Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Nut allergy news

Posts

Nut allergy news

#1

Nut allergy news

John Lucas

I hope this OK. I copied this from a brief community news article published in Woodturner magazine. I know Mike Mahoney's says his oil is refined to remove the nut alergin and I think this article helps answer that question.

Nut Allergies- A finishing Dilemma, or is it?

This is a very important area of allergy-Acute anaphylactic attacks following nut ingestion are very alarming and sometimes fatal. The incidence of peanut allergy is now about one in 60 of the younger population.

The nut allergen is a protien and not all nut oil preparations contain that protein. This was shown in Southampton Hospital where a group of patients very allergic to peanuts were given increasing amounts of arachis-peanut oil-with no ill effect.

This is because the commercial oils are hot pressed thus releasing the oil from the nut but not releasing the protein. These oils are golden and absolutely clear.

Cold pressed oils are completely different-cloudy and often with a significant sediment that contain the allergen and that is why these oils are dangerous to nut allergic people.

The lower the temperature of the pressing the more likely it is to contain the allergen.

If what was being used to finish the bowl was completely clear nut oil there would be little chance of an allergic response even if the oils was drunk. If a cloudy nut oil was used for finishing, the important question is”what amount of oil can “escape” from the wood by contact?

By the time the bowl is dry and polished, I suspect very little allergen is available to be ingested. To my knowledge, an experiment to test this possibility has not been done. General advice on safety might be to only use hot pressed, golden and clear nut oils. Have there been any case reports of allergic people reacting to food from a bowl finished in any nut oil? I would be interested to know if there has been any such case.

Jonathan Brostoff

Re: Nut allergy news

#2

Brad Vietje

Re: Nut allergy news

Brad Vietje

Very interesting, John...and timely, too. I would like to get Mike Mahoney's comments on this; do you know him well enough to ask him to post something here? Ellis?

Since my son has nut allergies, this is pretty important to me, and has really got me thinking about those who could have allergic reactions to a bowl or carved serving spoon finished with various nut oils.

I just finished a Black Walnut bowl a few days ago, and in preparation for an unrelated turning demo, I went looking for a set of accessory jaws for a Oneway Stronghold. I even dug through a few boxes of woodworking stuff I inherited from my dad when he died 9 years ago, since that's where the chuck came from.

Mahoney's Walnut Oil Finish: I came across a bottle of Mahoney's Fine Finishes Utility Finish with about a tablespoon missing and a small air space at the top. I expected the whole container to be either a solid block or gelled beyond use, but it was clear and fluid, with no skin on top (?). So, remembering the discussion about getting this oil to harden from a few weeks back, I decided to use it on the Walnut bowl, and see how it worked. This bottle must be 10 years old at the very least, and more likely about 12 years old.

Results: The oil had either hardened or dried within 24 hours, so I applied more, which hardened sooner. I've now given it about 5 applications, and it still seems to soak it in, but the oil does seem to harden. I wet the surface with a paper towel, allow it to soak in for 10 - 20 minutes, then wipe off any excess with a clean paper towel. About 8 hours later the bowl feels dry, and no longer leaves oily finger prints where handled. I've now applied this finish to a number of other turned items, including a refresher coat on a 10-year old bowl we use every day, which looks great. At least it does seem to harden, so the stuff has a very good shelf life.

Allergic Reactions ?: Since my son is allergic, I could do a little experimenting. We could go park in the lot outside the emergency room and have a little picnic with a salad bowl and tongs finished with Walnut oil, and just see what happens, eh? His wife is a pathologist, so by the time we needed her help, it would be too late! Maybe our oil & vinegar dressing could be made from Walnut oil instead of Olive oil? That might be pushing things a bit!

On a more serious note, I'd really like to hear if anyone, anywhere has experienced allergic reactions to the cured oil in bowls and wooden utensils.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Nut allergy news

#3

Walnut oil finish

Jorge

Walnut oil is the finish 90% of my bowls get ,the other 10% gets lacquer.

I have sold over a thousand and have not have a complaint.

