Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Sharpening System

Posts

Sharpening System

#1

Sharpening System

Kelly M. Robison

HI All, Thinking about buying the "Work Sharp" 300 sharpening system to touch up my turning tools. Does anybody have any thoughts about this tool and have used it. Possibly something out there that is better or different. Feed-back please. I do have a slow speed grinder that I use a lot but I was thinking that this system might give me a better edge. Thank you,

Kelly in Port Orchard, WA

Re: Sharpening System

#2

Re: Sharpening System

John Lucas

Kelly It depends a lot on what grit wheel your are using now. I have 100 grit wheels and I get an edge good enough to sand with 220 if I do my job correctly. I'm now trying out several sanding systems with much higher grits to see if there is an advantage to that. If there is I'm thinking it will be pretty slight and hard to justify any serious money to get there. However I'm still in the early stages of testing.

I am testing a sanding system that I put together using a 1" strip sander from Lee Valley. My first tests were on a 120 grit belt and were just fine but not much better if any than my 100 grit white wheel.

The CBN wheel I'm testing is 180 grit and it seems to produce a noticeably better edge but the finish on the turning is probably only slightly better if at all from my previous tools. It does seem to cut easier which of course has to be better for the wood. I'll know more in a few weeks when I've really had time to turn. I've been gone a lot lately and haven't been in the shop.

Re: Sharpening System

#3

Re: Sharpening System

Sevilla

I use a 7inch Baldor with the dedicated Tormek tool rest for the rough grounging; my tool rest is on blocks I built but I believe now Tormek now seels an inexpensive block. For the final grounding I use a Tormek T7. Actually, once I've shaped the tool with the Baldor I use only the Tormek and it takes 20 seconds to sharpening the tool. I do not usually hone the HSS tools. In this way the alignement between the Baldor and the Tormek is perfect and the sharpness is super in my opinion.

Re: Sharpening System

#4

I don't see any reason for a sharpening.......

JamieDonaldson

...machine other than a good low speed grinder with a 180 CBN wheel and a diamond hand hone for touch-ups. The Work Sharp is more of a toy than a real tool for sharpening turning tools.

Re: Sharpening System

#5

Re: I don't see any reason for a sharpening.......

Greg Haugen

Everyone is going to have the "answer" as far as to what THEY like. The worksharp system is designed more towards the flat, single bevel, chisels for cabinetry or carving-and ultimately doesn't have a grinder in it already. As Jamie said, compared to what we use for turning tools, it's a toy.

A quality grinder with good wheels would handle the majority of sharpening, a simple fine grit diamond for honing would complete it. The skew is one tool that is sharpness sensitive. Some use a tormek or Sorby's Pro Edge system, but a quality dressing on the grinder and a touch-up with a diamond hone will do considerably the same thing. Yes, Steven A. and other love their tormeks, and they are nice systems and do have their place. The WorkSharp system, in my opinion, isn't in the same conversation.

Re: Sharpening System

#6

Re: Sharpening System

robo hippy

You don't need one for turning tools, but then, one can never have too many toys. I would consider the Work Sharp to be better suited to really fine edges like chisels and bench planes, but not as well suited for turning tools, except maybe for the Skew chisel. You can put really fine grit abrasives on it so your steel will shine brighter than the top of my bald head.

The debate goes on from 'to hone or not to hone' to 60 grit for my gouges because a more serrated edge cuts better.

robo hippy

Re: Sharpening System

#7

Re: Sharpening System

Terry Scott

Kelly all I know is that I cannot sharpen without some form of jig

Ive been in the trade for 35 years both joinery ,carpentry and boat building

So my saying "there are those that can sharpen and those that cannot I come into the cannot category " wish I could free hand sharpen it would be handy when Iam demonstrating

My sharpening journey has been an expensive one

Brought a tormek with all the rig to slow for me

Wolvine

sorby,

oneway ,

Heli grind

Ive pretty much tried (and brought them all )

Iam finally with a Wood cut true grind and a cbn yes my preference that many other will all have differnt conclusions.

The important thing is each time you come to the grinder you can set the same position and angle each time

Honing, I dont even go there as I seem to round off the edge

Cheers

Re: Sharpening System

#8

Re: Sharpening System

Mark ravensdale

Yep that's right Robo, these kind of questions seem to pop up virtually every week or so, personally I'am of the opinion that if it works for you then use it, I tried the sorby pro-edge for a long time and gave up on it in the end (and I'am a big fan of sorby equipment) it just didn't work good for me, but yet there are no doubt many turners out there that love it, I ended up going back to my bench grinder, but then I tried the new (to woodturners) CBN wheels and what a revalation, when I first got into woodturning I used the Tormek to sharpen my turning tools (which it did a good job of) but the wheels would wear down so quickly, it was costing too much cash/money, if I remember right the wheels cost abt £92 (UK pounds Stirling) at that time and seemed to last no time at all, for now the CBN wheels seem to offer what seems like the best combination of efficiency value for money and results, and more and more woodturners seem to be making the jump/switch to them (I seem to remember hearing you singing there praises!)

