well. I also didn't wax the mating surfaces of the lid and body and can't unscrew it so even if I had not gone through the lid it might be a loss. Normally on these screw lid boxes I wax the threads and mating surfaces to make them screw on easier and screw off easier. This one might as well be glued in place.

Re: How thin to turn a lid

#2

Mike Stafford

I have never turned a lid or a body too thin....

Mike Stafford

since the last time I did it which was probably in March when I trashed a beautiful piece of mesquite by making the inside and outside diameters of the body of a box the same.

Re: How thin to turn a lid

#3

Re: How to turn a lid

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

How do you "fix" your lid to hollow it?

I've taken to using a jamb chuck and hot-melt glue and this makes it pretty easy to avoid your kind of casualty. I put tape and 2 marked rings on the outside of the chuck representing the center and the hidden part of the lid profile. I can then use my laser to accurately gauge the lid's thickness. Haven't gone through one yet (since using this method ;) )

Re: How thin to turn a lid

#4

Steven Antonucci

More hollow than solid.

steven antonucci

Inside> outside

Zero thickness.

I crush these so I don't get tempted to fix them or spend a lot of time thinking about fixing them. Usually, as it happens, with the lathe still spinning and a quick strike of the handle of whatever is closest. While voicing profanity.

Be done with it.

Steve

Re: How thin to turn a lid

#5

Mike Stafford

Re: How to turn a lid

Mike Stafford

When I turn a box I turn a tenon/spigot on each end of the blank. Then I part the blank into two pieces determining where to part based upon the design proportions I am aiming for on a particular box.

Then I chuck up the lid by the tenon/spigot and hollow and shape the underside of the lid forming square shoulders for the lid to overfit a tenon on the body of the box.

When all this is done I carefully mark the depth of the hollowing in the underside of the lid on the exterior of the lid blank and use that to gauge thickness when I jam fit the lid on the body for finish turning.

I don't usually have lid problems unless there is an unseen crack or something. I tend to get carried away while hollowing the body and make it too thin.

Re: How thin to turn a lid

#6

Re: How to turn a lid

John Lucas

Mark I hollow the lid before installing it on the box. Then I turn the lid and box together. I can't ever remember that I have done this before. It was actually just a practice piece testing a new threading machine and the top was thinner than usual. I didn't think it was that thin however. I would have been OK but in rushing the box I made a force cut across the top and left a tiny bit of tearout. I made 2 more shallow passes to remove the tearout and that was probably my error.

Re: How thin to turn a lid

#7

Me neither

Dale Miner

I have a wood stove though and sometimes practice on the wood before tossing it in. :D

Re: How thin to turn a lid

#8

Re: How thin to turn a lid

Bob Macgregor

Well, how else were you going to get into the box if the threads were jammed?

Re: How thin to turn a lid

#9

Exactly Bob and saves on Glue


Re: How thin to turn a lid

#10

Re: How thin to turn a lid

robo hippy

Keep it on the lathe and hollow out a contrasting plug for it. Might be difficult to turn out the inside again.

Which threading jig do you have?

robo hippy

Re: How thin to turn a lid

#11

I use the Baxter Jig and highly recommend it

John Lucas

I was sent a much less expensive unit to test and I'm still playing with it. It needs some improvements both in the unit and the literature. I will be passing my suggestions on to the maker. I think it has possibilities. It will never be a BAxter threader but it's like driving a Ford vs A Mercedese. You can have a tool that will get the job done with some limitations and maybe not as accurately or you can have a real precision instrument. You of course pay for the precision, so there is a place for this tool if they work out some bugs.