Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Taking bets...

Posts

Taking bets...

#1

Steven Antonucci

Taking bets...

steven antonucci

Yesterday, I turned a figured beech platter to about 1/4" from piece of the wood I hauled out of the wood a week ago. It was soaking wet when it started, and I probably spun 1/2 the water out of what was left. Oh, yeah, the tree had taken a lightning strike, so it has a dark mark in the finished platter.

If I just bagged it like all of my other we turned pieces, I could have just thrown it away, as I have no doubt that it would have torn itself in half drying. I started thinking "How can I prevent that much warping?" and the answer came to me from behind the lathe...

I have a large donut chuck that I rarely use. Placing the platter face down in it, the largest ring can cover 1/2" of the edge of the entire platter, making it impossible to move. I wrapped it in brown paper first, and then tightened it down.

So, I am taking bets... who thinks this is going to work?

Steve

Re: Taking bets...

#2

Re: Taking bets...

robo hippy

If it is under compression, as in squeezing down and squeezing in from the sides it will or can work. It will shrink and try to warp, but if it is totally fixed in place it will still shrink, and crack. 1/4 inch thick will be dry in 10 or so days. Compress at night maybe, then relieve it for an hour or so in the morning, compress again, and relieve again in the evening. Probably needs more relief in the first couple of days than in the last few.

robo hippy

Re: Taking bets...

#3

Re: Taking bets...

Galen Vetterick

It's not gong to work so send me the $20 now. :D

Re: Taking bets...

#4

Re: Taking bets...

John Lucas

Steve You didn't say which direction you turned this. If it's side grain piece turned to 1/4" I seldom have problems cracking. It's it's a crotch or you just sliced a chunk off the end then it may crack. I haven't tried to stop wood from moving as it dries so I don't know what's going to happen there.

Re: Taking bets...

#5

Steven Antonucci

picture for reference

steven antonucci


If you look on the lower part of the platter, the black mark is the lightning strike. It runs through the entire length of the trunk up to the first branch (25'?)

The waffle marks on the raised part of the face of the platter confused me when I first saw them. I thought it was chatter, but they are not visible to the naked eye. I have a non slip rubber carpet pad with this pattern on the face of the chuck, and it caused a tanin stain...go figure?

Steve

Re: Taking bets...

#6

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Taking bets...

Lyle Jamieson

I thought the bet was $100.00?? My bet is it will not stay round. Unless...you replace the water with something else. When the bound water leaves the wood it will shrink. Death, taxes and wood will shrink when it dries, all sure bets. It will shrink side grain to side grain and it will not move end grain to end grain. You can not compress the end grain enough to compensate for the side grain shrink. (That might crack it.) Therefore it will not stay round. I would put it in a paper bag to slow the moisture loss and slow things down a bit and watch the character develop from the drying process. Beech has enough elasticity to survive as long as it is a uniform wall thickness. It has a very high shrink rate but it will likely do just fine at that thickness. Double turning a thicker piece would be very iffy. A thicker piece will usually crack.

Re: Taking bets...

#7

Steven Antonucci

The over/under bet is 1/4" ;-)

steven antonucci

I know it won't stay round, but if it stays within 1/4" across the grain without cupping, I'm going to call it a win!

The real test here is can you take a wood that wants to split and make it somewhat behave with low tech clamping? A huge split is a failure, just the same as a huge potato chip shaped platter might be (who knows, it may be a nice potato chip?)

I don't think this will stop all of it... but I am optimistic that it will minimize most of it.

Pictures to follow...win or lose!

S

Re: Taking bets...

#8

Next Time

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Boil that puppy for an hour before you put it in the clamps while still hot. ;)

Re: Taking bets...

#11

Re: picture for reference

Jorge

Steve, the black marks may be metal stains, like there was a nail or bolt somewhere above. Sometimes lime juice will take them away

Re: Taking bets...

#12

Re: Taking bets...

Don Orr

I've turned a fair amount of Beech and it moves like crazy. My bet is that trying to restrain movement will make it crack. I think it was Keith Tompkins that did some experimenting with clamping wet turnings to control their shape but I don't remember his results. Hannes clamps his hats rims to control their shape so the technique has some merit and is worthy of experimentation. I don't have much hope for Beech though. Steamed or boiled maybe. Cool piece of wood though.

Re: Taking bets...

#13

I don't get it...

Craig Daymon

...what does this have to do with where the next Pope will come from? (Oops, sorry, I thought that was the only thing anyone was betting on right now.)