Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Johannes fixtures

Posts

Johannes fixtures

#1

Johannes fixtures

John Lucas

In order to properly test my Johannes grinding fixture I had to build the rest of the jigs so that the gouge would be extended the same.


Re: Johannes fixtures

#2

Re: Johannes fixtures

Richard T. Jones

John,

Can you describe the difference and pros/cons in this jig?

Thanks.

Rich

Re: Johannes fixtures

#3

Re: Johannes fixtures *LINK*

John Lucas

Well I'm still very new at it having just built and used it yesterday. The pros are that you can use the entire flute. The tool is inserted with the top of the U down on the jig. This means the 2 flat edges of the flute are down against the jig when aligning the sharpening jig, or fixture as Johannes says. What this means is you can sharpen the entire tool. On the Oneway jig when you run out of flute you have to hand sharpen because it won't align properly. In this jig will align as long as there are some flats on the top of the flute.

Johannes extends the flute 2 3/8" beyond the fixture so it gives you more room for the fixture to clear the stone. He also claims this gives a different shape to the primary bevel but I'll have to experiment more on that because it looks almost exactly like the bevel I had on my Oneway. It probably rolls in more so the wings aren't quite as acute as on my Oneway grind but I'll have to figure out how to measure and what the advantages are.

You can watch his video here.


http://hannestool.com/products-overview/michelsen-grind

Re: Johannes fixtures

#4

Re: Johannes fixtures

Dick Coers

I don't know how you can say it looks exactly like your Wolverine grind. The pivot is off the center line of the wheel, and the extension from the pivot is way longer. It can't be the same. Maybe your homemade parts aren't an exact copy? Did you measure his parts, or trace a pattern off them? As far as I'm concerned, this is a place where buying the real thing pays off. If you want the real grind, buy the real parts.

Re: Johannes fixtures

#5

Steven Antonucci

Or you could buy a Tormek?

steven antonucci

The Tormek turning tool jigs have always registered against the flat of the flute. Setting the distance to the wheel and the amount of extension is trivial, and could just as easily be achieved by laying the flat of the flute on a bench with a line on it and a block to get the Wolverine/Oneway/homemade perpendicular.

If you need a jig to grind the heel off of your gouge, make the block have a step in it, or make your wheel distance block with two steps in it.

By the time you buy your slow speed grinder, CBN wheel, and all the Wolverines, Oneways, Raptors, Johannes grinding attachment... you could have bought a Tormek.

Just sayin...

Steve

Re: Johannes fixtures

#6

Re: Or you could buy a Tormek? *LINK*

Craig Daymon

Tormek does offer a jig for use with other grinding wheels. Don't know what the price is for it. Might even be a little to save buying just the jig that's meant for the wet wheel and building the rest of the mountings, if you have the equipment/skills to do so.

Having only the wet wheel may not be the best system if what you are trying to do is establish the shape of a new tool, or make your own tool from drill blanks or planer blades. It may be great for refreshing an edge, but I don't believe it is the best for hogging off steel to shape a tool. (For example, I bought a Crown Pro-PM 1/2" bowl gouge with a traditional grind and reground it to an Ellsworth grind. Buying it with the grind would have run me about $40 more and I'd still have to know how to maintain that shape/grind.)


Tormek jig with regular bench grinder.

Re: Johannes fixtures

#7

Steven Antonucci

I own a grinder for grinding

steven antonucci

I picked up a cheap grinder for heavy stock removal ($10...craftsman) I use it to grind "lots" of metal. I use the Tormek to sharpen.

Do people with CBN wheels grind on them? I don't know? The Tormek is slow, and heavy stock removal is possible, but it tends to make depressions in the wheel, so I stopped doing it. No doubt CBN is faster than a Tormek, but probably not as fast as an angle grinder, belt sander, or stock high speed grinder. I suppose it all depends on whether or not you care about the temper of the edge. Heat kills.

I use the $10 Craftsman to grind away the heal because it doesn't matter what the heel looks like and it doesn't matter if the heel gets hot, because it doesn't cut. My edges are never blued because they are water cooled.

Steve

Re: Johannes fixtures

#8

Re: Johannes fixtures

John Lucas

Dick My measurements are really close. Sure the grind is off center but when you hold the two tools side by side there's very little difference. I'll learn more as I go with this. It's a good system I'm just not sure I'm ready to say go with one or the other.

Re: Johannes fixtures

#9

Here's why I say that

John Lucas

2 identical gouges. The one on top is ground using my homemade Hannes jig (fixture, whatever) The one on the the bottom is my Oneway Wolverine for the main bevel and simply moved forward in the V for the secondary grind and pulling out of the jig and hand grinding the bottom bevel As you can see the difference is so little I can't tell by looking.

Now I'm not putting down the Hannes jig. I think it's wonderful and love the upside down flute setting of the jig. However due to the way these two tools are ground it's hard for me to say jump out and buy one if you already own a Wolverine.

