Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Spoon Gouge and hook knife reviews?

Posts

Spoon Gouge and hook knife reviews?

#1

Spoon Gouge and hook knife reviews?

vamatt

I'm looking at turning some spoons for cooking. I'd like the flexibility that carving the scoops provide. Any recommendations on manufacturerers of hook knives? Also recommendations on spoon gouges/bend gouges types and sizes? Are most spoon gouges as long as the Henry Taylor and is there an advantage to thier length? The pictures make them seem quite long...

Thanks and cheers,

Matt

Re: Spoon Gouge and hook knife reviews?

#2

Re: Spoon Gouge and hook knife reviews?

Greg Haugen

Matt,

First of all, are you looking to turn or carve them? Spoon gouges, like Henry Taylor's, are for carving-not turning. "Spoon gouges" have little to no relation to an actual spoon or its production. They're named that from the gouge's shape (bent) and are used in relief and sculptural carving where straight gouges just can't reach. Carved spoons are usually done with straight "sloyd" knives and bent/crooked/hook knives. I'd recommend www.pinewoodforge.com, they make the all kinds of knives, most specifically for carving utility items-it's owned and operated by Del Stubbs. In my opinion, they are the finest knives you can buy. Tableware that is turned fringes more on the spatula or spurtle side of things.

Re: Spoon Gouge and hook knife reviews?

#3

Re: Spoon Gouge and hook knife reviews?

Donna Banfield

Ditto on Del Stubbs'/Pinewood Forge carving tools. I have three hook knives for carving out the bowl of the spoons, and two straight, or sloyd knives for all the rest of the carving. I wouldn't part with those tools for anything in the world.

To put it in perspective, I started out with just one of his hook knives. I loved it so much, that I sold ALL my Flexcut and Crown carving tools (6 or 7) so that I could afford three more of Del's tools. It was after I sold them that I learned that Del had an accident - a very serious hand injury. I waited more than seven months in the wait-list queu for him to get back to production again. I ended up buying 4 more when my name came up on the wait list. They're THAT good.

Re: Spoon Gouge and hook knife reviews?

#4

spoon plane *LINK*

John Lucas

Here's what I prefer. I think it's much safer because you can hold the spoon in your hand and just pull this plane in different directions. I haven't made any steep sided spoons with it so I don't know how effective it is at that shape but for your average scooping type spoon it works really wonderfully.


http://www.woodcraft.com/product/2004867/7518/carvers-spoon-plane.aspx

Re: Spoon Gouge and hook knife reviews?

#5

Re: Spoon Gouge and hook knife reviews?

kruizen

I have a 3/4" #7 and an 1/2" #5 Taylor spoon gouge and they are what I use the most. If I was going to buy again I would stick with the 1/2".

I generally use a Nicholson #49 pattern makers file and a cabinet scraper to form back of the spoon.

I made a V clamping jig for holding the spoon after I turn the outside shape.

I would stay away from the Ashley Isles and the Hirch Spoon gouges, the sweep of the spoon is too gradual and to long for doing spoons.

If you do not want to make something to hold the spoon I would recommend the spoon knives from Pinewood Forge (Probably the finest knives you can buy) goes back to the old adage you get what you pay for.

There is more than one way to carve a spoon!! :D :D

Re: Spoon Gouge and hook knife reviews?

#6

Scorps

Jorge

is other way to go, Woodcraft is one selling them, Lee Valley sells crooked knives, which what I use, if the spoon is big enough there are small planes with roker in their sole, lenghtwise and crosswise, but most of the work is done wth straight knives. You can also use riffling rasps and of course sand paper.

Re: Spoon Gouge and hook knife reviews?

#7

Steven Antonucci

I made my bent knife

steven antonucci

I used an angle grinder to liberate a piece of old lawnmower blade. It's not hard, and it cuts pretty well. It's no Del Stubbs knife, but it can make a spoon.

Alternatively, a Pfeil spoon gouge is a wonderful alternative. (I have both)

Steve

Re: Spoon Gouge and hook knife reviews?

#8

Re: I made my bent knife

Jerry Klug

This is an interesting subject string for those of us that try to self teach carving. A local carving group mostly does characters and none turn so I make a lot of false starts trying to figure out what tool to attempt to carve with. Steve, can you post a picture of your lawn mower gouge?

Re: Spoon Gouge and hook knife reviews?

#9

Local carving club

John Lucas

Our local club is the same. The mostly use chip carving style knives and carves angels and santa's. I'm joined and will probably try some of those but I enjoy so many other ways of carving as well. Spent most of the morning carving a mirror handle.