Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

The Evolution Chuck is about to land

Posts

The Evolution Chuck is about to land

#1

The Evolution Chuck is about to land

Greg Haugen

Just FYI......since this was a recent subject. I just saw this on Lee Valley's website. First shipment is due by mid April.

http://www.leevalley.com/US/Wood/page.aspx?p=70639&cat=1,330,69091,69183&ap=1

Re: The Evolution Chuck is about to land

#2

Re: The Evolution Chuck is about to land

Craig Daymon

Looks like a great chuck. Though problematic if you have multiple lathes (with different size spindles), the lack of an adapter should result in less vibration. The addition of indexing positions is an interesting one. Wonder if the 24 positions on the edge and 36 positions on the face are oriented in such a way to offer a larger range combining both?

I definitely like the key better than the one I have for my current Axminster.

Speaking of keys and a bit OT, the chuck key is dislike the most is the chuck key for my JET 17" drill press. I have slammed my knuckles every time because that thing won't register properly with the chuck.

Re: The Evolution Chuck is about to land

#3

I'm likely to bite on one

Mike Foster

but can't figure out if the jaw slides are compatible with the older Super Precision chuck. I have a bunch of jaws that I know will work with the chuck, but I got jaw slides for each set of jaws so I can just spin a set in quickly. Do you know if the jaw slides are the same as the rest of Axminster chucks?

Re: The Evolution Chuck is about to land

#4

Re: I'm likely to bite on one

Craig Daymon

Should be compatible. Last line from the Lee Valley description, "Compatible with any Axminster jaw set (sold separately)."

Re: The Evolution Chuck is about to land

#5

Rob Wallace

Looks a lot like the Vicmarc chucks....

Rob Wallace

On the surface, I don't see much of a change from the former Axminster chucks of what the new ones look like. BTW - The Vicmarcs have indexing on the back of theirs too....although I have never used it, preferring to use separate indexing wheels instead.

Looks like a good chuck, but I'm sticking with my Vicmarcs - 5 so far (4 x VM100's and one VM120) plus one of the Grizzly knock-offs of the VM-100. I'm too vested in VM jaw sets, and also prefer the hex key format of the Vicmarcs for the tightening tool. (I never did like the geared keys of Oneway chucks, etc.)

If someone has the "before" and "after" Axminster chucks and can compare them, I am sure many turners would be interested in learning how the new and old versions differ, and what improvements, if any, are significant.

Rob

Re: The Evolution Chuck is about to land

#6

Re: Looks a lot like the Vicmarc chucks....

John Lucas

I've always heard that Axminster makes a great chuck and I love their selection of Jaws. I'll have to look but I think they have what they call the O'Donnel jaws which are fantastic. I have something similar for my Vicmarc's but they don't make them anymore.

I'll probably stick with my Vicmarc's as well since I have so many. Like Rob I've never used the indexing on the back of mine either. I prefer the ironfireLLC wheel although it is a pain when you forget to put it on before needing it and have to stop and remove the chuck.

Re: The Evolution Chuck is about to land

#7

Re: The Evolution Chuck is about to land

Greg Haugen

I think the one big improvement is just the design element. The old Super Precision was a monstrosity. Great chuck, but rather long (protruded a fair distance off of the headstock) and the threaded plates were outdated. This is a nice looking chuck and gets Axminster back in the market with the Vicmarcs and Oneways with a contemporary design. The O'Donnell jaws are nice and some of the features of an Axminster, like the backing out of the jaw slides to change jaws, are nice. It's nice to see them getting back into the market.

Personally, I'm a Oneway chuck guy. They have vastly improved the jaws selection in the past 5 years and I do like the geared key. Very fast action.

Re: The Evolution Chuck is about to land

#8

Re: The Evolution Chuck is about to land

Mark ravensdale

Like many I have been a fan of the Axminster precision chuck and have been using it for around 7 year now so I looked forward to the new Axminster chuck coming, but there have been a few things that have put me off it as well, for one they have been advertising it here in the uk heavily in the mags for upwards of 12 months and indeed it has been released here for over 6-7 months but no one can seem to get hold of one, why release it if you haven't got any stock!!!

Secondly, apparently there can be problems with it not fitting some lathes because of the way it has been designed,

Thirdly, the way it locks to the spindle (for reverse turning) is a little strange, it uses screws that push through the back of the chuck (up against the register) and not on/around the spindle, strange one this!!!

And fourthly, over the last few years the number of jaw types available for the Axminster chucks has shrunk a lot, over here in the UK (where they are made) in the last 5 years I would estimate that the number of jaw types available has reduced by around 50 percent, the number of jaws available was one of the main reasons I choose the Axminster precision chuck, but now they have less and less types available this tells me something, Axminster power tools seem to be going more and more down the cordless drill and other power tool road and withdrawing more and more away from the woodturning world!!!

I for one will NOT be buying one (if they ever come into stock that is) and instead will buy another stronghold !!!

There is one thing that Axminster do that none of the other chuck makers seem to do, that is that they make available the jaw carriers for sale, so instead of messing with Allen keys and bolts one simply winds the jaws out and winds a different set in, why the others don't do this I don't know (well I do, but if you wind your jaws so far out when clamping then you half deserve problems!!!)

Re: The Evolution Chuck is about to land

#9

Re: The Evolution Chuck is about to land

Mark ravensdale

Gregg I have to agree with you on most of your post, but although they (Axminster power tools) are releasing this chuck, they have less and less jaws and other woodturning equipment available in there catalogue, they seem to be shying away from the woodturning world and going more and more down the power tool and cordless drill road (which is a real shame as they built there name with woodturning !!!)

The number of jaws they have available is a fraction of what they had available 5-6 years ago, they sell less and less woodturning tools, they no longer sell wood blanks (other than for pens) it's a real shame to see this happening !!!