Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Best glue for segmented salad bowl

Posts

Best glue for segmented salad bowl

#1

Best glue for segmented salad bowl

Ron B

I was wondering what the experts use for gluing a segmented utility salad bowl that will actually be used? Epoxy, wood glue, polyurethane, CA or ??? It will be coated with a polymerized finish. Urethane would give a small glue line but maybe it would look nice. Thanks in advance for your thoughts.

Re: Best glue for segmented salad bowl

#2

Re: Best glue for segmented salad bowl

Joe Herrmann

Polyurethane would most likely provide the strongest bond but I don't like dealing with the mess. CA is brittle and seems to degrade over time--probably wouldn't hold up at all. Really god epoxy is expensive to buy for just one project. I wouldn't use the 5 minute stuff. I think I would probably use the Titebond III because I've always had good luck with their products.

Re: Best glue for segmented salad bowl

#3

Re: Best glue for segmented salad bowl

John Lucas

I disagree on polyeurethane if you have an end grain to end grain joints. It was the second weakest bond of all the glues I tested just ahead of CA glue. I would go with either Titebond 111 or epoxy. Either one of those two are also far easier to clean up than Poly and less likely to glue your fingers together. :)

Re: Best glue for segmented salad bowl

#4

Re: Best glue for segmented salad bowl

bill Crommett

I have used Titebond Sash and Trim glue with great success. It is easier to work with and if the bowls are well treated with several coats of hardening oil they will withstand much use, but not for soaking in soapsuds.

Re: Best glue for segmented salad bowl

#5

Re: Best glue for segmented salad bowl

Ralph Lindberg

Bill, I think the actual name is "Window and Door Trim", but that's what I prefer, it has a faster tack time then "III" but still with good strength.

Re: Best glue for segmented salad bowl

#6

Re: Best glue for segmented salad bowl

John Lucas

Not familiar with that glue. Is it waterproof. that's why I recommended titebond 111. I have used it on cutting boards for years and they hold up under washing. Probably not dishwasher but hand washing hasn't hurt them at all.

Re: Best glue for segmented salad bowl

#7

Re: Best glue for segmented salad bowl

Joe Herrmann

John's right--didn't consider end grand to end grain bond in the segments.

Re: Best glue for segmented salad bowl

#8

Re: Best glue for segmented salad bowl

John Lucas

I ran tests about 10 years ago on a bunch of the common glues I use and was amazed how weak all of them were. I glued 3/4" square pieces of several types of wood together end grain to end grain. Then I put one end in the vice and slide a 2 1/2 lb weight out the wood past the joint to see how far I could go before it broke. I didn't get 2" out with the CA and Polyeurethane glues. In fact I could break the joint just like you break a pencil in your hands. It was incredibly weak.

The yellow glues were much better but still very weak. I improved the bond by putting what they call a sizing. I diluted the glue about 50/50 with water and spread it on. let it dry and then apply full strength glue and clamp. Almost as good is to simply apply full strength and rub it in good, let is sit for 30 seconds or so to soak into the end grain and then apply more glue and put the joint together. If you've ever glued side grain to side grain with PVA glue you know it's stronger than the wood. Not end grain. I don't remember the exact numbers but I was able to move the weight out about 5 or 6"

Epoxy was better but not as much as you think. It added only a few more inches but definitly was the stronger of the glues I tried.

I need to do the test over with a new glue I found this morning called OakandTeak epoxy. Sounds like exactly what we need for gluing exotics. It stays somewhat flexible so woods with different movements won't suffer and is specifically designed to glue the oily woods. How cool is that.

Re: Best glue for segmented salad bowl

#9

Re: Best glue for segmented salad bowl

Ron B

Thanks very much for your comments. I will look for the sash and trim but if not available will probably use Titebond III. I could edge glue all the pieces for a stronger bond but then that leaves end grain exposed in the bowl. By end gluing I get side grain in the bowl (which is preferable). Like all things in life it is a compromise between form and function. Thanks again for all your comments.

Re: Best glue for segmented salad bowl

#10

Re: Best glue for segmented salad bowl

John Lucas

Ron If you offset the joints the end grain to end grain isn't much of a problem because each ring will be glued side grain to side grain which is very strong. If you align all the joints that's when you have a potential problem.

Re: Best glue for segmented salad bowl

#11

Re: Best glue for segmented salad bowl

Peter Hyde

Something to consider with glue choice is how flexible the glue is when dried. Most of the white and yellow wood glues including TB111 will allow creep and movement at the joints. Not good, also TB111 is NOT waterproof, only water resistant. There is a plastic resin glue that mixes with water and is waterproof and will not creep. It's a military certified marine grade glue and will hold up under long immersion times. Circa 1800 is one of the brands available here in Canada. Comes in a 1 pound tin of dry powder. Shelf life is about 2 years.

Re: Best glue for segmented salad bowl

#12

Re: Best glue for segmented salad bowl

bill Crommett

John: Waterproof is not an issue with salad bowl glues .Salad bowls hold salad and oily dressing and are not subjected to deep immersion or soaking - if properly cared for.

Re: Best glue for segmented salad bowl

#13

Re: Best glue for segmented salad bowl

John Lucas

that's why I suggested titebond 111. Although it isn't totally water proof by the actual definition it will withstand X number of dunkings or hours in water. I forget the actual figure but that's what seperates it from titebond 11. Of course epoxy is still a good choice.

Re: Best glue for segmented salad bowl

#14

Re: Best glue for segmented salad bowl

Ron B

John, Thanks for that. I now realize that alternating the rings to eliminate repetitive glue lines (on the end grain) will be the answer.....plus it will look better. R.