Recently in a thread I mentioned about a wood swap and some of the turners here elaborated the reason for not spreading the diseases of the woods and sending the protected trees and ........................
Here is the Qsn. I have, suppose that I go to my friend in Kerrville, which is about 80 miles away and get some wood form my buddy's ranch. He doesn't know that the tree had disease, or what killed it. Or, I may find a spalted piece of wood. so, I bring it home and put in shop to dry it and elements are working on it. I am not a botanist so, how can I tell if I already spread that disease to my environment and in case of a spalted log how can I tell what's in it for my lungs. I know some of you will tell to wear mask and facial protection, however, beyond this how did I do for the environment. In reality as wood turner we all get excited when we see a potential piece of log and so we grab it and bring it home ,but what are we really doing to our immediate enviroment?
Just a few comments to answer some of your questions:
Here is the Qsn. I have, suppose that I go to my friend in Kerrville, which is about 80 miles away and get some wood form my buddy's ranch. He doesn't know that the tree had disease, or what killed it. Or, I may find a spalted piece of wood. so, I bring it home and put in shop to dry it and elements are working on it. I am not a botanist so, how can I tell if I already spread that disease to my environment
In this example, the tree is dead, and although there is the possibility of spreading insect pests, such as beetles found in/under the bark, there is likely a very small chance of spreading a tree disease (i.e. bacterial, viral, or fungal infections) from dead trees alone (in many cases these are carried by insect pests which help spread the disease). Additionally, unless there are great differences in environment between the locations 80 miles apart, the likelihood is that whatever insects or pathogens are in the Kerrville location, they are probably also found in your location too. The exception to this is if there is a county- or region-specific pest or disease quarantine in effect that prohibits moving materials into or out of quarantined counties. Your county agricultural agent or State Department of Agriculture will have this information readily available, likely on a web site, that can be checked to see if there are active quarantines in effect, and on what materials (agricultural produce, specific trees or shrubs, firewood, etc.). If the tree is dead (of "natural causes"!), the major threats to spreading damaging organisms lie mostly in spreading insect pests (i.e. Asian Long Horned Beetle, Emerald Ash Borer, Gypsy Moth). De-barking the wood and inspecting for "worm" holes and other obvious signs of insect activity in the wood (i.e. presence of frass, uniform grooves chewed into the wood) can signal that the wood may contain undesirable insect pests.
and in case of a spalted log how can I tell what's in it for my lungs. I know some of you will tell to wear mask and facial protection, however, beyond this how did I do for the environment.
The fungi that are responsible for creating spalting in wood are not those that can grow and create infectious disease in humans, particularly through inhalation. There is a misconception that spalted wood has spores within the wood, and that inhaling the "spores" (which are not there!) can allow the spores to germinate and grow in one's lungs - this is simply not true! Spalting fungi are wood decomposers and are not animal pathogens. They do produce spores, but these are formed in 'mushrooms' or 'brackets' found on the outside surface of the wood, not inside the wood itself. Removing the bark along with these external fungus structures (if they are present) drastically reduces the chances of spores being transported, if there is any concern about spores. Regardless of whether the wood is spalted or not, ANY inhalation of wood particles is harmful, so yes, having proper forms of efficient respiratory protection is necessary to avoid any intake of sawdust. In some sensitive individuals who have been previously exposed to fungi (including molds and mildews), they can develop immune reactions (or allergic responses) to coming in contact with fungi in general, so avoidance of fungal organisms is recommended. Spalting fungi are everywhere, so it likely will not cause changes in the presence or absence of wood decomposing fungi in the environment if you move spalted wood from place to place, particularly if the wood has been dried. Just be careful about unnecessarily moving insect pests, and the chances of doing environmental damage is greatly reduced.
In reality as wood turner we all get excited when we see a potential piece of log and so we grab it and bring it home ,but what are we really doing to our immediate enviroment?
The likelihood of doing bad things to the LOCAL environment is small if you harvest wood from within your area for woodturning, and do not move it very far. Many of the current problems devastating forests today have been traced to the moving or shipping of unprocessed wood (i.e. in pallets) out of the region (or country) in which insect pests (including those potentially carrying diseases) are moved by humans to areas where they do not currently occupy. This is particularly important where "exotic", non-native species are concerned, since they can do immense damage in a relatively short period of time.
In short, go get that dead tree, cut it up, remove the bark (leave it where you found the tree, if you can), take the wood home, mount on the lathe and make something special out of it! If you see insects in the wood, be sure they do not get away to live another day!
...treated buggy wood for insects by enclosing it in a plastic bag with moth balls for an extended period of time. Do you consider this an appropriate and effective method to destroy such unwanted critters, as it seems to be effective for my purposes?