I do not use Mahone's oil, I use toasted walnut oil, from a gourmet store, meant for salads, it dries in a few minutes. The brand is "Saveurs de la Terre" made in France, I get it in a health food store, I've seen it offered also in a place that sells supplies for cooks.

I did use also hazelnut oil which Russ Fairfield recommended, I like it better than the walnut oil, but has not been on the shelves in a long while. The hazelnut oil darkens the wood less than the walnut oil. Neither one of these two congeals or gets rancid. As a test, I saved a container of each with one third left back in 1995, last year, 2011, in a pinch I used them, both in good shape.

Re: Nut allergy news

#4

Re: Instant Walnut Allergy?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Last month my wife was fighting a nasty sinus infection. I was turning a piece of fresh/wet walnut when she poked her head through the door and inquired what I was turning. "Walnut" I said. She then described the onset of an allergic reaction including air-way swelling. I immediately opened the garage and hooked up the exhaust fans to get several air changes through the space and clear any lingering "walnut vapor" plus bagged the walnut piece to be turned when warm weather returns and I can use the garage with the doors open.

She had never exhibited a reaction to walnut before, so it is possible that the reaction (which faded over several hours and a Benedril) was a function of the existing respiratory inflammation.

As walnut is a proven sensitizer, I post this here to see if anyone else has experienced this kind of "flash allergic" reaction and to make you all aware of the scenario.

Re: Nut allergy news

#5

Mike Stafford

Re: Nut allergy news

Mike Stafford

I saw that article.

Having worked in the food industry for a number of years I have some actual experience with nut oils.

If an oil is deodorized and winterized so that it remains clear when refrigerated it should be free of all proteins which are the source of the allergic reaction. Deodorization is a process whereby the oil is subjected to extremely high temperatures under pressure to remove the impurities. Winterization is the process of cooling to remove particles that crystallize during the cooling process by filtration.

When I worked for a major peanut oil manufacturer which shall remain nameless on our major customers for highly refined peanut oil was a drug company that used the oil in breast creams for nursing mothers. There were no proteins left in the oil to cause an allergic reaction.

It is thought by some that the allergic reaction is triggered by exposure to the long chain proteins within certain foods. Peanuts and treenuts are two of the eight major sources of food allergens the others being dairy, fish, shellfish, wheat, eggs and soy.

I don't know of any tests which prove or disprove that edible oils have been sufficiently refined to be free of proteins.

Re: Nut allergy news

#6

Mike Stafford

Re: Instant Walnut Allergy?

Mike Stafford

I think your wife's allergic reaction may be different than the identified tree nut allergen problem I write about in my response that follows. It still may be related to a protein but not one ingested in the manner being discussed. Sometimes I find walnut irritating when it is dry and I am turning it. I alway use dust removal and lots of fresh air when I turn walnut these days.

Wood allergies, of which there are many, seem to affect people very quickly if they are sensitive or as in my case with padauk, the sensitivity was cultivated with repeated exposure.

I don't turn padauk any more.

Re: Nut allergy news

#7

Re: Instant Walnut Allergy?

Greg Haugen

Mark,

I've experienced what I thought was an acute wood reaction. I was attending a demo out of town. The demonstrator was turning an exotic, one that I hadn't turned before. Before the piece was roughed out my eyes and sinus were burning-more than just dust in the air. I tried several things to relieve the symptoms and nothing worked. I had plans afterwards to have dinner with the demonstrator and another friend but had to cancel since the symptoms were getting incredibly worse-the true reason for the cancellation wasn't disclosed. After a few hours, and some medications, I was back to normal.

The wood that was turned I wasn't familiar with and didn't think any of it but it hit hard and fast. I also once turned Black Bean, ONCE. The dust from it was like a chemical weapon. I've had these two reactions from wood that I've never been around prior. I've heard once you're allergic to one wood you can be to others with similar make-ups. Walnut doesn't bother me personally though, turn it a lot. So are these two circumstances acute reactions or are they tied to another "sensitive" wood?

I'm a big advocate for no exotics, walnut, or cedar for demos. You never know who is in the audience and what could happen.