Now granted I didn't actually walk up and measure Johannes jig just to copy it. I did measure a photo to get a pretty good idea of the sizes and spacing of the holes. I want everyone to know I'm not trying to rip him off or anything. I'm just trying to learn more about sharpening and find his jig interesting. I can't afford to just buy one for the heck of it. I do find his turning skill remarkable and like everyone else wanted to think that it was just the tool or his grind that was going to solve all my problems. Apparently not, it is his skill with the tool. :)


Re: Johannes fixtures

#10

Hold on there..............

Dick Coers

You've gotten something wrong on your homemade fixture. From the real (purchased) system, you can see a lot more of the bevel in the top view. Your work is not duplicating the grind correctly. I see a danger is what you are doing here John. You try and duplicate someones design from a photograph, the grind doesn't come out the same as what you get with an original, then you tell folks you just can't see a difference in the way it works and question why they should buy it. How can you make an accurate comparison and evaluation with your pine knockoff? In my eyes, it's like the reverse engineering the Chinese do with our construction equipment that we design in my day job. It looks about the same, they paint it yellow, but it falls apart in the field because they don't know the original design specs, materials, or understand the loads and forces the design must endure. I suggest you edit your last post about questioning why someone should buy this system if the already own a Wolverine. Instead of making the irresponsible statement, "However due to the way these two tools are ground it's hard for me to say jump out and buy one if you already own a Wolverine", what you should have said is "don't buy my pine knockoff if you already own a Wolverine". Then we have an accurate statement of fact, not assumption.

Re: Johannes fixtures

#11

Re: Hold on there..............

John Lucas

Dick You are right I should not have said that. I can't seem to edit it for some reason. I think my jig is pretty darn close I based the measurements on the 3/4" bar used for mounting on the ONeway system so I'll bet my jig is pretty darn close. There are however a lot of variables, the angle and length of the arm on the tool holder as well as the spacing of the holes in the base jig.

Quite honestly I was expecting quite a bit of difference with the holes being that far off center and was surprised when it wasn't. I also did the same grind with the Wolverine jig and my usual 1 3/4" extension and could not tell the difference in the grind when compared to my homemade copy that had 2 3/8" extension and the rod is slightly longer than the wolverine. I thought there would be a real noticeable difference.

I have a friend who has one of the Hannes jigs and I've called and left a message to see if I can compare the two side by side and maybe use his to grind my tool.

Re: Johannes fixtures

#12

Re: C'mon, John . . .

Doc Green

Hey John,

What's up with all the facets on the bevels?

Yeah, I know, only the bevel near the cutting edge matters, but all those facets command so much attention that an untrained eye might not even notice the expertly fashioned, tiny bevel where it counts.

:)

~Doc

Re: Johannes fixtures

#13

Re: C'mon, John . . .

John Lucas

:) Doc they just happen. Since all the bevel underneath the main bevel doesn't do anything other than get out of the way it really doesn't matter how they look. I suppose you could put dots every quarter of a inch down the length of your V arm on the Oneway jig and just move it forward one step at a time and get perfectly ground bevels every time but I don't care. I care more about how it cuts which is why I'm experimenting anyway. Hey it looks better than all the vertical facets I used to get when hand grinding.

Re: Johannes fixtures

#14

Re: Johannes fixtures

robo hippy

Johannes did say that he was going to shoot a video clip about using his jig. I haven't seen it yet, so don't know if it has been done or not. I have not seen this grind in action, so I could be missing some thing.

As a free hand platform sharpener, a couple of points. Even when I used a jig for my gouges, I would get facets. No big deal, mostly because they are very small. Same holds true for free hand sharpening. Any facet that is not on the cutting edge will make no difference at all since it never comes into contact with the wood. I haven't had a chance to see the Johannes grind in person, but it looks similar to one that Christian Burshard (spell?) used years ago that he free hand ground so it had no bevel, kind of like the Eli Avesera convex skew grind. I don't think I would have any problem replicating that grind free hand. Even if you use a jig for the primary cutting edge, the 'relief' bevel can be easily replicated free hand.

I had hoped to go to Tampa and see it in person this year, but a fishing trip to a fly in conservation lake in NW Ontario Canada with my 90 year old/young dad and brothers got in the way. Have to wait till next year in Phoenix.

robo hippy

Re: Johannes fixtures

#15

Re: Johannes fixtures

Jim Bodin

Your fishing trip with your Dad is most important but - hope it isn't interfering with your sharpening video too much.

Re: Johannes fixtures

#16

Re: Johannes fixtures

joHannes Michelsen

OMG!!! I don't even know where to start!!! So I feel it is fair to start with the person who has his head out in the light for clear thinking, Dick has it all right! It is not possible to just pull a new product out into the sunshine and expect it to work like a charm, first one must do the research and testing that must be done to ascertain that " if we sell this thing will we be OK???"

Boy did I do some serious mock ups and grinding grinding grinding till i was blue in the face! at first I used wood though not anything as lowly as pine---I say again OMG! I used Mahogany and found it to not be substantial enough to get a true "read" on where am I truly going??? So I switched to PaperStone for my final trials---a countertop material which can still be cut with the machines I have---I felt I got a good read with it, as a matter of fact I did consider using it to produce the Pivot Plate but that would have left me as the manufacturer of at least that part and I'm too busy to do that sort of thing, so I let the machine shop do them of aluminum (no pine) and since we did the "hardcoat anodizing" I'm really happy it went that way because hardcoat is a Rockwell74 so now the Pivot Plates have great wear resistance---a good thing! So hard it feels like its waxed-- also a good thing!!!

