Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

Posts

Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

#1

Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

robo hippy

If you don't know by now, I am a self proclaimed scraper psycho. Back tracking some years ago, I was at a Bonnie Klein workshop and mentioned to her that I used scrapers a lot on bowls. She commented back that she used gouges and it felt good to see long strings of shavings coming off the tool, and she couldn't do that with scrapers. Well, I just could not figure that one out. I can get heavy duty shavings that are wide and thick, and I can get ones that you can read a paper through, and can almost float in the air like 5 micron dust particles. So, that seems to me like I can 'cut' with the tool. I can get equally rough or smooth surfaces using gouges or scrapers. If I push the tools through the cut faster than the wood can slice, both gouges and scrapers will leave tear out. If I am gentle and light, I can get nice clean surfaces.

Am I missing some thing, or have I rediscovered long lost secrets to using scrapers?

The scraper in action:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hKdqiAc0jx4

robo hippy

Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

#2

Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

Mark ravensdale

I can back up Robo on this one, watched his YouTube videos and was amazed at what he can do with his scrapers, we are not talking abt dust or chips coming off his tools but thick ribbons of wood, if there is anyone out there that hasn't yet seen his YouTube videos I would well recommend you check them out (you can't help but be impressed!!!) just do a search for Robo Hippy

Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

#3

Aage Rendalen

What do you do when heresy works?

Aage Rendalen

I should go without saying that if a scraper is good enough to clean up after a gouge, a scraper can also clean up after a scraper.

Gouge is orthodoxy, scraper is heresy, even if the result is the same. I suspect that one reason we avoid scrapers has more to do with the perception that it cheapens the craft by making it look too simple rather than any indication that it delivers an inferior result.

I'm a gouge user, but when I've tried working with a scraper I've been surprised at how good it works. For people whose tool budget is limited, it certainly would be a ways to cutting down on expense.

Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

#4

Steven Antonucci

It's cutting if you can rub a bevel.

steven antonucci

First, roughing cuts... between scraping and negative rake scraping (saw it once or twice). Because you lower the handle, you can ride the bevel of the scraper, so you are cutting (my definition: bevel rubbing=cutting).

My personal issue with scrapers is that they leave a lesser finish if you can cut with a gouge. The gouge is sharper, so it cuts better. Other than that, when I can't get a shape right, I resort to scraping and sanding.

Steve

Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

#5

Re: It's cutting if you can rub a bevel.

SergioV

In my opinion a scraper, which cuts with a burr is no different than a gouge that has been sharpened without honing. The burr is also on the gouge and actually it can interfere negatively in this case with the quality of the cut. The difference between the two tools is the angle and the length of the edge that cuts the wood. Much longer in the scraper which, therefore, when heavy enough to prevent vibrations, can cut green wood much faster but raising more grain unless used at an angle (less contact) than a bowl gouge used in push cutting mode

Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

#6

Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

Jorge

Thanks for posting this, I have seen it several times now,

You sure do good with those scrapers. The tool that got me hooked up to turning was the skew and my mentor was against scraping. From my flat woodwork days, I did enjoy the most planing with a scary sharp blade, and leave a smooth and flat tabletop or whatever, so the gouge had more appeal tome, a sharper edge.

The scraper with its blunt nose still has a lot of secrets for me, last year I inherited a number of them, some thick, none as wide as yours, I should spend some time playing with them and broaden my repertoire.

Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

#7

Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

Harry Pye

I believe a sharp scraper, one with a burr, cuts. The almost transparent streamers coming off the newly sharpened scraper prove that. Once the burr is gone, the tool scrapes. The steep angle on the nose of the tool allows it to support a burr. This is my opinion and I believe the shavings and quality of cut tend to prove it.

Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

#8

Face shields suggested with scrapers too.


Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

#9

Don Leydens

Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

Don Leydens

Robo, you're an animal (my highest compliment). Seriously, I agree with Aage and Harry. If a scraper is so bad, why is it so often used as the final cut. Even the bowl gouge in "shear scraping" mode is often the last cut the wood will see. Some call Mike Hunter's tools scrapers, but like a burr, his cutters face UP at the very end and that makes a world of difference in my book. Smooth City!

Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

#10

scraper test

John Lucas

I had time while my glue is drying on other projects to run this test this morning. You may not be able to see the details as well once I shrunk all the photos but I'll be glad to send you the bigger ones if you want.

Top row left to right, then bottom row left to right. Someday I'll learn to add type to these photos.

This is a piece of yellow poplar that had a patch in it that doesn't want to cut clean. I had already turned about 10 of these so I knew how it turns. The first photo top left is a 3/8" thick 3/4" wide flat scraper ground with a negative rake at about 60 degree included angle and burr raised by a steel rod which I have found is the best burr for this scraper.

The second photo is my 1/2" thick round scraper, same negative rake angle, burr off the CBN wheel, which again seems to be the best way for this scraper.

3rd photo is a skew laying on it's side, included angle about 43 degrees, no burr.

4th photo bottom left, the 3/4" flat scaper with burr held at a 45 degree shear scraping angle. You notice a definite improvement in the finish.

5th photo was a freshly sharpened bowl gouge with a 40 degree grind. A better finish especially on the end grain.

5th photo, a #4 Hunter tool. It's hard to see in the shrunk photo but it was a better finish still especially on the end grain.

I hope to have time to read all the scraper articles I've been collecting and to regrind a scraper into the very sharp negative rake grind that Stewart Batty has on his tools to see if it makes a difference.

As far as scrapers being used as the final tool for finishing I'm a little mixed on that. I do quite often because I turn fairly quickly and sometimes leave little tool marks and it's easier to use the shear scraper to clean these up. On smaller projects like boxes and quite often on my hand mirrors the cutting tool is the last finish and never touched by a scraper. The wood simply looks better if I can do it that way.


Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

#11

Different woods scaper differently

John Lucas

Maple for example will leave a fairly good finish off a flat scaper and get really nice curls off a shear scraper. Cocobolo doesn't scrape as good but shear scrapes fantastically. Blackwood cuts very clean with a flat scraper although I still get a much better finish with the Hunter tools either as a scraper or bevel rubbing.

Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

#12

Re: It's cutting if you can rub a bevel.

robo hippy

Steve,

I kind of disagree a bit.

First, I think there are 3 main cuts we use, a scrape, a shear cut, and a 'shear scrape'. A scraping cut is with the cutting edge at 90 degrees to the rotation of the wood as in scraper flat on the tool rest, or a gouge held level, with the flutes at 90 degrees/pointing straight at the wood.

The second is the bevel rubbing cut, which leaves the cleanest surface. I guess because the bevel helps hold down the wood fibers as they are cut. This can be done with both scrapers and gouges. I would never try to rub the bevel of a scraper with it flat on the tool rest, though I have tried it at very slow speed just to see if it works. The danger with that one is if you start to raise the handle, and the bevel comes off the wood. You can have a spectacular catch. Rolled onto its side, at a 45 or higher angle, it leaves a very smooth finish.

The third cut is the 'shear scrape'. This name confuses me. The shear/sheer angle makes for a nice gentle slicing action but you are not rubbing the bevel, and you are not scraping according to my definition because the cutting edge is not at 90 degrees to the rotation. This cut, whether done with a gouge or scraper leaves a very fine surface, and is equal to about any bevel rubbed surface. The main difference between the 'shear scrape' and the bevel rubbing cut is the bevel rubbing cut leaves a burnished surface. Jimmy Clewes doesn't like a burnished surface, because it is more difficult to sand out. I wish I could think of a better name for it.

robo hippy

Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

#13

to simplify things

John Lucas

Lets call is a cut if it raises a curl or wood, and scrape if it doesn't. I'm saying that because what most of us call shear scrape really has the burr lifting a shaving just like a cabinet scraper does. The burr becomes a cutting tool. Bevel rubbing cuts leave a curl.