Re: Nut allergy news

#8

Walnut

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The Juglone protean is present in all parts of the walnut tree, roots to leaves to nuts. I know of at least one turner who, after years of exposure by turning walnut, became so sensitized to walnut in any form (including dust) as to be life-threatening. Point here, is that you don't have to eat the stuff. My situation of turning fresh-cut wet walnut, with all the extractives and free/bound water present, may be a somewhat extreme case, but it should still be noted by those who work this domestic wood.

A dust collector and air filter should be present in every woodshop, but it's easy to forget the dust and residue that are deposited on our clothes, only to be carried with us into other areas of homes where they may exacerbate a family member's existing medical condition.

Re: Nut allergy news

#9

Re: Nut allergy news

Greg Haugen

The biggest issue about the subject isn't fact, it's fiction. I do believe quality, hot pressed oils are safe. I do believe Mike's finish and others are safe. Mike's, and others', butts are covered-the finishes are safe. They can sleep at night knowing that. Try to explain that to a parent with a child with nut allergies. Not going to happen. I use Mike's finish on our own bowls (and have had visitor's kids use them with severe nut allergies), but I use Tried and True on bowls that I sell because I can say, "It's a polymerized linseed oil with no thinners or driers." I never once say the word "nut".

Re: Nut allergy news

#10

Padauk

Jorge

me too. Is the only wood I am sensitized to, makes me have trouble breathing, so no more turning it.

Re: Nut allergy news

#11

Old Saw

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

"There are two groups of people in the world sensitive to Cocobolo: Those who are and those who will be."

We had a nice discussion about turning with and without gloves.

Anybody up for Moon suits? :D

Re: Nut allergy news

#12

Re: Nut allergy news

Mike Mahoney

Thanks John for posting Jonathan's article. It does capture the heart of the issue. I have worked with bench chemist and some of the best allergen specialist around the world to understand this subject better. Walnut oil besides being an excellent wood finish is one of the most benign wood finishes we have at our disposal. Think about all the other finishes we use and never think twice about their health consequences. Lacquers, poly's, Varnish's, Shellac. All cause not only immediate health problems if ingested through skin and lungs but are all known carcinogens.

Re: Nut allergy news

#13

Re: Nut allergy news

robo hippy

Well, no one has yet mentioned that pea nuts are legumes, and not nuts. Not sure that it makes a whole lot of difference. I have thousands of bowls out there, and have never had any reports about reactions to the finishes.

robo hippy

Re: Nut allergy news

#14

Mike Stafford

Re: Walnut

Mike Stafford

Juglone is not a protein, it is a toxin and is probably made up of many proteins. Juglone has been detected in the wood, particularly concentrated in the roots but also in the leaves and bark. It serves to reduce competition around the base of the tree as the toxin is not very water soluble.

It also shows up in the plant's pollen and has been known to cause an allergic reaction in sensitive individuals.

For some reason you never hear it discussed but juglone is also produced by butternut which is a cousin of the walnut i.e. same family.

Re: Nut allergy news

#15

Mike Stafford

Re: Nut allergy news

Mike Stafford

Peanuts are category of allergen unto themselves are not included in the tree nut category.

Re: Nut allergy news

#16

Protean - not

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Thanks for the correction.

What then, is the walnut allergen?

Re: Nut allergy news

#17

Mike Stafford

I don't know.....

Mike Stafford

I read some time ago that there were at least two compounds in walnuts to which people were sensitive. I believe these were called lipid transfer proteins and were long chain, i.e. large molecular weight proteins. Lipids are in general fats or waxes. I don't know where I read that and I could be "disremembering" the name.

I believe there is a lot of research into allergens at this time as the number of people exhibiting sensitivity to food products is increasing almost exponentially.

Re: Nut allergy news

#18

Re: Nut allergy news

Bill Jacksonville, NC

People diagnosed with ANAPHAPHYLAXIS should avoid all exposure to allergens containing products or by products (tree & peanut) regardless of processing method.

Tree nut allergies different from peanuts (legumes) some not all children out grow tree nut allergies. While peanut allergies seem to be lifelong. Of course, some tree nut more problems than others for people and then have people allergic to both tree nut and peanuts..

Because heat is generated during, pressing there are temperature standards that have to be observed in some countries or oil is not cold pressed. Oil yield is less using cold pressing higher in hot pressing procedure.

