I still use a bowl gouge. I've tried ring tools, hook tools and a reground drill bit. The only one that is competing with my bowl gouge is the new Hunter Hercules. I'm still too new with it. It doesn't take as large a bite as a freshly sharpened hook tool but then it never needs to be sharpened. My hook tool and ring tool have to be sharpened frequently, they just don't hold an edge that long.
My bowl gouge will take a moderately big bite and holds an edge pretty well. Sharpening it is something I've done a million times so it's pretty easy and quick. If I did a lot of end grain work I might use the hercules more. It's effortless to use and removes wood pretty fast.
Jorge, my approach would be to rip into it with an ordinary bowl gouge, sharp, of course. Then, when I get down to the final finish cuts, I would switch over to a round-nose scraper and clean it up by shear scraping from center to rim.
Actually, if the walls are thin, I would do the shear scraping on the part near the rim before I hollow all the way to the bottom, to avoid vibration, etc. Be sure your scraper has a very fine burr, best produced by a few strokes of a diamond hone.
I'm sure others will suggest the latest and greatest super carbide hollowing tools, but I tend to cling to the basics - and my money. Ordinary tools will do the job.
Of course, if the rim of the bowl turns in, you may not be able to use a bowl gouge for the part under the rim. In this case, my tool of choice would be one of the Kelton hollowers, which I invested in a long time ago. Whatever the material they use for the cutting edge of those tools ... it is amazing. They stay sharp forever, and when you do need to touch up the edge, all you have to do is let the mere shadow of a diamond hone fall on the surface.
The first thing that comes to mind is the Jimmy Clewes DVD/demo on natural edge vases with the shielded hollowing tools, (Pro Forme, Munro, Hamlet's Brothers).
I'd go with either a Bowl gouge to start, and depending on depth switch to a carbide tool. I've been looking and shopping for a similar situation. I like the Hunter #5-good all around tool-especially for finishing. The Hercules looks to be a little short for deep end grain bowls. The Straight 5/8" HollowPro tool (Craft Supplies) with a negative cutter is what I've been leaning towards. With that tool, you'd also have a tip that swivels for undercuts, etc.
No matter what you use, make sure you post the end results. Can't wait to see them.
If you are considering a new tool beyond bowl gouges and scrapers, I suggest you take a close look at (or, if possible, try) a Rolly Munro hollower. It is very efficient, has a short learning curve, and is highly versatile for end-grain bowls, vases, hollow, and other enclosed forms.
I've had mine for at least 7 or 8 years, and it is still one of my go-to tools for deep hollowing, particularly for end grain vases or hollow forms.
I would recommend the Oneway Termite tool. It is easy to sharpen on a router. It removes wood really quickly and leaves a nice finish on the bottom. The sides are not quite as good but ready to sand. I haven't used the tool a great deal but am impressed each time I use it.
Greg You just have to move the tool rest. I've been able to do some pretty deep bowls with the Hercules tool. When I first got it a friend brought over a log and wanted to make a vase. He had no skills at all and I was teaching another student. I gave him the Hercules and a breif lesson on how it cuts and turned him loose. I figured I'd be back shortly to help him but he hollowed that whole thing to about 12" deep, 6" around at the lip, without a single word from me. It was totally end grain.
I haven't used the more exotic tools mentioned in the thread but I have a Oneway Termite and I also think it is great for end-grain work. Does take a bit of getting used to.
I wouldn't use a scraper if the wood is not a hard-wood.
Still trying to make my mind about this, I counted 21 chunks, so it will take a while to do all and time savings is a must.
I tend to do as much as I can with a bowl gauge as several of you suggest, thinking back to the end grain bowls I made, I was using the #6 Hunter tool, a very early one, a whooper, kind of unwieldy that gave me very good results half of the time, or a scare when it self feed into the work, and never figure out why it did that. It has a short shaft.
Before I was using not even a bowl gouge, just a spindle gouge and that works well, but in some woods it just made catches and was limited to shallow depths.
Scrapers I use sparingly, for some reason I tend to get tear out when using them in certain woods. I prefer shear scrape with the bowl gouge.
So I am tempted to try a tool with a long heavy shaft, as much of my work is big, carbide cutters are an attractive feature to me, save a bit on time sharpening. A friend on Spain swears by the Pro Forme (WoodCut) so I just did look at it and it is a hook with a cap to limit the depth of the cut, which I think is a good idea. No mention at all to the metal used or how to sharpen it.
I have seen Jimmy Clews and also I've seen Rolly Munro, both a couple times. His tool is attractive to me now that I make deep vessels, the articulated links make it very adaptable to different shapes, so I was thinking about it. Thanks Rob for the endorsement.
I was not aware of the The Straight 5/8" HollowPro, thanks Greg for suggesting it, looks good! the but I see on using that is the sharpening, again I did not found info, or is it carbide?
So I will start with what I have, thanks john and Doc Green; besides many gouges I also have Kelton hollowers.
Nobody mention what they use to finish the bowls with, I think of end grain bowls as strainers, all the Phloem and Xylem structures are meant to carry liquids, so an end grain bowl will leak if not sealed. So far I just used lacquer sanding sealer.
Hi Jorge! I like the Hunter #5 for end grain bowls as well. It yields a predictable and constant cut and of coarse, no sharpening is a big plus. His large swan neck tool will get under the rim.
I finish most end grain bowls with sanding sealer and Tung Oil.