I'm sorry John but pine just doesn't cut it for this purpose, what were you thinking??? Makes great siding or kindling but that's where it ends! Also it is painfully easy to see from the pic of "your jig" that you have the geometry all wrong, it's not even close, how can you expect a good result? The pic of the grinds you were able to achieve tell it all! It is clear that you were working with none equipment and with no view of your desired result, you were expecting the "JIG" to do it all for you!

I made it clear in our last thread on this subject that there really is no such thing as a grinding jig for wood turning gouges somehow the people who first made the thing called grinding jigs for wood turners totally misunderstood the meaning of the word "jig"! A true "jig" is a device in which one can clamp and or secure a work piece and then look out the window and daydream while the mechanizm goes thru its cycle and get a replica of the the original or the last piece you clamped in basically a sort of robot. This is not the case for the Vector Grind Fixture or any of the self proclaimed "jigs" which are actually "fixtures" which are divices that help the operator hold a work piece in a controlled secure fashion so that a desired result can be achieved by the operator with the help of said "fixture"! To do this the operator must have a clear "vision" of that desired result! In other words " if you don't know what it is you want, you will never get it"! I can see by the grinds you are getting that it is clear that you don't know what it is that you want!

Its a lot like wood turning, if you put wood in the lathe w/o knowing what you want then you may as well just stop. Its all about knowing!!

John if you would agree I will be happy to send you a "Vector" for your trials free of charge, pay only if you decide to keep it because you will hate to live w/o it! I will send it with the complete instructions so there will be nothing to go wrong by!

The true reality is that this thing is better than I imagined and can be adjusted to do about any grind configuration out there! and another reality is that if anyone was the champion/ backer of freehand grinding it was me and now that there is this device even I no longer freehand it, its just not "good" enough for me any longer, the results from the fixture are just superior to anything freehand ever!!!!

The videos I've done are on my web site or YouTube search "Vector" but it seems more info is called for so soon there will be a third with better clarity--out in the light!

Steve, 10 buck grinders don't hog anything:-)

Re: Johannes fixtures

#17

Re: Johannes fixtures

joHannes Michelsen

Yo Robo, Funny you should mention Christian--- he learned that grind from me back in the old free hand days.

Check the vids on youtube --search Vector!

Re: Johannes fixtures

#18

Steven Antonucci

best of all... they don't hog cash 


Re: Johannes fixtures

#19

Re: Johannes fixtures

John Lucas

Johannes Thanks for your reply. I am truly impressed with your turning and that's why I wanted to try out the Vector. I drove to a friends house today who had your Vector fixture and compared it to my homemade one. I had nailed it except for 2 small things. The arm on my tool holding fixture was 1/2" too long, and the holes for the secondary bevel was off by 1/8" and the tertiary grind was off by 1/4". Those two of course don't matter it's the initial grind that is critical.

I did have the Vector set at 6 1/4" instead of 7 like it says in your video and it is 5" exactly from the center line. I'm using 8" wheels and it seems that I'm grinding very close to the center line of the wheel which is unsafe so I may be doing something wrong.

I am using a 1/2" thompson V bowl gouge for this project.

I am always trying to learn more about sharpening and grinds and appreciate any help you give. As always I pass this info on to others.

Re: Johannes fixtures

#20

Re: Johannes fixtures

John Scheideman

Wow! Just want to point out what a class act Johannes is. I am not sure I would be as generous if someone were trying to replicate an invention that I spent a lot of time developing. Then too, I know that John is very generous to all of us who need assistance. I appreciate you both! BTW- I bought the vector from Johannes and will recommend it to anyone.

John

Re: Johannes fixtures

#21

Re: Johannes fixtures

John Lucas

Well I'm not trying to replicate his jig to steel it or sell it. I simply wanted to try it out having just had my income cut by retirement I have to be very careful on what I spend. I have made many jigs out of wood quite successfully. They don't last forever of course. After about 5 years of use I gave my homemade Oneway jig away and bought one. I suspect the same thing will happen with the Hannes jig. And I will agree Johannes is a great teacher and demonstrator and obviously a pretty darn good tool maker. I did get to play with one of his handles yesterday as well and that might be the best handle on the market.

Re: Johannes fixtures

#22

Re: Johannes fixtures

joHannes Michelsen

Now I have to say WoW John S thanx for the class act comment, I do try to do what I can to make good product and to remain calm when it is torn down unfairly and w/o full info. And john L I want to thanx you for remaining calm as well I just wish you would move more gracefully! and with more precision!

I would love to stay and chat wit Uusss guys but we are half out the door headed for OK City to do a club demo and two days of teaching--spreading the good news about grinding ---the "Vector and not least those fabulous CBN wheels I have out of Austria--the face of sharpening has changed forever! In five years I don't think you will see any stone wheels except maybe as patio pavers.

We can pick this up again when I return in a week.

Mean time remember "it's all in the details!"