Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

The patient is on life support

Posts

The patient is on life support

#1

Steven Antonucci

The patient is on life support

steven antonucci

Took a looksee when I got back from Raleigh last night at the platter aforementioned. It does not look good, as there is a definitive crack developing.

Will have to see what happens in the long run, but it may end up being an "art piece".

Steve

Re: The patient is on life support

#2

Re: The patient is on life support

???????????????? :\

Re: The patient is on life support

#3

HA!!!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

No soup for you!

[ :D ]

Re: The patient is on life support

#4

Re: The patient is on life support

Galen Vetterick

Now will you send the $20 cause I knew it would crack. :D

Re: The patient is on life support

#5

Re: The patient is on life support

phillip medghalchi

Took a looksee when I got back from Raleigh last night at the platter aforementioned. It does not look good, as there is a definitive crack developing.


where is the platter aforementioned, and who is cracking in the hospital? :D

Re: The patient is on life support

#6

Steven Antonucci

Re: The patient is on life support  *LINK*


reference

Re: The patient is on life support

#7

Re: The patient is on life support

Don in Central Illinois

My teacher taught me, if ot holds soup it's not art.

Re: The patient is on life support

#8

Re: The patient is on life support

Chip in Plano

Can you just cut through the crack, sand the two halves to mate nicely....glue it....and call it a football-shaped platter?

Re: The patient is on life support

#9

Steven Antonucci

Here is a picture

steven antonucci

Last weekend:


This weekend:


I will say that the donut chuck idea worked at keeping it flat, but I think you almost need to turn a ring to keep it from going oval too? It was flat when I took it out, but you can see how much it shrunk across the grain vs. elongating with the grain. I suspect that movement is what tore it almost in half. If it was resrticted in a round recess, I think it would dry OK?

I never expected it to work, so I don't have anything bad to say about the experiment. One less thing to sand...

Steve

Re: The patient is on life support

#10

Allan W

Re: Here is a picture

Allan W

Would a strap clamp work to keep it together? Another possibility might be some large hose clamps around the outside. I noticed that a turner in Alaska used them to hold his segmented pieces together when he was doing glue up.

Re: The patient is on life support

#11

Steven Antonucci

Thought about that.

steven antonucci

I'm OK with losing a piece in the name of science (sort of OK, but also sort of not OK...if you know what I mean?)

I know that it wants to move, and I was interested in trying to see what would happen if I didn't let it move. I think it actually cracked more than it would have if I had just let it move? I may try it again with another piece of wood and restrict it further to validate my theory. Sometimes in life, you just need to go with the flow and realize that you cannot control things and you take what you get...

I have a pile of these, so it is no big surprise... but more a reminder of something I already know.

Steve

Re: The patient is on life support

#12

Son of a Beech!

Don Orr

Tore itself up alright. Nature of the beast.

Re: The patient is on life support

#13

Re: Son of a Beech!

phillip medghalchi

Steven, I had a walnut piece long time ago that everyone said to toss it remember? It opened up badly then what I did I put it back in abed of shavings (coarse) and left it alone for few months. I checked it recently and the crack came to gether very closely, so what you say to do that and leave it alone for few months and see what happens. what you got to lose and in the interim you may learn something too?

Re: The patient is on life support

#14

Steven Antonucci

way ahead of you


Re: The patient is on life support

#15

Re: way ahead of you

phillip medghalchi

I thought I just suggest it. Didn't realize that you were an expert, already.

Re: The patient is on life support

#16

Steven Antonucci

It's not going to work in this case...

steven antonucci

Took it out again to check last night, and the piece is 1" longer than it is wide (14"x15"), which means it's moved 1/2"...which explains the 1/4" cracks!

I may do a DNA soak on the next one before binding it. This one is probably going to the firepit.

Steve