Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Slow Speed Grinders; Necessity or Overrated?

Posts

Slow Speed Grinders; Necessity or Overrated?

#1

Slow Speed Grinders;  Necessity or Overrated?

Greg Haugen

Recently had a student and he question why do so many woodturning catalogs/suppliers have high speed grinders if slow speed grinders are preferred? We talked about how tools used to be carbon steel and bluing the edge was an issue with those tools and high speed grinders. Now, the vast majority of the tools are HSS and bluing them doesn't have much effect on them other than cosmetic, and with practice and a light touch it can be avoided all together. Also, to shorten the learning curve, slow speed grinders don't remove material as fast. However on the flip side, there are more options available for standard grinders compared to slow speed, and the standard grinders are often times more affordable.

So my question to everyone is this; Are slow speed grinders still necessity or are they overrated?

Re: Slow Speed Grinders; Necessity or Overrated?

#2

Re: Slow Speed Grinders;  Necessity or Overrated?

Bill Howatt

Over-rated if you know what you are doing. I have a machinist friend who says that you should try to avoid bluing on HSS but it isn't nearly as sensitive as carbon steel.

IIRC, several years ago on the Oneway site their recommendation was for a high-speed grinder with 8" wheels but I don't think it is there anymore.

Bill

Re: Slow Speed Grinders; Necessity or Overrated?

#3

Re: Slow Speed Grinders;  Necessity or Overrated?

robo hippy

I don't really think they are necessary, but biggest thing would be for people who have never really used a grinder. Less intimidating. Maybe another point about being safer. If your wheel explodes, which has never happened to me, and won't now that I have CBN wheels, there is less chance of injury. I can see having a separate grinder for shaping, but think that actually some of the belt type sander/grinder systems would work better.

robo hippy

Re: Slow Speed Grinders; Necessity or Overrated?

#4

Steven Antonucci

I own a Tormek, so NO!

steven antonucci

Whether you are just beginning or an experienced turner, slower and finer is better for SHARPENING, which is what we are trying to do most of the time. Heat destroys temper even in HSS, albeit not to the same extent as high carbon steel.

Steve

Re: Slow Speed Grinders; Necessity or Overrated?

#5

Re: Slow Speed Grinders;  Necessity or Overrated?

Bob in NE Ohio

I do not want to Hi-Jack you question, but....

I have a Delta Slow Speed Grinder but the wheel seems to have an out of balance situation on the large stone. The wheel has been dressed but when it turns there appears to be a high spot during rotation, as if it is not centered on the motor shaft.

Is there a way to adjust the stone to get it back in balance?

Hope this makes sense.

Thanks for the help

Bob

Re: Slow Speed Grinders; Necessity or Overrated?

#6

Dick Hines

Re: Slow Speed Grinders;  Necessity or Overrated?

Dick Hines

I have been using a high speed, 3250 rpm, grinder since I started turning in 1998. The only tools made of carbide are the ones I made. If I screw them up I can make more. I use a very light touch and use the Wolverine system. I have not any trouble with bluing. One of my bowl gouges I have had since 2008. It will be retired soon though.

Re: Slow Speed Grinders; Necessity or Overrated?

#7

Re: Slow Speed Grinders;  Necessity or Overrated?

waltben

I think they aren't 'required', but also believe they make life easier, especially for a new turner by lessening the chance for mistakes. If you get one on sale, they aren't more expensive than high speed. I got a Chinese made Woodcraft one well over ten years ago and am still using it (along with the original white wheels). It works and when it breaks I'll probably get a high speed one along with some better wheels.

Re: Slow Speed Grinders; Necessity or Overrated?

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: Slow Speed Grinders;  Necessity or Overrated?

Keith Tompkins

HI Greg, I think a high speed grinder gives a better finish if the same wheels are used in either grinder. Once accustomed to a high speed grinder, the low speed model is not necessary.

Re: Slow Speed Grinders; Necessity or Overrated?

#9

Re: Slow Speed Grinders;  Necessity or Overrated?

John Jordan

1800 rpm grinders (and motors) cost more to make-the main reason there aren't more cheap ones. All else being TRULY equal, the slower speed grinder is nicer to use. It takes the same amount of time to sharpen on either, for me maybe ten seconds on a bowl gouge to make one pass around the tool-my motion or movements will not change, just one smooth controlled pass. As Dick pointed out, the faster grinder works just fine.

The most important aspect is a grinder that is smooth and balanced, and that outweighs the speed. And one should not need balancing wheels that cost as much as the grinder-if its out of balance, remove the wheels. If its smooth without wheels, then the wheel(s) are junk. If its out of balance with no wheels I would throw it out.

I use dozens of different grinders every year, and I rarely think about it if it runs smoothly and has a decent wheel. If one is in the market and has the $$$, you would NEVER regret an 1800 rpm Baldor-there's just not anything better IMO, but if budget outweighs that, the Woodcraft grinder is a great bargain, comes with at least one good wheel, and is $5-600 cheaper than a Baldor. I've used many of them and have always found them good.

John

No, the nickels are not glued on. :)


Re: Slow Speed Grinders; Necessity or Overrated?

#10

Re: Slow Speed Grinders;  Necessity or Overrated?

robo hippy

If I was ever going to consider replacing my Baldor grinders, I would go with this:

http://www.cuttermasters.com/portfolio/tradesman-dc/

Or maybe Stuart Batty's Omni Grinder when and if it ever comes out.

robo hippy

Re: Slow Speed Grinders; Necessity or Overrated?

