Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Time Lapse Motion - in 3D

Posts

Time Lapse Motion - in 3D

#1

Time Lapse Motion - in 3D

charlie belden

"The purpose of art is to let others see or hear or feel or taste or smell - in a way it has not before been experienced."

With computer 3D modeling programs now readily available and affordable (some are FREE) AND easier to use than AutoCAD or AutoDesk, creating virtual 3D objects can now be done by anyone with a computer. There are even computer programs - or should I call them APPS - that will convert mathematical equations into 3D surfaces. 3D scanners and apps that can generate virtual 3D models of objects from still photos of the object are becoming more affordable and available. Throw in more and more affordable 3D printers and viritual models of existing objects can now be "printed" in actual 3D.

When photo film got sensitive enough to capture a sequence of images of a running horse (to settle a bet about whether a running horse's feet were ALL off the ground at one time while running) we could now SEE what we couldn't see before.

There are now 3D scanners that can scan fast enough to capture moving objects. And from the scanned data, 3D models can be created - and then - using a 3D printer - print an actual 3D object of a moving object.

Duchamp's Nude Descending a Staircase showed basically a cubist version of a series of time lapsed photos.

Now 3D scanners are fast enough to capture the motion of moving 3D objects - like a dancer for instance. For the first time one can see a dance as a scultpure in space - and time - changing how dance may be seen. One must wonder what a time lapsed 3D model of part of a Martha Graham performance would look like - and how it would change the experience of seeing the performance.


Now if something similar for sounds and colors could be developed - and made available.

Re: Time Lapse Motion - in 3D

#2

100 Years Ago

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Umberto Boccioni tried to do that. This piece "Unique Forms Of Continuity In Space"


was inspired by the blurred motion/stop-action of multi-exposure photographic images showing various stages of a given movment.

Re: Time Lapse Motion - in 3D

#3

Steven Antonucci

The coming storm...

steven antonucci

With 3-D printing, there comes a fair amount of coolness, like what you've done, but also, a fair amount of chaos.

There is a kid who printed a functioning AR-15 that fired a handful of rounds before it broke. What happens when you download a plan to manufacture your own parts, and the parts fail causing injury? What happens when you can make an exact replica of something that isn't yours?

I wish I knew...I'd be buying stocks right now.

Steve

Re: Time Lapse Motion - in 3D

#4

Alan Zenreich

Re: The coming storm...

Alan Zenreich

Steve would likely start printing hook tools...

Re: Time Lapse Motion - in 3D

#5

40 Years Ago

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

There was a firm started in New York called the Studio for Solid Photography. They used laser grids and CNC routing units to scan and then replicate what was billed as perfect likeness portraits which the customer could then have done in bronze, or various resins, or marble. The idea was to put the portrait sculptors out of business with photo-real quality.

Portraitists are still working. The company went broke

Fear not the storm. It too shall pass. We haven't gotten to the Replicator stage yet. ;)

Re: Time Lapse Motion - in 3D

#6

So right Steve, and it's just around the corner


Re: Time Lapse Motion - in 3D

#7

Re: The coming storm...

charlie belden

To clarify, I didn't do the pieces in the photo I provided. The image was a screenshot taken from a video of a talk by a cutting edge designer on the impact of 3D modeling, scanning and printing on art, architecture, manufacturing, etc.. A scanning studio was scanning dancers to create 3D models for a client. When the photo shoot was over, just fooling around, they scanned dancers as they moved to see what their capture rate was - and got what you see in the images I provided. Playing often leads to discoveries.

I've been very interested in 3D modeling, scanning and printing and can see just some of what's coming. Looking ahead a decade or two is a carry over from my career as a transportation forecaster, looking out 20 years - the forecasting field now called Futurists.

I first thought of 3D modeling, scanning and printing as a means for 3D artists to make and sell limited editions of their work and make them more accessible to folks who don't have a lot of money to spend on art work. This idea is not new, Ansel Adams used it quite effectively - and Bathsheba Grossman (see thread "If Foster and Fennel Collaborated) is doing affordable limited edition 3D jewelry, done with 3D printers - in metal. Of course, initially, Adams and other photographers' work - and doing limited editions - was seen as cheating - not really art. But with time, that changed - as will the use of limited edition "printed" objects.

What I didn't see is that 3D modeling and printing would allow for the creation of 3D objects that would be impossible to do with prior methods and technology.