I had to do a little snooping through the literature to see how effective "moth balls" are against insects that would normally be found associated with wood. You may already know that there are really just two different chemical compounds that are typically used in moth balls: paradichlorobenzene (=1,4-dichloro-benzene; PDB), and naphthalene. Both are supplied as low melting point solids that readily sublimate to a vapor phase and permeate the air in the container in which they are used. Use of moth balls is best known as a fumigant and insecticide for clothes moths, and has been suggested for use against certain beetle larvae that occasionally infest carpets made of natural materials. Additionally, they are also used as a repellant for rodents, small mammals, and other vermin. These chemicals can have negative health effects on humans from prolonged skin contact and inhalation of vapors; care and obvious cautions should be taken with use of either of these chemicals.
It seems that both PDB and naphthalene are effective vapor phase insecticides (used as a fumigant) that are effective against moths and their larvae (Order Lepidoptera), and this has been well-documented for a long time. The question I had is whether the same compounds would be as effective on other insects, including BEETLES and their larvae. Reports are present in the literature that both PDB and naphthalene are effective on a range of different insects, but I could not confirm that they are 100% effective killers of beetle larvae (grubs) or their adult forms. There was one study which reported that naphthalene-based moth balls were up to ten times more effective in killing the larvae of confused flour beetles (Tribolium confusum) than was PDB, so if you extend that information to apply to controlling other beetles, broadly defined (Order Coleoptera; such as those found in unprocessed wood), it would seem that the more effective fumigant would be naphthalene-based moth balls. Unfortunately, moth balls made from naphthalene are becoming harder to get due to the chemical's relative toxicity to humans and other animals.
You can have a look at the web site of the National Pesticide Information Center (located at Oregon State University) which gives good, easy to understand summaries of many common pesticides, that include cautions about the chemical composition of the pesticides, effects of skin contact/inhalation, typical uses, toxicity, application types, mode of action, and other relevant data. Have a look at the following links:
If there is sufficient penetration of the fumigant chemicals into the wood (...how to test this is a concern??), it would seem that use of moth balls to control larvae and adults of beetles might be possible and effective over a sufficient time period to catch all of the stages of insect development. It certainly would be less of a hassle and potentially much less dangerous to use this method, instead of immersion or spraying of more toxic pesticides. I have heard of using plastic bags, plastic storage tubs, 5 gallon lidded buckets, etc. as long as the container can be sealed well. Obviously, the use of fumigants should be done in areas of good ventilation, outdoors, with precautions taken to not inhale any of the fumigant-laden air from within the containers. The fumigated wood should remain outdoors until all fumigants have outgassed and have left the treated wood. There should be no residual chemicals left in the wood from either PDB or naphthalene after this treatment.
I will have to check with our extension entomologist to ask more detailed questions about using PDB or naphthalene as broad spectrum insecticides, particularly in untreated wood. When I find out more, I'll post a report to Woodcentral in the future.
Rob Wallace
[BTW - My favorite paradichlorobenzene joke is the guy who asks his friend, "Hey, have you ever smelled moth balls?" and the friend replies, "Sure!"; the first guy then asks, "Really....??? Did you pick them up by the wings?" ]
Check on the use of CO2 via dry ice in a sealed container. I've talked to guys who swear by the method of placing the wood in a 6 mil plastic bag along with a pound of dry ice, then sucking most air out with a shop vac and clamping the bag shut. The ice sublimates to a high concentration and elevated pressure of CO2 that penetrates and kills everything but then disperses without a trace when the bag is opened after a week or so.
In homebrewing circles, it has been reported that they have successfully used CO2 (from gas tanks, not dry ice) when killing mild infestations of meal/flour beetles in brewing grains, and it was very effective. Provided you can get the penetration of the CO2 into the wood and keep it at a sufficiently high concentration for a long enough time, this also might be able to get most of the active organisms, such as larval, pupal, and adult stages. I don't know how CO2 or other chemical fumigants would act on insect eggs that had not yet hatched to the early larval stage. Several contact pesticides are effective at all stages including eggs. I'll ask my extension entomologist colleague when I see him next and will report back.
I can't remember [oh well ] the size of the wood being "gassed" but I would tend to doubt the method would work for whole log sections. Boards and roughed turning not more than 2" in thickness would be my guess for any kind of fumigation absent doing something like a vacuum pump to say 20" and a switch to 50psi gas pressure.
Of course, there's always the solar power solution. Sealed black plastic bag in bright sun for 3 days to get the piece up to 180°, but we might be producing turnings in pieces with that method.