Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Pie Server

Posts

Pie Server

#1

Pie Server

Royce Meritt

My sister-in-law makes the BEST pie. Her sour cream-raisin pie is to die for.

I am going to make her a pie server. I have the "blade" purchased. Just need to turn the handle. I need suggestions as to what wood to turn the handle from and/or what type of finish to use that will hold up to repeated washing. She doesn't own a dish washer so it will be hand washed and I'm sure she will be careful to not let the handle get overly soaked

Any suggestions? I'd like it to be as durable as possible. Thanks.

Royce

Re: Pie Server

#2

Re: Pie Server

Don Orr

I would be inclined to use one of the decay resistant woods like white oak, black locust, catalpa and seal the joint where the metal meets the wood with silicone caulk. I have also used cherry with a good penetrating oil finish. Really anything is fine if protected with a durable (read curing penetrating oil) finish. Curly maple looks great as a handle. Just keep away from exotic non-domestic woods in my opinion. Remember to post a photo of the finished piece.

Re: Pie Server

#3

Re: Pie Server

Coyne

How about sharing her pie recipe?

Coyne

Re: Pie Server

#4

Re: Pie Server

Royce Meritt

I've never asked for her recipe. I figure mine would never turn out as good as the ones she makes so why take a chance. As long as she keeps making them, I'm happy!

Re: Pie Server

#5

Re: Pie Server

GaryG in MD

Personally, I would probably use a closed-grained wood rather than open-grained.

Seems to me your choice should begin with the color you prefer.

Do you want it to be light or dark or in the middle?

That would be my starting point.

And do you prefer plain, or highly figured?

Cherry and hard maple would be possibilities.

Dogwood is also nice -- although it is often light in color and a bit plain, I have some very nice darker pieces with lots going on.

Beech and hickory would work well.

Just about any burl would be a good choice.

If you don't mind the open grain, oak and walnut are fine, as well as osage orange.

Nothing wrong with "exotics" either. They can be heavier, which is another factor you may want to consider. Turning squares of many non-endangered non-native woods are readily available for quite reasonable prices. Woodcraft just had a good sale on a number of them, including some of the Jim King stash.

Be sure to show us your result, GG

Re: Pie Server

#6

Re: Pie Server

Chuck Engstrom

Teak -- nice color, sort of self-oiling, durable and stable. It's ridiculously expensive now but you need so little for a handle it shouldn't hurt much--you could even go begging at a boat yard for little scrap pieces.

Best -- Chuck

Re: Pie Server

#7

Re: Pie Server

Barry Irby

Two things.....

I agree with all those who suggested dense closed pore woods.

Second, I think you should get the recipe. I had a similar experience. My Aunt made wonderful biscuits. I asked for the recipe and she just laughed. Said there was no such thing. She just made them. She would bring me some from time to time and even bring me the dough and we would bake them at our house. I went to college and moved away and she passed away. To this day I wish I had gotten "lessons" from her and learned to make them myself. I have other family recipes, but I miss that one.

And, I have never even heard of sour cream raisin pie. Sounds delicious. I'd like to have the recipe myself.

Re: Pie Server

#8

Brad Vietje

Sour Cream Rasin Pie ?  Gotta know more!

Brad Vietje

I'm with Barry. I think learning how to make a family treasure is a darned good thing! I have also never even heard of a "sour cream raisin pie", which sounds mighty interesting. Is sour cream and raisin pie is a regional treat? Around here, we have all sorts of recipes using Maple syrup or Maple sugar, which might seem pretty unusual in Alabama or Idaho.

Are you interested in using a native wood that's important to your region? For example, around here, Mesquite means almost nothing -- it just doesn't grow around here, so people only know it as something vaguely related to Barbeque. I might use some really nice curly Sugar Maple, but that might have no relevance in your area. Is there some wood species in your area that might be more important than others?

I hope you show us what you create, and do see if you can score a recipe. You can tell your sis-in-law that hundreds, even thousands of wood turners -- including men -- want to learn how to make it... maybe she could even host a cable TV cooking show... Heck, she's almost a celebrity already!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Pie Server

#9

Re: Sour Cream Rasin Pie ?  Gotta know more!

bos bosworth

Pie lovers here in Idaho are wise to check out the days list of flavors at any cafe. If any of several flavors are listed as sour creame-whatever, save room for a piece, or get a piece to go. Sour creame raisin is most frequent, but marionberry, cherry and lemon are often served that way. I'm pretty picky, however as there are only 2 kinds of pie I'll eat. Hot pie and cold pie!

Re: Pie Server

#10

Re: Pie Server

Terry Quiram

Check out sellers of pen blanks and look at the huge selection of stabilized material.

Re: Pie Server

#11

Re: Sour Cream Rasin Pie ?  Gotta know more!

Don in Central Illinois

My grandpa also said it was a sin to cut a pie on more than four slices.

Re: Pie Server

#12

Re: Pie Server

Brian

Apple or Cherry to go with or in a pie

Brian

Re: Pie Server

#13

Mike Stafford

Re: Sour Cream Raisin Pie- Recipe

Mike Stafford

Sour Cream Raisin Pie (Easy Recipe)

Ingredients

9 inch unbaked pie crust

2 eggs

1 cup sour cream

3/4 cup white sugar

1 teaspoon vanilla extract

1/4 teaspoon salt

1/4 teaspoon ground nutmeg

1 cup raisins (fresh plump raisins are best)

Directions

Preheat oven to 375 degrees.

In a large bowl combine eggs, sour cream, sugar, vanilla, salt and nutmeg. Beat until smooth. Stir in raisins.

Pour filling into pie crust.

Bake on the lower oven rack for 40 minutes or until filling is set. Allow to cool before serving.

Not bad if I do say so myself. I have another recipe with more ingredients and more steps but it is only marginally better.

Re: Pie Server

#14

Gracias!

Jorge

much appreciated Mike.

Re: Pie Server

#15

Steven Antonucci

You can bet I'll try this.


Re: Pie Server

#16

Re: Pie Server

phillip medghalchi

Royce they al have given yo ugood advise as for the wood choice, however, when you are all doen you have to showcase the pie in it for everyine esle to drool over it. :D

Re: Pie Server

#17

Re: Sour Cream Raisin Pie- Recipe

Bob Edwards

This is a great filling but you need a "baked" pie shell not unbaked. Otherwise the crust wont cook with the filling.