Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Sanding belt sharpening

Posts

Sanding belt sharpening

#1

Sanding belt sharpening

Craig Daymon

The Sorby sharpening system has looked very appealing to me.

I went to an Allan Lacer demo yesterday. He espoused the benefits of a concave bevel and explained how it let him avoid the grinder by honing. This is lost with a flat grinding surface like the Sorby.

I was thinking that it should not be terribly hard to make a system that used a sanding belt running around an 8" wheel on one end, the other end being the drive wheel. Should be relatively easy to exchange the 8" wheel for one matching the rear wheel and the addition of a platen to convert it to a flat grinding surface. Though the surface would move faster with the flat grind. (This, of course, could be compensated for without much difficulty.)

For those that also have an interest in sanding belt sharpening, what do you think? Downsides? Upsides?

I don't remember who, but I know there is someone in the U.S. revamping their system. Maybe some of this would benefit suggesting?

Thanks in advance,

Craig

P.S. Please no discussion of CBN wheels. A quick search indicates CBN is available on belts, so this could just be a different form. That's really a different, though related, subject.

Re: Sanding belt sharpening

#2

Honing

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I don't seem to have any trouble honing a flat or even convex bevel. A hollow grind on a skew does, however, provide two contact points for the hone to maintain the grind angle.

Re: Sanding belt sharpening

#3

Re: Sanding belt sharpening

John Lucas

I am a concave grind person also and for the same reason as Alan. When I had flat grinds you have to sharpen the whole grind or tilt the hone to create a micro bevel. On skews this micro bevel was easy to create reasonably accurately but on bowl gouges I kept rounding the edge into a more blunt angle. Of course now I'm using very short main bevel on my gouges so there isn't much for the hone to ride on. Consequently I don't hone them I just go back to the grinder. The skew I keep on honing but it's so much easier when you have the concave surface with 2 reference points.

What your describing is really a knife grinder. A belt sander with a big front wheel. They work fantastic but are really expensive. I think I could very easily put a slight convex surface on the platten of my Lee Valley strip sander and achieve very much what your talking about. Might be hard to create an 8" radius but I could easily do one somewhere between 12 and 20" radius.

Re: Sanding belt sharpening

#4

Re: Sanding belt sharpening

Greg Haugen

Craig,

As by my recent post about the Sorby ProEdge, I've thought about the system or a similar one but it came down to why spend $500 on another tool when I have something that does the job just as good, and probably better. The most versatile belt system isn't out yet. It's Stuart Batty's OmniGrinder. From the diagrams it looks like you'll have a multitude of surfaces, from round to flat.

I completely agree with Alan and John. The idea behind the system is good and the "real" world usefulness, I question. I was thinking about it for oval skews mainly. They're not that thick, and to put an adequate bevel on them, it's a little too much for a 8" grinder-something like a Tormek or Sorby is needed. And it has nothing to with the silly old excuse of it being oval and rocking on the rest, it's the length of bevel. But one thought of honing it and the option of the system gets erased. I like the rolled edge skews, it's a great compromise of the old style of rectangular stock and Oval stock skews. Plus, they're ground normally. When push comes to shove wouldn't trade my 8" grinder with Norton 3X wheels for anything. Skews are cherished tools to me. Honing the concave bevel is the best in my opinion.

Could your idea be done, absolutely and I think Stuart is planning on releasing it some time soon.

Re: Sanding belt sharpening

#5

Re: Sanding belt sharpening

Craig Daymon

One correction. There would be no difference in speed switching from a large front wheel to a small front wheel as the drive wheel would remain the same. This is not like where a bicycle changes gears as that is a translation of axle speed. With the larger wheel, the axle of that wheel will turn slower, but the surface speed remains constant.

Re: Sanding belt sharpening

#6

Re: Sanding belt sharpening

Mike Foster

Well I hate to chime in here, but just have to give my 2 cents (where did the cents character go from the keyboard?). I have a modified belt sander with an indexing jig that was designed and built by Jon Siegel. It has a built in buffing wheel that you charge with some rouge. It takes me about 8 seconds (a little longer if I have to reconfigure my jig from freehand sharpening my gouges for a Hannes grind) to sharpen the skew, and remove the wire edge leaving an edge I would venture to guess is just as sharp as what Allen Lacer can get with his diamond hone (and I have one of his hones). I can sharpen faster this way, than I can hone. Because I use a 180 grit belt and just barely touch the skew, I would guess that my skews will last just as long as Allen's. I no longer hone. My belt sander is a 4" sander, and has a platen. Not sure what you get with the Sorby system, but I bet it is a lot more expensive. For me the hollow grind is a myth and a non-issue. Like I said, just my 2 cents. Pics of my setup can be seen on my website if you're interested.

Mike

Re: Sanding belt sharpening

#7

Re: Sanding belt sharpening

Devon Palmer

While I use an 80/120 grit Blue SG wheels for 90% of my sharpening, I've started using a diamond 600 grit 3m trizact belt on my 1"x30" sander for small tools, touching up carving tools, and refreshing the edge on Munro and other hollowing tools - sometimes for putting a convex bevel on a skew (since it's not hollow ground, it doesn't self-feed and its much less "catchy").

Not having a hollow ground bevel on hollowing tools takes out some of the aggressiveness IMHO.

The only downside is the lack of power and the increased heat from the finer grit. The belts are inexpensive (6-7 bucks?) and last a while.

Re: Sanding belt sharpening

#8

Brad Vietje

Re: Sanding belt sharpening

Brad Vietje

Gotta second that!

Honing is only necessary on hollow grinds because we tend to use pretty coarse grits, which leave a pretty jagged edge. When a sand & buff belt system is used, there is very little tool steel removed (less than with most wheels), and "honing" is reduced to using the buffing wheel with Tripoli to remove the bur at the ground edge.

I hone tools that come off my grinder (8" 120 Al-ox wheel), but I don't have to hone tools that are sharpened with the sand/buff system.

So YES -- it is very definitely easier to hone a hollow ground tool.... but it is also necessary for a really sharp edge. Using a well-worn 180- or 220-grit belt for sharpening, and then a second or two on the buffing wheel, you don't need to hone the edge, and the whole process takes about 6 - 8 seconds.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

PS: Craig: what you are describing is the Woodcraft Mark II, which has been out of production for a number of years. As for speed, if you attach a given motor to the shaft of a 10" wheel, the belt speed, in fps, will be much higher than if that same motor was attached to a 3" wheel shaft. RPM's will be the same, but belt speed will not.

Re: Sanding belt sharpening

#9

Re: Sanding belt sharpening

Craig Daymon

With respect to speed, yes, you are correct. But what I described attached the motor to a wheel of a fixed size at the rear. The front wheel was being changed and therefore the fps speed remained the same in both cases.

Truth is, there should not be any reason to change wheels as long as the belt was long enough to provide a reasonable flat area braced by a platen between the 2 wheels. So use the area between the wheels for a flat grind and the 8" contour for a concave bevel.

Re: Sanding belt sharpening

#10

Brad Vietje

Sounds Perfect -- Sign Me Up, I'll Take One!


Re: Sanding belt sharpening

#11

look to the knife making guys for belt sanding

Dick Coers

I even saw a machine that uses glass for the platen on a belt sharpening machine. Unfortunately, those folks aren't much for fixturing.