Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Any Sorby ProEdge Owners out there?

Posts

Any Sorby ProEdge Owners out there?

#1

Any Sorby ProEdge Owners out there?

Greg Haugen

I was curious if there are any WC'ers who own a Sorby ProEdge would give their feedback/opinion on it? I'm a free hand sharpener, don't even own a Vari Grind. The jig usage would be new to me, but with their platform freehand sharpening would still be an option. The feature of the system that really appeals to me is the flat grinding surface, which would be nice for oval skews, etc.

Re: Any Sorby ProEdge Owners out there?

#2

Re: Any Sorby ProEdge Owners out there?

Joe Herrmann

I had a chance to use one for a review for a Woodturning Design review coming up and liked it. It was easy to use, set up and did a great job.

Re: Any Sorby ProEdge Owners out there?

#3

Re: Any Sorby ProEdge Owners out there?

John Lucas

Greg I haven't found any advantage to a flat grind. I'm going to play with it more since I just built the Lee Valley strip sander for this purpose. I used to think that it would make a beefier edge but it really doesn't since you end up honing the edge so you really have the same thickness for the first millimeter or so.

So then I thought a convex edge definitly has a thicker edge. Well it does but I can't tell a bit of difference in edge holding or the strength of the edge. Maybe some scientific studies could tell but I can't by just using the tools.

So the bottom line is, whatever makes sharpening easy and efficient is worth pursuing. Then shape of grind (thickness or concave vs flat) seems to be negligible to me. What seems to be much more crucial is the actual angle of the grind and size of the grit used to get the grind.

Re: Any Sorby ProEdge Owners out there?

#4

Re: Any Sorby ProEdge Owners out there?

Cyril Griesbach

Greg,

A good friend of mine has one and loves it. However I should say that he's a tool junky. I was not that impressed with it...especially for the cost.

Re: Any Sorby ProEdge Owners out there?

#5

Re: Any Sorby ProEdge Owners out there?

robo hippy

I did look at it, and it seems to be a fairly good tool, but to me it didn't look heavy duty enough. I was a concrete construction worker for 30 years, and prefer things to be over built rather than under built. I will wait till Stuart Batty gets his Omni Grinder out to buy some thing like that.

robo hippy

Re: Any Sorby ProEdge Owners out there?

#6

Re: Any Sorby ProEdge Owners out there? *LINK*

Mike Brazeau

Greg - if you have a B&D Workmate and a 3" belt sander, try mounting the belt sander upside down or on angle with the handle between the plates of the workmate with the switch on. I have a switched outlet mounted on my Workmate. I use a 120 belt to put a convex grind on a oval skew (as Eli Avisera promotes) and it works great. Will allow you to at least experiment. When I got back into turning about a dozen years ago, that was my sharpening system until I bought a grinder.


The Joy of Wood

Re: Any Sorby ProEdge Owners out there?

#7

Re: Any Sorby ProEdge Owners out there?

John Lucas

Mike I did the same thing with my belt sander before I got a decent grinder. Unfortunately I didn't think to remove the cloth dust collector bag. Now it has tiny pin holes in it from the sparks.

Re: Any Sorby ProEdge Owners out there?

#8

Yeah.  It's not worth it.  "if it's not broken....


Re: Any Sorby ProEdge Owners out there?

#9

Re: Any Sorby ProEdge Owners out there?

Mark ravensdale

Gregg, I have the sorby pro-edge (had it abt 3 years now) used it for abt 18 month and found no real advantage to it, Infact I didn't like it at all for sharpening my bowl gouges or spindle gouges (they just seem very grabby, I was constantly waiting for them to snatch)

It did work well on scrapers and parting tools though!

Please note that the above findings could just be down to my turning style, but as soon as I went back to wheel sharpening the snatching and grabbiness went away!

I now use a CBN wheel on a bench grinder and wish I had spent my money on these rather than the pro-edge!!!