Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Quick tip for turning thin spindles(Charlie et al)

Posts

Quick tip for turning thin spindles(Charlie et al)

#1

Steven Antonucci

Quick tip for turning thin spindles(Charlie et al)

steven antonucci

Was looking at Charlie's spindle turning, and I assumed that he was turning between centers because it is easier to move centers. However, digging back through my mechanical engineering courseware, I recalled this little tidbit.

To reduce vibration, a fixed point on the headstock (aka a chuck) provides a rigid mechanical contact point and moves the load point further towards the tailstock (vs. the center of the length). Whenever practical, a chuck on one end will produce less vibration than a center point.

Steve

Re: Quick tip for turning thin spindles(Charlie et al)

#2

Re: Quick tip for turning thin spindles(Charlie et

John Lucas

Boy do I agree with that. Not only that but the beefier the chuck that holds the spindle end the better. I did a 3 day demo on making ornaments for the Craft Center a few years ago. I think I was using a Oneway chuck with small jaws furnished by them. I brought my Vicmarc chuck back the next day with the beefy extended jaws and could not believe how much it reduced the chatter out at the loose end of the finial. I also have the standard extended jaws that Vicmarc sells and they aren't as good as the older extened jaws.

Re: Quick tip for turning thin spindles(Charlie et al)

#3

Re: Quick tip for turning thin spindles(Charlie et

charlie belden

While what you stated is certainly true, it couldn't be used for this piece because it was turned on six axes, only one of which was on the centerline of the blank. Multiple Axes turning presents challenges that you don't have to consider when turning on a single axis. Takes more planning, both in terms of placing the centers to get the desired result and then the turning sequence, which, in this case was an iterative process - turn everything and then start tuning the proportions.



Multiple Axes turning is a lot more challenging than single axis turning.

Re: Quick tip for turning thin spindles(Charlie et al)

#4

Steven Antonucci

More from the archives

steven antonucci

John-

You are correct about the mass also dampening vibration, but it is not what I originally meant.

A chuck mechanically attaches the one end of the piece to the system. A point center does not. It is the mechanical attachment that reduces the bending capability of the spindle. I graduated 25 years ago this June, so this is about as deeply as I can dive on the topic without relearning it, but it is 100% qualitatively accurate, even if I can no longer remember the formulas or handle the calculations.

The same would also be true if you were to attach the work to a face plate or a collet. Think about the difference between a diving board and the same board between two cinder blocks. The diving board cannot move at the back end, and this imparts strength to it.

Practical physics...

Steve

Re: Quick tip for turning thin spindles(Charlie et al)

#5

24 Years for Me!

Tony - Memphis

Although I am an ME, it has been so long since I was actually tasked with using my education, I don't remember much of it. I'm in IT now...go figure. Sometimes, I think I'd like to go back through and learn it all over again. Might do better as an "adult!"

Tony - whose spindles tend to vibrate and chatter too

Re: Quick tip for turning thin spindles(Charlie et al)

#6

Steven Antonucci

ME's became ITs in the middle 1990's

steven antonucci

because it paid better! I came directly into IT in 1988 because I wasn't smart enough to be a EE (and I didn't want to be a EE).

Steve

My spindles chatter too...

Re: Quick tip for turning thin spindles(Charlie et al)

#7

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: ME's became ITs in the middle 1990's *LINK*

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Hey, watch it Steve, I'm an EE and proud of it. BTW, the following link gives equations for the displacement of a simple beam (read uniform cross-section spindle) for many situations including simply supported on both ends, and rigidly supported (chuck) on one end and simply supported (live center) on the other end.

Dennis


http://http://www.engineersedge.com/beam_calc_menu.shtml

Re: Quick tip for turning thin spindles(Charlie et al)

#8

Steven Antonucci

nothing but respect for EEs

Steven Antonucci

Without them, IT people wouldn't have a job that pays twice theirs :D

Even my ME buddies abandoned their HVAC jobs for IT. I still see a Civil guy with a shovel once in a while, but those guys were always a special breed :)

Steve

Re: Quick tip for turning thin spindles(Charlie et al)

#9

Moment & Shear Diagrams

charlie belden

Chucking one end of a spindle rather than mounting it between centers doesn't increase the STRENGTH of the beam, but does effect how the load on the beam acts on it.

These Moment Diagram and Shear Diagram for a "supported on both end beam" vs a "cantilevered beam" may clarify what is happening to the wood for each case.


Re: Quick tip for turning thin spindles(Charlie et al)

#10

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: ME's became ITs in the middle 1990's

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Sorry, the link should have been www.engineersedge.com/beam_calc_menu.shtml

Dennis

Re: Quick tip for turning thin spindles(Charlie et al)

#11

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Moment & Shear Diagrams

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Charlie, I'm not quite sure what you meant by "doesn't increase the strength of the beam". In any case, for a spindle (beam) of uniform cross-section, rigidly fixing (chucking) one end AND simply supporting the other end (live center) reduces the deflection at the center of the spindle for a given tool load at that point by a factor of four. This is compared to mounting the same spindle between centers.

Dennis

Re: Quick tip for turning thin spindles(Charlie et al)

#12

Steven Antonucci

Thanks for the quick calc

steven antonucci

I knew it was significant, but I did a quick read on moment and shear and very quickly realized that I wouldn't be able to explain it because I didn't understand it beyond the qualitative answer I started with (chucking is better).

As for a factor of 4, well, there you go. It is 4X better ;)

Steve