#11

The 8" Woodcraft slow speed grinder....

JamieDonaldson

...is just fine for most turners, but the weakness is often the quality of the original AlO wheels. That grinder set-up can usually be fine tuned to make the wheels run true, but better quality replacement wheels will often be a welcome upgrade.

Re: Slow Speed Grinders; Necessity or Overrated?

#12

Mike Stafford

Re: I own a Tormek, so NO!

Mike Stafford

I do not own a Tormek but I had the opportunity to have some of my tools ground by a Tormek representative while I was in Norway and I was truly amazed at how sharp they were. It took him a long time initially to duplicate the grind I had from the grinder using the Wolverine system but once he did he wrote down the settings on some stickers and applied them to the shaft. For the rest of the cruise it was very easy to duplicate that grind and enjoy the sharp edges.

I have a Tormek on my bucket list but being the cheapskate I am it is unlikely that I will give up my Baldor slow speed grinder for anything.

I have both a slow speed and a high speed grinder and I think it is easier to control the action, particularly for a new student, with a slow speed grinder. I don't know if there is any other advantage.

Re: Slow Speed Grinders; Necessity or Overrated?

#13

What is recommended speed for CBN?


Re: Slow Speed Grinders; Necessity or Overrated?

#14

Re: What is recommended speed for CBN?

robo hippy

CBN wheels work fine on either slow or high speed grinders. I have heard that diamond on a very slow speed grinder, like the one from Cuttermaster will do okay for steel, but speed range needs to be around 300 rpm. My DMT diamond 3 by 8 inch stomes, some 15 plus years old, are hopelessly clogged up, and were that way quite some time ago. So, I would guess that even at the slower speeds, diamond is not the best choice for our turning tools.

robo hippy

Re: Slow Speed Grinders; Necessity or Overrated?

#15

Re: Slow Speed Grinders;  Necessity or Overrated?

Mark ravensdale

When I was in metal work class at high school one day I saw and heard a 10inch grinder that was running at either 2800 or 3500rpm (not sure) explode, it scared the life out of me, and I was standing 20-25 feet away from it when it happened, the noise it made was so loud, and even though it was fully guarded (being used in school it would be of course) a chunk of the wheel still managed to get itself stuck in the ceiling (somehow!), it was like a shrapnel bomb going off, after that I never used a grinder right up till I took up woodturning, and even then I was a little scared of it, I now use CBN wheels and no longer have a problem with it (though I still take as many safety precautions as possible)

As to the question regarding slow speed or high speed grinders, I personally use a slow speed grinder, but to be honest I really don't think it makes that much of a difference if you use a high speed grinder, just use light pressure and don't keep the tool on the wheel too long!

I use CBN wheels now and think they work great, they cut fast, cool and clean, and there's no wheel wear to take into account (stay same size) and no cloud of dust because you don't have to dress them, and the scratch pattern they leave on the tool is really nice (once they have bedded in:-)

Re: Slow Speed Grinders; Necessity or Overrated?

#16

Re: Slow Speed Grinders;  Necessity or Overrated?

phillip medghalchi

For almost half the price of a lathe, when my rich unlce dies maybe. :D

Re: Slow Speed Grinders; Necessity or Overrated?

#17

Re: Slow Speed Grinders;  Necessity or Overrated?

Mark ravensdale

John, how much would a good grinder like that go for, and do you know if they are sold in Europe ???

Re: Slow Speed Grinders; Necessity or Overrated?

#18

Re: Slow Speed Grinders;  Necessity or Overrated?

Mark ravensdale

Robo, wow that cutmaster looks the biz! Very nice machine!!!

Have heard of baldor grinders before but never looked into them much!

Creusen have a good name over here in Europe (what I'am using) there machines can run into many thousands of pounds (UK), what is your opinion of the baldor grinder you have, and have you had It a long time, when I was looking for a grinder when I first started woodturning (abt 9-10 years ago) I was going to buy one of the cheap grinders but my dad advised me to go for a more expensive one, and it was good advice too, I've never had any hint of a problem and it runs as true today as the day I got it, it just takes a little longer to spin up to speed now it has two CBN wheels on it, there's only really one bad point to it, my workshop is tiny and I don't have room enough to have a grinder out all the time, so every time I sharpen my tools I have to lift it onto my pillar drill and it weighs a ton compaired to the cheaper grinders (kills my back sometimes ;-)

Re: Slow Speed Grinders; Necessity or Overrated?

#19

Re: Slow Speed Grinders;  Necessity or Overrated?

john Lucas

Slow speed grinders aren't needed. I love mine and won't go back to high speed but the higher speed certainly won't hurt the modern tools. They do remove steel a lot faster so they take much more care when sharpening. I still do sharpen a lot of home made tools and they are mostly high carbon steel so that's another consideration for me.

Re: Slow Speed Grinders; Necessity or Overrated?

#20

Re: Slow Speed Grinders;  Necessity or Overrated?

robo hippy

Mark,

The Baldor is an industrial grade 3/4 hp grinder. Heavy as in 80 to 90 pounds, and one that I don't think I can wear out, and I am hard on my tools. Cost in the $800 to $900 range. They are made here in the USA, so most likely, because of cost and added shipping, are not available on the other side of the pond. Never heard of the Creuson grinders though, I will have to check them out.

robo hippy