Well actually now that I think of it that doesn't necessarily work either. When I cut Bocote it never leaves a curl, just dust. It looks clean like a cut vs scrape but it's more or less dust coming off. Kind of like turning MDF.

Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

#14

Re: to simplify things

robo hippy

Yea, some times you get the shavings, some times the dust/chips. Depends a lot on the wood. On the shear scrapes, with scrapers, they work better with the burr, but can be done without a burr, and I found out when I attempt it with gouges, some times the burr interferes, and it works better with the burr honed off.

robo hippy

Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

#15

Steven Antonucci

all about the bevel guys...

steven antonucci

I had this debate with a very good turner in my local club once. I was cutting on the wing of my gouge and he kept calling it a "shear scrape". I kept telling him that I was using the wing like a skew, and hence cutting. If you've ever gotten a skew off bevel, you know how quickly it tells you.

There are two basic things we can do when we "cut" wood. Either there is bevel support or there is not. It's binary, and things like shear scraping, negative rake, etc. are variations of the NOT variety.

If the bevel is rubbing, it holds the wood down so only the leading edge can be cut. The burnishing it gives is usually bad, because most turners cannot get the same level of burnish on every surface. I can cut all of the elements of a table leg with a skew, but I have to sand them at 150 to get them all to look the same... so I agree with whoever said burnishing=bad.

Scraping moves the bevel away from the wood, eliminating burnishing, but opening the potential for "a catch", when the wood plucks out. No amount of sanding will help here. Think of a scraper as a flat, fluteless gouge with a steep nose angle. If the bevel is rubbing, you are cutting.

After watching the video, I will have to try to cut with a scraper again. I think I picked up a tip or two from the video, so I will give it another go.

Steve

Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

#16

Re:  Face shields suggested with scrapers too.

SergioV

A cabinet scraper leaves the cleanest and most reflective surface on wood, but it must have a perfect edge which is its burr and produces very thins shavings and not dust. Exactly like a turning scraper that when presented at 45 degrees to the wood behaves like a plane used at 45 degrees to minimize tear out. At time definitions are only definition and nothing else.

Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

#17

Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

Philip Duffy

I learned the value of scrapers from Myron Curtis, one of the guru's of our craft. He uses nothing else and turns out the most accurate and elegant architectural turnings. I my view a scraper does a superfine cut, in a few thousands of an inch and that is what a gouge or skew would like to be able to accomplish but can not.

Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

#18

Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

John Lucas

If a gouge or skew cannot do it then they aren't sharp. I have no problem taking off a hairs width with any of my cutting tools, and I guarantee the finish will be cleaner. The other problem with scrapers is it's difficult or impossible to get really clean crisp sharp details such a 2 corners bumping into one another or a very sharp pointed reverse V shape. The details I put in my Christmas ornaments are impossible to get with a scraper.

Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

#19

Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

SergioV

unless you use a three point tool or other scraping tools shaped in the right way.

Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

#20

Re: Scrapers don't cut, they scrape??????

John Lucas

I have a 3 point tool. It scrapes and although it is an easy tool to use for beads the cuts aren't as clean as a cutting tool. I did sharpen it twice trying to improve the cut. I cut beads in maple yesterday with it and had to go back and clean them up with my detail gouge. It was a segmented piece and about 4/5ths of the segments cut clean with the 3 point tool. I cleaned up the rest by making a final cut with the detail gouge.

When cutting beads down the side of a side grain bowl the 3 point tool does a pretty good job. When covering the whole outside of the bowl I only have to go back and touch up a few rings. Bowls with swirly grain don't fair quite as well. The tool works better if you tilt it so it's rubbing the bevel. This makes it into more of a blunt cutting tool instead of a scraping tool. I haven't tried raising a burr on one of the flat surfaces. That might work better but I would have to mark that side so I know it's the one with the burr. I'll try it in the next day or so since I still have another segmented ring with 4 more beads to go.