Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

What would you do?

Posts

What would you do?

#1

What would you do?

Harry Pye

I have a bit of dilemma and thought I'd bounce it off the collective knowledge of this group. Recently I bought a turned piece at a local auction. Not an important item but it is well made and turned by a person I know and respect. I bought it without examining it closely prompted by knowing the turner and having seen other things he has made. After closer examination, I realized the finish is really poor. It looks as if the finish was applied and never rubbed or buffed. Far from smooth.

So...should I buff it? Or is that a breach of ethics. I could take the position, the item is mine, so I can do anything with it that I want. On the flip side, perhaps the turner had a reason for leaving it that way. But I don't want to ask him since he might consider that to be a good finish and my question would be embarrassing to both of us.

What do you folks think?

Re: What would you do?

#2

Re: What would you do?

Mark Wollschlager

Once you own the piece, it is yours to do with as you wish.

I would amend that slightly by saying that modifying the piece significantly beyond it's original appearance without disclosing that fact would be, IMHO wrong.

Just my .02

Mark

Re: What would you do?

#3

Re: What would you do?

ihmserv

at a recent symposium that I attended I sat in on the instant gallery critique.

one of the critiquers was a gallery owner, he said that the finish is as important as any other part of the turning. and the one he see's that we as turners seem to drop the ball on. not necessarily on purpose, but we have spent so much time already on a piece that we just want to finish it up and move on.

that being said, he picked up a piece he had chosen to critique, a well made piece, that he had also brokered the sale of beween two other participants of the symposium. as he was examining and showing off the piece he noticed a blemish in the finish, he looked at the person buying the piece and said he should give the piece back to the person who turned it and have them fix the finish. if they were not willing to do so, then cancel the purchase.

after listening to this along with, 40 or 50 other people in the room, It made me think that I was at times guilty of rushing the finish to get a piece done.

I try not to do that anymore, and a piece isn't done until the finish is right.

so to answer your question, I would contact the person who turned it and explain your concerns about the finish. most turners want the piece to be right even if we do it in a rush.

just my opinion

IAN

Re: What would you do?

#4

Re: What would you do?

phillip medghalchi

You bought on the account of knowing the turner, so there must have been some reason for that piece go on auction. It may have been one of the peices that he rushed to get it to the auction, so the money would be raised for the cause. You can cherish for waht it is or you can p;olitely ask him if the finish was intentionaly put on that way. I don't think he'd be offended. then I may be wrong.

Re: What would you do?

#5

Don Leydens

Re: What would you do?

Don Leydens

Yup, you own it Harry. Something like that could bother you every time you look at it. Not worth the small amount of repeated aggravation. Fix it yourself and enjoy the piece.

Re: What would you do?

#6

Speaking as a collector, I would not.......

JamieDonaldson

...tamper with the original maker's finish, as that is how the maker presented their work for your consideration.

Re: What would you do?

#7

Re: What would you do?

waltben

While I try not to have finish blems or imperfections on things I sell, I use tung oil or wipe on poly, and almost always tell buyers how to repair the finish if they need to for whatever reason. I want my pieces to be seen and used and that means they may get scratched. While I've refinished old pieces from someone else on occasion, no one's ever come back asking for one of mine to be refinished yet.

Re: What would you do?

#8

this has happened to me...

GaryG in MD

My response was simply to make it the way I wanted it. ...GG

Re: What would you do?

#9

Re: this has happened to me...

Barry L Elder

If you like the piece but not the finish, it is yours to adjust. But it is not the effort of the seller that is in question, but your quick purchase. Both of you should be satisfied.

Re: What would you do?

#10

Steven Antonucci

long term goals

steven antonucci

When I make something, it leaves my shop when it is "done". As a maker, I make to my specifications, not yours or someone elses, and I do not let something leave with a "poor finish" ...but it may be a poor finish in comparison to someone else's standard.

If the goal of owing this piece was to say that you have a piece from woodturner X in you collection, you have that now as it is. If your goal is to have a collaborative piece, you can refinish it because you own it. Personally, under no circumstance would I ever go back to the original maker and request that they make it better or up to your finish standard because that would be insulting.

As an aside, I have seen some people look at highly finished salad bowls and consider them "too nice to use". I stopped finishing mine to that standard because I cannot think of anything worse than making a salad bowl that never gets used. They may have small "sanding problems" in them where it could have taken me another hour to get it right, but the it would be too nice to use...

You bought it as-is. Leave it as-is.

2 cents.

Steve

Re: What would you do?

#11

Re: this has happened to me...

GaryG in MD

In my case, it wasn't a purchase. :) ...GG

Re: What would you do?

#12

Re: What would you do?

Mark ravensdale

Harry, If you know him, I would ask him, you shelled out the cash for it, he may explain that it's a new way of finishing he's trying/developing, or he may say to you, ohh my word that must have slipped through quality control without me noticing and offer to put things right (if it's wrong that is)

Ask him, or you will never find out, and nor will he!!!

Re: What would you do?

#13

Re: What would you do?

Harry Pye

Thanks folks, some good advise. For the present, I'll do nothing. In the meantime I'll try to look at some of this fellows work and compare finishes. If other items have a much better finish, I will try to find a diplomatic way to ask about the finish on my piece. If they are all second rate, I'll probably buff the piece I own.

BTW, I never thought about refinishing the piece.

Thanks again.