Has anyone ever had a failure of a wooden tool handle where the tool joins the wood? If so, can you give the details?
I'm working on an article (for my website) on making ferrules and the thought occurred to me that I've never heard of a failure of a wooden handle, either with or without a ferrule. My concern is having the wood split near the join.
If you've had such a failure, what type of ferrule was used, if any, and how far was the tool inserted into the wood?
I don't remember what the tool was, aside from being a PSI tool. (Maybe a parting tool, of all things?) I remember I had a really good catch that caused the break. The tang seemed particularly short and it was a square/tapered tang, which may have added to its ability to crack the handle.
Come to think of it, it was a parting tool. I still have it, still haven't replaced the handle, somewhere.
I have had a couple of ferrules split, and they were from commercially made tools, their 'house' brands. I did have one tool handle split near the ferrule. The ferrule held fine, but the wood was cross grained near where it broke, and it split on the grain line. I glued it back together, and it works fine. Best to have the straightest grain possible. I have some marine grade plywood that I want to try for a few handles, 1/2 inch with 11 layers of ply. It should be fine. Note here, I have WAY fewer catches now.
Doc I had a bowl gouge break on a homemade handle. That was many years ago and I don't think I had it in the wood far enough. I don't remember if it had a ferrule then or not. To many years ago.
It's funny you should bring this up because I was looking at an article on preparing Japanese hand chisels for use. One of the things they do is mushroom the wood that sticks out past what I'll call a ferrule (but probably incorrect) on the drive end of the chisel. The ferrule on this end is designed to keep the wood from splitting while you drive the chisel into the wood with a mallet. I got to thinking that if we did that on our turning tool ferrule's it would keep the ferrule from ever falling off.
I know I now use brass couplings that have threads for my ferrules so they will never come off but if you use plain pipe and glue it on it will almost always come loose eventually from wood movement. Most of my older gouges that came with a wooden handle and factory ferrule have a dimple in the metal to keep it from falling off.
Back in the good old days before captured systems I was using an Ellsworth type home built boring bar. It had a plastic PVC pipe ferrule and home made handle. It broke the plastic and the handle. It goes to show how much stress there is in the hollowing process. I would never turn with any tool that did not have a ferrule.
Have you ever used the string tied method that David uses on his tools? Not sure if the term for that is a ferrule or something else. If so, was it effective?
I like the look of it. Trying to apply it to a turning. Maybe use it as a decorative collar on an in-turned bowl or hollowform.
(Or anyone else that has used this method of bracing the tool end of a handle.)
.....string ferrule for any tool that might be subject to any real stress! First problem is that nylon and many other twine materials stretch under load, and wood movement from a tree branch that Ellsworth uses might still have significant movement from moisture changes. I just don't want to make my working tools to appear to be "hippy" made!
It works. I did it on several tools that lasted maybe 10 years or more. I wrapped the wood with some old string I had for making bow strings. Lashed it down and then covered it with thin CA. It lasted until the CA fell apart and then the string came loose. I would use it without worry for any tool I needed to make in a hurry. Otherwise I would take the time to make a metal ferrule.
Doc, I had one break a couple weeks ago on my favorite bowl gouge. The handle was home made with a copper pipe ferrule. The gouge was in a bowl about half way when a catch occurred. The piece on the lathe was OK, but the handle was split about 7" long on two sides. Epoxied it back together and it's been fine since. In fact, I'll be using it at my demo for your club tonight, so you can see the damage first hand if you like.
...which doesn't stretch. It is also usually waxed for that application, which makes glue stiffening less trustworthy, but I still wouldn't trust ANY string ferrule under load!
...makers pay enough attention to grain orientation and material characteristics for wooden tool handles. This can have a very significant effect on strength and splitting. I've seen turners who have been so proud of their beautiful custom made burl turning handles, and they're heartbroken when they break! An "old timer" making handles from hickory for a shovel or axe would carefully select straight grain and proper grain alignment for such applications.
I've used string (or wrapped) ferrules a lot. The most important thing, in my opinion, is that thin CA and epoxy will soak into the string and "wet" the surface. I'm not sure this is the case for nylon and other synthetics. I just don't know.
The CA and epoxy should bond the thread to the wood, obviously.
I prefer fairly small thread instead of a larger one that may be called a cord or twine. The thread I use is less than 1/32" in diameter, about the same size as a 0.5 mm pencil led for a mechanical drafting pencil, if that large.