If oil is cloudy, chances are your oil is bad. Oil manufacturers catering to artist, cosmetic, and health food communities often lie about cold pressing. You do lose some oil benefits hot pressing.

Heating walnut oil does allow it to dry faster and tad more shinny depending upon wood applied too. Heated walnut oil imparts yellow hue and darkens wood faster. Like linseed oil, both cold and hot pressed walnut will impart yellow hue. Artist community mixing their own paints pays more attention to this than woodworkers.

Bottom line does not matter whether cold or hot pressed, heat treated or been through polymerization (higher heat) process had better tell folks you used Walnut oil as a finishing material!

Re: Nut allergy news

#19

Mike Stafford

Re: Instant Walnut Allergy?

Mike Stafford

When I send out information to people in my classes I suggest that they can bring their own woods but I ask that they not bring exotics because of how many people react unpredictably to some.

I have a friend who was turning yellowheart/pequia amarello for the first time and he broke out around the lips and nares, basically wherever the mucous membranes were close to the surface. He cannot turn that wood ever again.

I have turned over 350 species of wood and, knock on wood, the only one I am sensitive to is padauk. Walnut dust seems to irritate me more than other woods but it does not affect my breathing as profoundly as padauk.

One precaution, if Jamie Donaldson offers you some strange unidentified wood beware. He sent me a piece that turned out to be from a support post that stood in a horse barn for a hundred years soaking up the fluids from various horse excrements..... :b :D

Re: Nut allergy news

#20

Brad Vietje

Re: Nut allergy news

Brad Vietje

Thanks for weighing in, Mike.

I was pretty impressed that a 10-12 year-old pint of your Utility Finish seems to work as good as new. Have you changed the formulation or process at all, or is this the same stuff you are selling today?

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Nut allergy news

#21

...and on

Ralph Lindberg

I usually modify that a bit... There are two types of woodworkers, those that are sensitive to wood-dust, and those who will be.

BTW, one of the members of the local club has to wear a full-eviro suit to turn, that doesn't stop him though... he just does what he has to do to enjoy his hobby and breath too.

Re: Nut allergy news

#22

Re: Instant Walnut Allergy?

Mike Meredith

I wouldn't call it immediate, but a rapid pulmonary response to walnut, particularly wet walnut dust, can be caused by jugulone. Jugulone can paralyze the celia in the lungs that help clear material from the brunchial tree. If there is a preexisting condition; pollen allergy or upper respiratory infection, jugulone can make breathing difficult. This isn't the same thing as the immediate hypersensitivity reaction or anaphylaxis.

Re: Nut allergy news

#23

Re: Nut allergy news

Mike Meredith

The walnut oil/nut allergy question comes up pretty often. The comments about peanut allergy in other parts of the thread are right on point. About 90% of the people with "nut allergy" are allergic to peanuts which are legumes, not really nuts. Peanut allergy can be severe to the point of being life threatening and should never be minimized. Some people are allergic to both peanuts and tree nuts. Cashews and almonds are the most common tree nut allergies with walnuts contributing about 3%. Several studies have shown that tree nut allergens (those molecules that initiate the allergic response) are all proteins. Allergens are three dimentional structured, that is, they need to be in their native configuration. Heating the oil denatures (unfolds-like the white of an egg going from clear to white on cooking) any left over nut protein. The oil that I use is filtered and heated twice and contains has no detectable protein measurable by the most sensitive methods in my lab. Moreover, because walnut oil is a drying oil and hardens in the wood, release of anything from the oil is very unlikely. Still, I can't promise there is no chance of a reaction.

Re: Nut allergy news

#24

Thanks, Mike

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I figured my wife's reaction had to be, in part, a function of the infection. I'll save my walnut turning for the Summer when I can have the fans blow it all outside.

Re: Nut allergy news

#25

Now Mike, the source of that pallet....

JamieDonaldson

...skid was inknown, and it had such well defined grain, just perfect for endgrain boxes! Being phrugal, I just hated to discard such beauty, but immediately after it first touched the bandsaw blade I didn't even dare to put it in the Buck stove! :D