Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Oneway 1640 or Robust Liberty

Posts

Oneway 1640 or Robust Liberty

#1

Oneway 1640 or Robust Liberty

sevilla

Hello everybody, I have now a Jet 1642 2 HP which runs very smooth and has a very good point to point alignement (perfect on the orizontal axis and 1/32 off on the vertical). This is impotant to me since I often use a chuck also on the tailstock. There are a few poblem though I ecountered with this lathe that are pushing me to change it and buy another one as soon as I found a buyer for the jet.

Firts, when I work on the back of bowls or other pieces, which I often do, I tend to accidentally tuch the electric controls and change the speed or turn off the lathe. A couple o time I even put it in reverse. The controls have no protection and are in the way of my movements.

Furthermore, the banjo is not the strongest, and under certain condition it tends to get loose.

I do not know if there is a solution to these problems but my inclination is to buy a new lathe. Since sixteen incees if good for me, I'm coonsidering the Oneway 1640 or the Robust Liberty. The sweet sixteen seems a little complicated for my taste.

The Liberty seems rather light at about 320 lbs as a bench lathe and 380 with the legs, version that I'm considering.

Any experience with these two lathes and recommendations or inputs?

Thank you very much.

Re: Oneway 1640 or Robust Liberty

#2

Re: Oneway 1640 or Robust Liberty

John Lucas

I have demoed frequently on the Jet and have never had the trouble your having. You must be leaning on the headstock or something.

Re: Oneway 1640 or Robust Liberty

#3

Re: Oneway 1640 or Robust Liberty

Starry Chan

I have been using the Jet 1642 for a year. I have not encountered the problems you described regarding accidentally changing the spindle speed or direction. The alignment is perfect vertically and horizontally. When I turn, my body and hands are always in front of the headstock so there is no way I could have accidentally changed the speed or direction.

BTW, if I had to it over again, I would have to go for 20" swing instead of a 16". Trying to turn a 16" bowl on a 16" lathe is very difficult because the blank has to cut perfectly.

Starry

Re: Oneway 1640 or Robust Liberty

#4

Bill Blasic

Re: Oneway 1640 or Robust Liberty

Bill Blasic

Sevilla,

The only way I can visualize what you are doing is that for what ever reason you are doing something on the bottom side of the bowl while it is in your chuck. If the headstock is getting in your way you are turning right handed. Two choices: learn to turn left handed or once you are going to chuck the bowl make sure it is done on that side so you do not have to mess with the bottom.

Bill

Re: Oneway 1640 or Robust Liberty

#5

Re: Oneway 1640 or Robust Liberty

Greg Haugen

Sevilla,

As other have mentioned, turn left-handed when up against the headstock will help you a lot. It's a great skill, to be able to turn left or right handed, to have in your arsenal. When it comes to the banjo, I completely agree! The Jet 1642 Banjo IS the weakest point of that lathe. Now, keep in mind it is a lathe designed around spindle turning, but my feeling is if it has a 16" swing it should be able to turn a 15" bowl without distress and that simply doesn't happen. The lies with the banjo being the banjo from the 14" lathe, and possibly the old 12" model with the Reeves drive (I haven't seen only lately to check). That's why it's so short (length wise) compared to the other 16" lathes' banjos. With a 15" bowl blank, the banjo is pulled back to the point where it is only resting on one of the bed ways. With the lack of support, it becomes a trampoline.

For the best bang for your buck, work on turning left and right handed, and buy a new banjo. Oneway and Robust both sell their 16" lathe banjos. Oneway's is around $300 and Robust's is around $400. Much cheaper than buying a new lathe.

However, if you're in the market for a new machine, either Oneway or Robust would make a wonderful lathe. I've turned on both and tend to lean towards the Robust more. They're also made about an hour and a half from me.

Re: Oneway 1640 or Robust Liberty

#6

Re: Oneway 1640 or Robust Liberty

Sevilla

There are many cuts that can be done with body close to the bottom of the eace besides the bottom of a bowl. For example if you want to define the foot of a goblet which is bell shaped one must get very close to head of the lathe otherwise the handle of the tool gets in the way. by the way, I use very short handles to minimize this.

In any case I thank you but would ask again if anybody has experience with theese two lathes: Oneway 1640 and Robust Liberty.

Thanks again.

