Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Advice on air-filtration system

Posts

Advice on air-filtration system

#1

Advice on air-filtration system

Jerry Lear

I would like your help in deciding what air-filtration system for my shop. The size of my shop is about 15' x 30'

w/8 1/2' ceilings. I have been looking at three models - Jet 1000, Powermatic 1200, and the JDS HP. The Jet is the cheapest on sale at $315.00, the Powermatic and JDS are both about $375. The problem wthe JDS is they are backordered for over two months. I guess I could wait, if that were the best choice, but would really like to have one sooner. I recently began turning & found between the turning & sanding, the amount of dust created is a nusiance.

Any of you w/suggestions or experience w/these Units, your input would be greatly appreciated.

Thank you,

Jerry

Re: Advice on air-filtration system

#2

Re: Advice on air-filtration system

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

No comment on air filtration units - but I am looking forward to the answers, as I too am in the market for one.

I just want to comment that collection of dust at the source is considered a first line strategy. You make no comments on what other systems or components you have, or do not have, so I can only presume. I believe that any efforts and expense to collect sanding dust at the lathe are a much initial better investment. Once that is in place, air filtration is a worthy second step.

I have run 6" flex hose to my lathe, ending with a repositionable 4" metal HVAC flex-duct. In use I can see the sanding dust fly into the duct. This setup has drastically cut down the dust layers in the shop. Shavings (and associated dust I guess) from turning are a complete other matter though!

Henry

Re: Advice on air-filtration system

#3

Re: Advice on air-filtration system

Jerry Lear

Hi Henery, I do have a trend air shield and a dust collector at my lathe I am just want to get the overflow. Jerry

Re: Advice on air-filtration system

#4

Rob Wallace

Re: Advice on air-filtration system

Rob Wallace

Hi Jerry!

You will want to do the comparison of air filtration units based on number of theoretical complete air changes the filter unit makes in your shop. Calculate the approximate air volume of your shop (or the space to be filtered) and divide by the rated number of cubic feet per minute air flow through the filter unit. This value will be the number of air changes per minute. You will want to have a minimum of at least 3-4 air changes per minute (I think?) but you should do some research to confirm what the optimal air overturn rate is. I am currently not at that computer where I have my Powerpoint files for my demos on shop design and installing dust collection systems to give you the recommended number, and the 3-4 air changes is just what I recall (right now!), but that number may be a bit off. Do some searching on the web and the actual recommended volume overturn number per minute should be pretty easy to find.

Regardless, your air filtration (not dust collection) system should be sized based on the volume of air to be filtered, and of course with external and internal high performance filters to capture particles as small as possible (beware - the "under 5 micron" filter rating specified by some manufacturers can be "legal" and truthful at saying the filter captures particles of 4.99 microns or bigger, but may not get any of the truly 'lung-nasty' particles which are much smaller - such as 0.5 microns, which requires a much more efficient filter).

I always recommend purchasing long-term investment equipment such a dust collection system, lathes, other major machinery, lighting, etc. for the shop sized appropriately for the job, and never what is on sale this week. In the long run it may be better and less costly for you to wait a reasonable amount of time until the correctly sized unit is available on sale, or whether your actual needs require you to make the necessary purchase, sale or not. If the current on-sale units fit the filtered air flow rates you need, then pounce on the one with the most efficient filtration ratings, as to particle size captured!

Good luck with setting up your third line of defense against suspended particulates! I think you are already far ahead of most woodturners on this important part of protecting us from ourselves!

Rob Wallace

Re: Advice on air-filtration system

#5

Of course the primary concern........

JamieDonaldson

...is dust extraction/collection at the lathe, so if that need is met then the airborne particulates should be next addressed. I bought the JDS 2000 ceiling unit when I upgraded my shop years ago, and part of my criteria was the low operating noise level as well as air exchange volume. I seldom use it now that most of my woodworking is turning, but it still helps to clear the air when some sanding operation dust escapes the collection points at the lathes. Location of the unit is another flow consideration criteria when mounting the unit in the shop.

Re: Advice on air-filtration system

#6

Re: Advice on air-filtration system

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I have two air cleaners in my 14x30 basement (low bridge!!) shop. One is a JDS 750 and the other is a shop-made rig using a 20" box fan and 24x24 pleated filters. These are more than enough to handle what the 2hp 6" DC doesn't get.

The JDS is hung from the ceiling pointing in one direction, the box fan unit (above the drill press in the photo) points the opposite way so I get some circulation. It's up against the joists but out of the traffic lanes so I don't walk into it, and works off an external timer. The JDS has its own internal timer. I leave them on for about an hour after work stops, and Memsahib has pronounced the shop as "acceptable" with regard to the lack of dust laying around on things. :D

Re: Advice on air-filtration system

#7

Re: Advice on air-filtration system

Dale Bonertz

Jerry,

All three are good units. I happen to have the jet and it works fine. My shop is 10' x 30' x 9'. One piece of advice. These units come with two filters the primary (1st filter) and the secondary (2nd filter). I have found the first filter gets dirty fairly quickly and they are expensive or a pain to clean the reusable type. I have found that buying a cheap filter to tape over the primary filter keeps it much cleaner and for much longer. You can vacuum off that cheap filter several times before you need to replace it. This saves the expensive primary filter from damage and the secondary filter grabs the very fine particles thus longer life out of both of the two filters. Good luck.

Dale

Re: Advice on air-filtration system

#8

Some additions points

Ralph Lindberg

I bought a single stage Jet over-head system (discontinued) that sits above the lathe. I back that up with a Shop Fox HEPA filter, that can be set to run for up to three hours after I turn it now. This allows me to leave it running to finish cleaning the "fines' out of the air.

I would recommend a multi-stage to HEPA filter that can be left running and will turn itself off.

Re: Advice on air-filtration system

#9

Small Note On HEPA

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Such filters seriously cut down on air flow and must be changed more often, all of which translates as "money." More than one HVAC firm with whom I've dealt over the years have stated to stay clear of the "anti-alergen" [$15] filters as they cut down on air flow too much in systems. I use No. 8 filters in my furnaces and shop filters and they do just fine.

Re: Advice on air-filtration system

#10

Very inexpensive alternative *LINK*

Jack Savona

For less than $50 you can put together an alternative system. The WEB WP2020 Eco Furnace Filter Plus, 20-Inch by 20-Inch sells for about $25 on Amazon. It's a washable furnace filter that filters air to a low micron rating. Put this on an inexpensive 20 inch box fan and you have an effective 3-speed air-filtration system. I've been using one for years and just vacuum the filter off with my shop vac, which has a good HEPA filter. I just made another one for use at the lathe. Very effective and very quiet!


Filter System Instructions from 2005