The stress on a ferrule is vertical - from top to bottom, or vice versa. The split in the wood, if it happens, will be in a horizontal plane.
Consider this, to get an idea of the strength of a string ferrule. Suppose the breaking strength of the string is 5 lbs, which is not much. For each turn you apply, you get twice this, 10 lbs, of "strength" from top to bottom of the handle. That's because the string goes down one side and up the other, for each turn.
So, 10 turns gives 10 x 10 = 100 lbs of tensile strength. 20 turns gives 200 lbs, 30 turns gives 300 lbs, etc. This is a considerable strength, and it is with a string that breaks at only 5 lbs of tension - sewing thread.
I wind the "ferrule" while the handle is still on the lathe. After tacking the starting point with CA, I rotate the handwheel with one hand and guide the string with the other. I can wind on 30 or 40 turns quickly.
I coat the thread with epoxy after the wrapping is complete. And that's how I do a ferrule.
I am a stickler for safety. You are correct, the string ferrule is not as strong. The CA or epoxy plasticizes it so it will not stretch but it could break. I don't use my string ferrule tool much and it is only for finish cuts. The grain orientation is most important and the amount of wood the ferrule has under it for support and where the tool shaft enters the hole. There needs to be a larger diameter of wood up near the hole for extra strength on home built handles.
None of us ever get catches any more, but this was important before we figured out how to turn without catches.
One of the more unusual ferrules I have come across was a guy who used sections of springs as a ferrule. He would just go the big box store and pick out some of the larger springs and turn the wood to accommodate them.
Seemed to work and were distinctive. I actually have one on a tool he made for me.
My step-dad used wire wrappings on about every tool he owned from spades, , dirt shovels, grain scoops, hoe, or anything with a wood handle down to his old screwdrivers. I never did see any of them fail, even with the worst dried out and split looking handles. I see no reason why this would not work on any lathe tool. I guess I am lazy and just made the ferrules out of brass.
Doc , you may want to make your handles out of aluminum bar. It can be drilled on a wood lathe fine. Of course it will have more weight than a wood handle but I like the way the aluminum bar dampens the vibes.
I broke a handle about a year ago the ferrel split and so did the wood the tool was only in the handle about 1 1/2" it was a 1/2"Packard Spindle gouge When I make a handle I put at lest 2 1/2 to 3"in the handle and use a copper coupling ( most couplings are heavy then the pipe) also have 1/2' of wood around the tool.
Info: there was a thread on SMC about the insert ferrel you buy that are braking out of the wood. I think it was one from Craft Suppies but not sure. My memory in action.
One of my clients is a rope manufacturer. Their riggers use braided nylon to seize the area over splices. This stuff is incredibly strong when done correctly. Pull very tight, apply in half hitches. Soak the nylon twine in water. It (cheap nylon) shrinks on drying. Get the small stuff at the box store. Then coat the stuff when dry with CA or Epoxy (they use Polyurethane) and it should put the wood under tremendous compression and last a very long time.
I've used this method to repair older split wooden handles and they're still holding up under abuse with no problems. I don't think the stresses on turning tools wood be that much greater.
Of course string choice is a good factor. As a rockclimber we often use rope and webbing that will easily hold a car. My Spectra slings are about 3/16" thick and 1/2" wide and will hold 3000lbs. My rope is 10mm and will hold more than that.
So Doc's specs on how strong a ferrule is with many wraps of thread is probably not far off.
I have only every has a single issue with a tool handle, and it was while I was still learning and decidedly doing the wrong thing with the wrong tool (I broke the tang on a SRG)
Ferrules are pretty much like a safety net. If you've ever fallen into a safety net, it is better than dying, if you know how to fall into a safety net. If you do not know how to fall, it's like falling into a giant heavy pile of ropes on your head.
If you are worried about the strength of your ferrule, you should probably not be turning. Copper, String, brass, etc. are all going to resist a certain load, and fail under some conditions. Turners should NEVER experience those types of loads.
Ever.
P.S. Where does the force go when it cannot break the ferrule? (Hint: it doesn't go "away")
Doc This is what I was talking about to make the ferrules stay on as the wood shrinks. It would only have to be very slight. Just leave the wood a little proud of the ferrule and then hammer it over when your done. If it extends beyond the edge it could easily be trimmed.