But like I said at the beginning of this post, if it works for you then use it!!!

Re: Sharpening System

#9

Steven Antonucci

Defending the Tormek

steven antonucci

I think that the thing that most people overlook about the Tormek is that it has a finer wheel than anything that was available when it was first introduced, so it simply produces a BETTER edge. A good edge is consistent and cannot be made by a grinder. A grinder may make something sharp, but because the edge is "serrated", it fractures easily in cutting and does not last.

Secondly, the Tormek is a slow speed, water cooled wheel- which means that you NEVER blue your tools. Blued steel also will not hold an edge. A "slow speed" grinder runs at 25X the speed of a Tormek, and removes 4X the material every time I use it. Tormeks save tool steel for cutting.

Lastly, Tormek jig everything. I'm not saying that some people cannot freehand grind, but MOST people cannot freehand grind. The only thing I freehand grind is the heels off of my gouges. Jigs are not explicitly Tormek inventions, but Tormek did really drive the jig market.

If you want sharp tools, follow the formula:

Slow and water cooled

Jig

Fine wheel

A CBN wheel costs as much as a Tormek wheel, maybe even more. I've worn down 2 Tormek wheels sharpening A LOT of tools. They seem to last about 5 years before they get too small to be useful, but EVERY tool I have ever bought is still in my shop. I've never retired a single gouge.

Something to consider.

Steve

Defender of the Tormek :D

Re: Sharpening System

#10

Re: Defending the Tormek

John Lucas

Replacement Tormek wheels are about $180 to $200, the same as the CBN. They of course change shape over the years and have to be trued before being used for some operations. The CBN does not change size and never need truing.

I'm still playing with my older Sheppac and new Tormek so the jury is out on the advantages. I do love it for sharpening carving tools although that might change since I now have the strip sander with belts up to 800 grit. Same is true with my skews.

I do hand sharpen several tools and simply can't do it accurately with the water wheel grinders. I rely on seeing the sparks come over the edge to know when enough is enough. With the wet wheel I simply have to just keep going until I can feel the burr. By then I've removed more metal than I need and everytime I take it off the wheel to feel for the burr I might change the angle when putting it back down.

I do love the leather stropping wheels on the Tormek and I'm still building the carving tool stropping jig for the outside.

I'm not saying the Tormek is bad, it's just really expensive when the CBN wheel gets you almost the same edge.

Re: Sharpening System

#11

Steven Antonucci

I'd never use the Tormek on carving tools!

steven antonucci

Way too much material gets removed for carving tool sharpening. All of my tools are only hand sharpened on a glass plate with automotive body finishing wet dry paper (1200-2000grit) and then stropped with Flexcut Gold.

I gave up on using the Tormek because I spent more time fixing the "grinding" it did than I saved doing it by hand. Turning tools are almost never as sharp as carving tools, but most turners would benefit from learning how to sharpen like a carver.

Steve

Re: Sharpening System

#12

Re: Defending the Tormek

mjonesrdg

Several years ago, a few elitists on a few forums were deriding Jet for producing a "knock-off" Tormek. Being a poor old retiree, doing the best I could with what I had, I bought a "Wet Jet" knock-off of the Tormek and quickly adapted my Wolverine jigs to it. The 2" wide stone surface provided some advantages that I hadn't anticipated, and the 10" diameter makes a shallower concave grind that I have come to appreciate as well.

There is a printed gauge on the side of the case which shows the diminishing diameter of the wheel. With constant use, and more than five years in action, the gauge still shows 9-7/8"" of diameter left in the life of the wheel. Is it slow? Oh, yeah! It takes nearly 30 seconds to put a fresh edge on a 1/2" bowl gouge, but that's because I prefer to use the fine side of the dressing stone. This provides a 120 grit "serration" which I can see with a jewelers loupe.

That some turners seem to be in a constant search for another (better?) sharpening system may be the best testimony to the good fortune I have found with the purchase of my chintzy old wet Jet. I have a grinder that lives under a bench, that comes out every now and again for some special shaping project, but for sharpening, I expect my satisfaction with a wet 10" wheel will go on until I can't find my way to the shop.

Mike Jones in Redding, CA.

Re: Sharpening System

#13

Re: Defending the Tormek

robo hippy

Okay, now we need a CBN wheel for the Tormek, and a robo rest adaptation for it as well.

I did try free hand sharpening on the Tormek, and because I had a few years of experience on my grinder and platform, it wasn't a problem. I didn't notice any improvement in the cutting edge.

robo hippy

Re: Sharpening System

#14

Steven Antonucci

I already sent that e-mail to Dave.

steven antonucci

Tormek, CBN... no word yet on whether or not it will be possible. His first thought was "really expensive", but AFAIK - one does not exist today.

The Tormek black wheel is $205...

Steve