Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Copying others work

Posts

Copying others work

#1

Copying others work

barbara dill

What a great article in the new American Woodturner about copying the work of others. Jerry Bennett points out that copying or duplication is generally acceptable, except when a work has original elements. Basic shapes belong to all of us. He points out that originality is derived from unique content and not from the concept. I can not do this article justice here, but it has made a very positive impact on me as a woodturner. I'm sure many of us have had criticism that has not been justified about how our work looks like someone else's.

Way to go Jerry and Betty!!!!

Re: Copying others work

#2

Re: Copying others work

Bernie Weishapl

Thanks for posting Barbara. I belong to several forums and on a couple I got slammed pretty bad because a couple of my pieces looked like a professional turners pieces. I did put my own spin on them. So needless to say I don't post much anymore after that experience. I agree if you make them identical and then call them your own that is wrong. I look forward to reading the article.

Re: Copying others work

#3

Steven Antonucci

A copy of a copy...

steven antonucci

At some point, the work ends up either being commoditized (another bowl/vessel) or it gains a life of its own from the artists hands. It has been stated before that there is nothing new under the sun, and all we do as artists is try to "mash-up" the things we have, the things we've seen, and the things we dream into something that we feel inside.

I thought I had the coolest idea ever (and completely on my own) to make something that had never been done before, and then one day I saw the exact thing I was going to make in a stock photo for a furniture ad... as a prop on a bookshelf!

Make what you want to make, and don't worry about copying. You'll know it if you are.

Steve

Re: Copying others work

#4

I agree Barbara

Mike Foster

I read Jerry's article first when I got my copy of the journal. It was a very well written and thought out article. Hit home to me as well and really was a thought provoking piece of work. I too commend both Betty and Jerry.

Re: Copying others work

#5

Re: I agree Barbara

carl civitella

It is very hard to copy, it is probably easier to just to wing it, to bad, i do not have wings. Carl

Re: Copying others work

#6

Re: Copying others work

John Lucas

I agree, loved the article. It's one of those you have to read a couple of times to really understand all he has covered. For my self I never understood copying other than to just make one to see how it's done. I have always wanted to put a little something of myself in everything I make. I did make 6 roll top bread boxes from Woodsmith magzine about 25 years ago. That may be the only thing I've ever copied directly. No I take that back. I have made 2 bird houses that were very similar to the ones Andy Barnum put in a magazine also about 20 to 25 years ago. Even then I did change the shapes a little.

Re: Copying others work

#7

Re: Copying others work

Mark ravensdale

When I see a nice piece, instead of doing a straight copy I will do my interpretation of that design, so it may look similar but it's not an exact copy.

Re: Copying others work

#8

Re: Copying others work

Jorge

In my boat building days, i did by "lines" for boats I admired either for their looks or performance. Never felt I was copying, and had occasion to have my creation tied up side by side with somebody's boat built to the same lines, the overall look was similar but they gave quite a different feel.

Re: Copying others work

#9

Copying Is Vital

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

For teaching (and learning) technique. Painters (not for houses ;) ) have traditionally spent many hours literally copying the work of others, notably the Old Masters, to learn how to manipulate paint, color, light, and composition. It is not an uncommon sight to see a student planted with easel, canvas, and stool in front of a Rembrandt, DaVinci, or Van Gough working to copy brush strokes. Every art curriculum has a significant portion of required art history where students are trained to analyze works; if you can't develop a vision for what others have done, you can never expect to be fully able to know what you, yourself, are doing or trying to do.

The old system of apprenticing to a master had the same effect, and even modern students can require years to "work out" of the stylistic influence of their teacher/professors before they find their own artistic voice and style.

There are also a very important number of artists who, while doing their own "thing", are also highly skilled copy artisans who are commissioned to make copies of famous works. A rich collector may have bought a Monet painting for $XX million but will rarely hang it over his/her fireplace. The original piece rests in a controlled atmosphere bomb-proof vault and the exact copy hangs on the wall.

It is really only when a copy is presented as an original work that we raise the red flag of "FORGERY!!!".

As a figure sculptor, I've spent many hours studying human anatomy. But was I simply making mud copies of the original?

When I taught ceramics, was I teaching my students process and method by covering classroom walls with photos of ancient and modern pottery? Was I sensitizing them to alternatives and firing their imaginations, or was I just creating a bunch of plagiarizing copy-cats?

I rather regard what I did was to work to form a solid foundation of sensitivity and learning from which new art had a chance to spring.

"Copy" may be a 4-letter word, but it's not a bad one.

Re: Copying others work

#10

I'm pretty sure Michelangelo copied my body   


Re: Copying others work

#11

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Copying Is Vital

Lyle Jamieson

Can you share some photos of your Figurative art?? Web site?? Articles?? I might want to copy your forms in wood...Just kidding!!

Re: Copying others work

#12

A few

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Bronze: Maquete for proposal for Lincoln Plaza tower in New York -


Chief Justice Charles Evan Hughs -

Wood:

Plasticene:



Commission Proposal for 2nd Conan film.

Not much in digital yet. Have slide scanner; just need the time.

Re: Copying others work

#13

Bob Stocksdale

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

commented that the Chinese had been copying his forms for thousands of years :D

So now, John, should we just start referring to you as "Little David"?

Re: Copying others work

#14

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

So long as you don't mind copying a copy . . . . ;)

Re: Copying others work

#15

1 More

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Bronze:

Maquete proposal for Lincoln Plaza fountain


Re: Copying others work

#16

Lyle Jamieson

Great stuff, thanks for sharing


Re: Copying others work

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: A few

Keith Tompkins

Awesome work Mark,.....but then, I already knew that!! :D

Re: Copying others work

#18

Mike Stafford

I'm pretty sure Michelangelo rejected my body....


Re: Copying others work

#19

Neat stuff!!

Jorge

Thanks for sharing it Mark.

Re: Copying others work

#20

Re: Copying others work

barbara dill

It is great to see what other have to say about this topic. I do love the clarity that this article offered for the turning community. It is do good to have a conversation about these important issues.

Re: Copying others work

#21

More Than A Little OT

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

But Lyle did ask . . :D

Re: Copying others work

#22

Lyle Jamieson

Re: More Than A Little OT

Lyle Jamieson

Not off topic for me, I'm always looking for ideas and inspiration. Tough job, I know, looking at the female forms, but somebodies got to do it.

Re: Copying others work

#23

Re: Copying others work

Barbara Gill

This whole plagiarism thing really put me off as it was presented a number of years ago. Even the AAW had a session at one of the Symposiums where the plagiarism insanity was promoted by at least one well known and respected turner. The whole mind set reminded me of the Salem Witch Hunt.

I am glad to see that maybe some reason is being promoted now. It may encourage other turners.