Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Pen Making Help

Posts

Pen Making Help

#1

Pen Making Help

Tom

I continue to have problems with pen blanks "spinning" on the mandrel. After mounting the blanks on the mandrel, I tighten the nut as tight as I can-sometimes with pliers. Then I mount it in the headstock and bring up the tail stock. I have been told not to put too much pressure on the mandrel as it will tend to bend. Additionally, I have also been told too much pressure may cause the bearings in the headstock to wear faster. When I start to turn the blanks invariably they will "spin". I then stop, tighten the nut on the mandrel, tighten the tail stock, etc. Depending on the wood, I may need to do this several times.

Anyone out there have a solution to this dilemna? Thanks, Tom

Re: Pen Making Help

#2

Re: Pen Making Help

Bernie Weishapl

Not sure Tom but I know sharp tools are a must with a light touch. I know if I get heavy handed or fail to sharpen my tools when I start turning the blanks will spin. I just tighten my knurled nut by hand after the tailstock is brought up to the mandrel. When I bring up the tailstock I put just a light amount of pressure on the mandrel. To much will cause it to bow.

Re: Pen Making Help

#3

Re: Pen Making Help *LINK*

Dick Coers

What tool, what material, what speed? Faster speed the better, something over 2500 works best. Some guys turning acrylic round the corners over on the router table or sander before drilling and cutting to length. I prefer the skew from rough to finish. It keeps you from really hogging material, but also gives the best finish with minimal chip out. I've never tightened with a pliers. You might also consider the mandrel saver from PSI. You don't use the nut on the mandrel at all. The mandrel goes through the center of the the mandrel saver, and you put the pressure directly through the bushings and blank. Snugging up the tailstock, snugs up the blanks.


mandrel saver

Re: Pen Making Help

#4

Allan W

Re: Pen Making Help

Allan W

I have had a similar problem in that the blank will stop turning on my HF lathe when I first start to round it. I have found that I really need to use a light touch, like Bernie mentioned until I get it started to round. As soon as I try to get aggressive, the tool will catch and stop the blank.

Re: Pen Making Help

#5

I use this and love it.

GaryG in MD

I can't imagine doing it any other way. ...GG

Re: Pen Making Help

#6

Brad Vietje

Re: Pen Making Help

Brad Vietje

Tom,

As Dick wrote:

What tool, what material, what speed? Faster speed the better, something over 2500 works best.

I agree completely. If you use sharp tools and very light cuts, the blanks should cut fine. Do you need to insert an extra mandrel or a few washers to make sure the entire train is long enough?

If you can, post a photo of each end of the mandrel as you are using it, so people can see what you are doing to get the best help from the gang here at WC.

Good luck, and Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Pen Making Help

#7

Re: Pen Making Help

Tom

Thanks for all the responses. I have been using a round carbide finishing tool and a speed of about 1800 RPM. I'll try a skew and faster speed to see if that helps. I do start with light cuts but maybe the aforementioned will help.

I have used the PS mandrel when working with Wounded Warriors and admit it does give more pressure on the blanks but am told even that one can cause too much pressure on the bearings in the headstock.

Tom

Re: Pen Making Help

#8

Re: Pen Making Help

carl civitella

I turn the blanks round between centers useing your regular dead and live center before i do anything to it. This will help you pick the best line up before drilling and see what it will look like. With it is already round you can be a whole lot less aggressive in reaching your profile. Carl

Re: Pen Making Help

#9

Re: Pen Making Help

Tom

Thanks, Carl. Your method should be better for wood that tends to chip a lot. I'll give your suggestion a try as well! Tom

Re: Pen Making Help

#10

I don't understand this at all...

GaryG in MD

Makes absolutely no sense to me.

Using the PSI pen mandrel saver, I apply only a tiny, tiny amount of pressure. I mean almost none. After snugging it up by moving the tail stock into position, I might turn the tailstock stem handle 1/8 - 1/4 turn, at most. I'm talking about a feather touch. And my pen blanks do not rotate. I use a very broad spindle gouge for most of my pen turning -- like a skew with the edges turned up.

If I'm roughing a bowl blank between centers (which is my standard method), I probably put easily 100 times more pressure on it, and that does not damage my headstock bearings. I've been doing this for ten years on a cheap Jet 1236! There's no way you're going to damage your headstock with the PSI mandrel saver. Putting as much pressure on your mandrel as I do with a bowl blank would literally bend the mandrel into a bow shape.

I think you have to give a lot more details to help us figure out what your real problems is.

Wishing you luck! ...GG

Re: Pen Making Help

#11

Brad Vietje

Re: Pen Making Help

Brad Vietje

Hey Tom,

I hope things are working well for you.

I think there is some confusion about the pressure from the tail center against the end of the mandrel (very light -- just enough to spin and hold it steady), and tightening up the knurled brass ring or nut that bears against the train of blanks and bushings.

Tightening the nut will have no effect on the bearings; that will just tend to pull the shaft of the mandrel out of the Morse taper on most pen mandrels.

The PSI Mandrel Saver pushes the blanks and bushings up against the spindle, so that could cause some bearing wear, but I don't think you will need to push very hard.

If the blanks are stalling, are you using a barrel trimmer to true and square up the ends? If the ends of the blanks are not smooth and square to the shaft of the mandrel, pressing them together may not get enough "traction", and if the ends are crooked, this could push the mandrel to the side ==> bowing the assembly, and could lead to uneven wall thickness, which would be noticeable on thinner pens like the common "slimline" designs.

Hope that helps. We'll be turning pens on Sunday at my local club meeting, and I hope someone brings in a Mandrel Saver so I can try it out.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT