Start With A Blank Sheet Of Paper
charlie belden
If you were an experienced wood carver,never exposed to a lathe, turning gouges and chisels or existing turning technique - but very familiar with how the direction of the grain dictates how it can be carved without tear out or splitting
and
you were given a cross section of a bowl profile, or spindle profile to carve into the flat face of a board
and
told that the carving tool could be rotated on three axes and move in and out on one axis and the wood would be rotating about a single axis that would be oriented in any location of the piece of wood
and
you knew enough physics to understand the forces involved
and then
asked to come up with a cutting tool, or perhaps two or three cutting tools that would do the job (a real constraint for a wood carver who has a tool roll or two of carving tools - sweeps,veiners, swan necks, etc.)
what would you come up with?
Would it look pretty much like an existing bowl gouge - or something significantly different?
Conversely, were a carver to be given a fingernail ground spindle gouge, what carving cuts could he/she use this tool for and which carvers tools would it substitute for?
Lee Valley / Veritas has a history of studying the function a hand plane, then, starting with a blank sheet of paper and a list of well thought out criteria for what the tool is to do, designs and then makes a tool to do the specified job - with ergonomics as a key design criteria. They aren't constrained by It Has To Look Like This (because that's what the existing Tried and True tool Has ALWAYS Looked)
What might they come up with for the basic turning tools we use?
What would YOU change?
Here are some things I'd like to see
1. A more triangular handle for better leverage
and
that would keep the tool from rolling around when
placed on a flat surface
2. A reference mark on the handle to give you a visual
clue as to how the cutting edge is oriented when you
can't see it
3. rectangular cross section tools - like a flat skew - have
the corners rounded/ "eased" slightly to be easier on
my hands - and tool rest.