Re: Oneway 1640 or Robust Liberty

#7

Joe Bradshaw

Re: Oneway 1640 or Robust Liberty

Joe Bradshaw

Sevilla I have the Liberty and like it very much. It is a well designed lathe. I also have the tailstock swing away. I also have the Oneway 2436 and the Oneway 1224. You can't go wrong with either one. I am surprised that you are not being egged on to buy a new lathe. I thought that our fellow turners had a responsibility to help us spend our money on new toys. That being said, you should learn to turn with either hand. It makes life easier. Good luck with your decision.

Re: Oneway 1640 or Robust Liberty

#8

Lyle Jamieson

Made in USA

Lyle Jamieson

Both are upgrades, if I have a choice Id pick Robust. Id consider a 20 inch swing while you are at it. As your skills improve you will wish you had the extra swing down the road. Not that you need it for a 20 inch bowl but you might want to do some natural edge or square edge bowls or multi-axis work someday. The PM 35-20 is an option worth looking at. Spend a little more and get the American Beauty, you are worth it.

Re: Oneway 1640 or Robust Liberty

#9

Re: Oneway 1640 or Robust Liberty

robo hippy

No question that both are fine lathes. My preference would be the Liberty, which I do have. Main reasons are sliding headstock, and made in the USA. The liberty has a vector drive motor, and while I don't really know what that is, I believe that it can sense when the motor needs more torque. I was surprised by how powerful it actually is. Weight wise, it isn't as heavy as my Beauty, but ballast can be added. I have never turned on the 16 inch Oneway. I have demoed on the 12 x 36 (I think) Oneway, and was surprised at how little power it seemed to have, but after turning on a PM and my Beauty, that could be me and not the lathe.

robo hippy

Re: Oneway 1640 or Robust Liberty

#10

Re: Oneway 1640 or Robust Liberty

Sevilla

Thank you all. I usually work short wood but at times do long spindles. I agreee that a 20 inch lathe would be good but my little shop I made myself is on concrete posts and therefore the floor is only wood, no concrete. This makes me a little reluctant to go 24 or even 20. Furthermore the floor is 3 feets flom the ground and bringing inside a heavy weight is possible (did it with a 20 inch bandsaw and a saw stop) but it would be better if avoidable.

So, I'am asking to the liberty owners, do you have it on the Robust legs or on a self made bench? At 320 lbs is it solid ans smooth running and how is the precision point to point which, as I mentioned previously is important for my turning. In the Jet I got a reasonable good alignement after struggling with leveling the lathe.

Thank you again.

Re: Oneway 1640 or Robust Liberty

#11

Re: Oneway 1640 or Robust Liberty

robo hippy

Well, first, I have mine on the factory legs. I don't really think it would do well as a bench mount, in part because the body is square tubing, and the tube sits up on edge rather on a flat side. You could call Brent and ask him, and he may be able to figure out a way to do it for you. If weight is a problem for your floor, with 3 feet of clearance, it wouldn't be too much of a problem getting in underneath, and shoring it up with another frame and some more pier pads. That would make it a lot more stable, and probably a good idea for any heavy machine. Of course, it makes a difference if your floor joists are 2 x 6 or engineered laminated I beams too. For any spindles, the weight will do great. For bowls up to 16 inch diameter, it will do fine. If you do an outboard turning of a 25 inch diameter bowl blank, it will spin it, but you might get floor bounce, and have to turn at lower speeds. You can get away with more if it is on concrete rather than wood floor.

robo hippy

Re: Oneway 1640 or Robust Liberty

#12

Re: Oneway 1640 or Robust Liberty

robo hippy

Sergio,

Well, I went out to my shop, and discovered as you said in the e-mail that the square tube on the Liberty is different than the one on the Beauty. I never looked underneath. It could bench mount. The headstock and tailstock line up is excellent, like all other parts of the lathe.

robo hippy

Re: Oneway 1640 or Robust Liberty

#13

Re: Oneway 1640 or Robust Liberty

Bill Gasper

Sevilla, I have had a Oneway 1640 for 8 years and would recommend it without hesitation. The 1640 runs very smooth and has handled everything I've thrown at it. I added on the outboard bed extension which opened up the turning capacity to 24", which I have used at maximum swing numerous times. This accessory can also be used to extend the bed for longer spindle work. One thing I like about this lathe is that even though I consider it a "heavy weight", the castings (banjo, tailstock, etc) are lighter and easier to move around than a large machine. Good luck with your choice.

Bill