Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Something different for me.

Posts

Something different for me.

#1

Something different for me.

Bob Edwards

My turnings are usually rather utilitarian so this is rather a departure for me. Banksia Pod with Pecan finial and foot, as well as the band at the separation point. Also trying a poly catalytic lacquer. Builds nicely and harder than Delft. Comments and critique welcome.

Re: Something different for me.

#2

Re: Something different for me.

Craig Daymon

Looks real good.

How was turning the banskia pod?

Re: Something different for me.

#3

Re: Something different for me.

John Lucas

I really like the shape of the bottom finial. It pulls your eye right up into the piece. Nice job on the Banksia. They can be challenging.

If you move your lights to your photo both forward, or move the piece back of both you won't get that dark line in the middle of the piece.

Re: Something different for me.

#4

Re: Something different for me.

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

Hi Bob,

I like that a lot. I've turned a few of the Banksia pods and really like the look of them, but I have not hollowed one.

Nice piece.

Mike

Home in Apex, NC

Re: Something different for me.

#5

Jim Barbour

Re: Something different for me.

Jim Barbour

Nicely done Bob. I too like the bottom and how it brings the eye up. The only suggestion I might make is to taper the top finial a bit more quickly just above the beads -- it does not quite match the implied taper that the bottom creates and thus looks a bit heavy just as it begins above the two beads.

I really like the way the colors work together - pecan seems a perfect choice and the ring in the pod adds just the right visual; link between the finial and stand.

Again, nice job.

~ jim

Re: Something different for me.

#6

Re: Something different for me.

phillip medghalchi

Well, guess what I may get to hold this up close when he brings it to the local meeting then I can really tell you guys what it looks up close. My friend bob, you out your local club friends with your beautiful piece. Now, you can help me with the Banksia blank I've gotten form Aussie land, of course, I cannot even come close to what you created.

Nice job.

Re: Something different for me.

#7

Don Leydens

Re: Something different for me.

Don Leydens

Bob, Jim has written almost exactly what I was thinking. Overall a gorgeous piece, just that curve on the top finial needs a little more curve. The pecan and banksia goes SO well together. Well done!

Re: Something different for me.

#8

Nice piece, Bob.

GaryG in MD

I like it a lot.

I agree with Jim and Don that the middle cove of the finial could be a little thinner, but, otherwise, I'd say you nailed it.

I like the colors and the texture variations provided by the use of the banksia pod.

I've got a couple laying around, and you have raised my interest level in working with them. I've already roughed off the red fuzz, so the worst part is done. :)

Nice work, Gary

Re: Something different for me.

#9

Re: Something different for me.

Bob Edwards

Thanks for the comments John. And the lighting suggestion understood. I am really having trouble with my photo work. All suggestion appreciated.

Re: Something different for me.

#10

Re: Nice piece, Bob.

Bob Edwards

Criag, Gary; This is my first Banksia turning so I can only offer my limited experience. The core of the pod is reasonably hard but the holes chip out so lots of thin CA was needed. The "Fuzzy" areas are soft and easily crushed and if you use it for the tenon it will tear out. The piece is 13.75" tall with the foot being 5.5" and the finial 4". This is actually the second finial I made for this. The first was too long and heavy. Jim got it right, the taper of the finial should be sharper. Having said that It looks even more pronounced in the photo. I don't know if it's the angle or distortion that makes it look that way. Maybe John Lucas can help me with that as well. Thanks all for your comments.

Re: Something different for me.

#11

Leo Cuellar

Re: Something different for me.

Leo Cuellar

Very pretty, Bob!

Re: Something different for me.

#12

Re: Something different for me.

Mark ravensdale

Bob, that simply stunning!!!

It just works for me (checks all the boxes)

And your choice of banksia nut works great!!!

Those banksia nuts can be really challenging to work with sometimes, but then that's why we turn them I suppose, right !!!

Well done bob, you deserve the praise!!!