Had a little shop get together today with a buddy from WGW... he owns a VB36 lathe and I had some time on it. While I have never turned on a quieter or more powerful lathe, the hour or so I spent with it cured me of wanting one.
Everything on that lathe weighs 300 pounds and requires 2 hands to move. Nothing moves with ease, and usually it requires two levers or cranks to make a small change. I think it was probably built by someone who only turned 400# logs all of the time, as it would be exhausting to use for "regular" stuff.
Never turned on one but there is a lady who is a mainstay on WoW who turns on one all the time. She has never mentioned any of the problems you describe but perhaps she is used to them.
The VB 36 and the Serious lathe are both lightweights compared to this piece of iron brought home by a turner on another forum. Something like a 30" swing and 6 feet between centers.
I had a chance to turn on a Serious lathe a couple of years back and really enjoyed the experience. It was a top notch piece of iron and easy to manipulate the different parts.
I don't have a photo but my late friend Joe Looper had a metal lathe he converted to wood. It had a 54" swing and could have had 8 feet between centers but he never put the tailstock on it.
I have turned on most of the commercially available big lathes, and they all have their pros and cons, but I wonder how many "big lathe owners" secretly wish they had something smaller and more convenient for days when they didn't want to risk getting a hernia.
We turned a large, but not massive, bowl in wet beech that probably weighed 40-50 pounds when we put it on the lathe. It would have fit on my Nova, and probably taken 1/3 the time it took on the VB. I suppose that we all get into familiarity with our own equipment, but the VB is really an odd bird. If I use the Oneway at Peters Valley, it usually adds 20% to the time I'd need because I cannot use the handwheel to stop the lathe, and the banjo locks are so tight I can't move them without two hands. The Powermatic is as close to my Nova as I have ever seen in terms of layout and efficiency.
If I ever go back, I'll bring a big piece of wood so I can truly appreciate it for what it is. I think my test was like asking a fish to climb a tree...
Steve One of my good friends bought the 24" ONeway with all the gadgetry, outboard bed, etc. He puts his jet mini lathe on the bed of the Oneway to turn his fish bobbers.
Steve, if you are seriously considering a new lathe, with big-time capacity and extreme ease of use, get some time on a Stubby. You will find it similar to your Nova (one-hand lock and release of the banjo, one-hand removal of the tailstock) but more stable and...confident than the Nova.
I agree with Steve. When I've demoed on a Stubby it was very natural. I turned for years on a Nova 3000 and now my Powermatic. It handled very similar.
I went from a Nova 3000 to a Stubby 750 and found it to be a very smooth transition. I did not miss changing belts. It is a very steady sturdy machine.
I am totally satisfied with my American Beauty, and this lathe should be considered as one of the elite, "last lathe" group of excellent, top-end machines.
...what happened to Joe's Loop-de-Loop lathe after he died? They must have had to disassemble it to remove it from that small room at the Craft Center, so where is it now?
I'm past the Disney days....now it is college tuition for one semester or an American Beauty. Have another kid starting college in the Fall. I won't see my last lathe for 10 more years. Luckily the PM is only 3 yrs old so I hope it lasts that long. Now that I think about this....I will be more diligent in unplugging it when done. Problem is I never want to be done....I just have long pauses between Sunday night and Friday night...