Mike Foster's "minimal surfaces" series of turnings (and a bit of carving) and Derek Weiderman's multiple axes pieces push the limits of what can be done on a lathe from a single piece of wood. But once an artist can SEE what's possible now - I suspect turners will come up with ways to do things we now think of as impossible.

We live in interesting times - and things keep getting more and more interesting

Re: Time Lapse Motion - in 3D

#8

An Attempt

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Hi Charlie,

I actually tried to do a very similar piece while in grad school. Picking up on the 72' Olympics, I tried to do a piece based upon a gymnast's floor exercise by doing the "pose" (landing a flip) as the final image and then working up 6-12 "before images" in a stream behind the final. The idea was to do the figure in bronze, and then the "befores" cast in clear resin with decreasing amounts of tint like fading after-images. The idea crashed because there was no way to merge the elements while keeping each a complete image unto itself. Each stage in the progression had to be partly inside the next in line while at the same time having parts of both the next and the prior stage inside it. The optics of the "connections" between the elements became quite impossible, let alone the technical physical requirements for the many molds that would be required to make the component parts. By using the afterimage idea, I was trying to avoid the visual confusion that plagues Boccioni's piece in that the viewer cannot find the unified figure in the conglomeration of the solid parts.

What was so easy to do with a camera and film to make an image proved to be quite impossible when translated into solid form.

Re: Time Lapse Motion - in 3D

#9

PS: But

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

don't let my inability to solve the issues dissuade you from trying. If you'd like to discuss the wall I hit, shoot me a PM; you have the address. :)

Re: Time Lapse Motion - in 3D

#11

Big Effort

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

but it is, like the 3D "prints" posted by Charlie, still a static construct comprised of the outside surface(s) nearest to the viewer which hides the structure that was used to "make" that surface. As a portrayal of movement, it may actually be too much of a good thing, meaning too many parts in the composite. It has become a representation of the surface formed by movement of the body through space rather than a representation of the body's actual movement. Simplistic example is the difference between a ball moving through space and the surface it creates in doing so. On the one hand you have a ball + motion. On the other you have a static rod (or tube) formed by the outside surface of the ball as it moved.

It is, naturally, difficult to analyze any complex 3D object from a photograph, but my impression is that it would be more effective with half (probably more) of the "segments" removed to allow space between some body parts when "moving" through the arcs; not a viable alternative using sand as the medium.

Re: Time Lapse Motion - in 3D

#12

Steven Antonucci

So you want a strobe effect?


Re: Time Lapse Motion - in 3D

#13

Not I

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I looked for a concrete moment in time (as all images are) coupled with an exploration of the past and at least one possible future. The dynamic of the uncompleted movement will always contain more visual energy than a completed one, as it has the ability to visually predict continuation of the depicted movement. The movement and its representation needs a starting point and our ability to perceive that the object in question has moved from point A to H. That perception depends upon how clearly we can see points B through G as part of the progression. A though G need not be as "concrete" as H (as would result from the use of a strobe), but they need to be seen.

I didn't say it was easy. :D

Re: Time Lapse Motion - in 3D

#14

SCI FI Fan?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Catch the Vin Diesel flick "Chronicles of Riddick" (been playing on HBO lately) and watch for the representations of movement by the "Lord Marshall" [super bad dude] character. ;)

Re: Time Lapse Motion - in 3D

#15

Steven Antonucci

Multiple points of view, I suppose

steven antonucci

The stationary (photo)

The Strobe (sand castle)

Moving (movies, other)

I guess it all depends upon what you are trying to show. Half the fun is figuring out how to get from point A to point B...

Steve

Re: Time Lapse Motion - in 3D

#16

The Eadweard Muybridge "Animal .......

JamieDonaldson

...Locomotion" series was a significant work in my early studies of horses in motion many years ago. Since I made my living "shooting" horses for 33 yrs. his book was an early "bible" for my education. ;)

Re: Time Lapse Motion - in 3D

#17

Very Different Points of View

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I worked at establishing the gesture in a given movement, looking for the single place along the progression through space that best (in my judgment) communicated that motion. A piece became a matter of precise balance, both visual and physical, and the interpretation and distortions of anatomy I worked out were used to reinforce those qualities.

What Charlie and you were showing is all stages of the motion used to create an object that shows the entire progression; in the case of the sand piece, the object formed by progression through an entire yoga exercise. The figure itself becomes quite secondary to the result, just as the ball becomes secondary to the tube in my other example. The result becomes an exercise in abstraction with the exercise concept as its progenitor.