lathe recomendations
paul grover
I AM CONSIDERING PURCHASING A NEW LATHE. I LIKE THE NOVA 16-24 DVR.MY CONCERN IS THE LONGIVETY OF THE ELECTRONICS.THE JET JWL 16-42-EVS IS ALSO A CONSIDERATION.ADVISE WOUDL BE APPPRECIATED.THANK YOU.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
lathe recomendations
paul grover
I AM CONSIDERING PURCHASING A NEW LATHE. I LIKE THE NOVA 16-24 DVR.MY CONCERN IS THE LONGIVETY OF THE ELECTRONICS.THE JET JWL 16-42-EVS IS ALSO A CONSIDERATION.ADVISE WOUDL BE APPPRECIATED.THANK YOU.
Re: lathe recomendations
Josh Bowman
I had a Jet 1642 2hp and loved it. I only traded it to get a larger throw and I thought mustard yellow would match my shops decor better. Seriously, though the Jet is a very nice lathe. I only know a little about the Nova and the electronics kind of scare me.
Re: lathe recomendations
Bernie Weishapl
I looked at both lathes and turned on both before I bought. I settled on the Nova DVR XP because of space considerations. The DVR XP has a smaller foot print. I have had mine now for 6 years and not a bit of problems with the electronics. You can't go wrong with either lathe IMHO.
Re: lathe recomendations
Bill Howatt
I don't have either machine but they both will serve you well.
What follows are my personal opinions not necessarily absolute facts:
When I bought my lathe the DVR was just coming onto the market and I decided I didn't want a machine with a new-fangled proprietary motor built into the headstock. I still don't care for the concept but there are very, very few problems reported on turning forums about DVR's having motor problems and they've been on the market a good number of years now.
The Nova requires you build a suitable stand for it.
The Jet is a heavier machine which is good for larger, out-of-balance pieces.
I like the idea of the sliding headstock compared to a rotating headstock.
Like I said above, either will serve you well unless you really need something in the Robust or Oneway category.
Bill
Re: lathe recomendations
Terry Scott
Id recommend going for a Dvr rather than the 1624 or did you mean the 2024
We have 6 Dvrs in our club some are the original Dvr 3000.Which are over 15 years old
In that time one board needed replacing
The warranties are very good ,like everything else the new replacement boards are getting cheaper.
I wouldn't go for the 2024 for a while as Ive found Teknatool still have a few minor bugs to sort out not with the motor and electronic but the castings .They may already be on top of this.
I run a stubby 1000 but have found that a Dvr will do everything my stubby will do.Ive had a few turn offs with mates that have Dvrs same size wood e.t.c
My advice to anyone looking for a lathe is spend 10% more than you can afford.
Re: lathe recomendations
Steve Kubien
You will love the DVR. It is the most underrated lathe around. Plenty of power and as smooth as you could ask for. The only reason I ended up with a Stubby was because I found a deal on a used one. I am reluctant to part with the DVR though.
Re: lathe recomendations
Pete in Holland, MI
Love my Jet 1642.
If you turn bowls and have 220 available, opt for the 2hp. I did and never have any power problems hogging big bowls.
Build the weight box and filler full of stone too. I put my stone in several large bags. Makes it easier if I need to remove the stone at a future date.
Pete
Re: lathe recomendations
Alan Trout
I have a nova DVR XP, a Robust American Beauty, and Woodfast. They are all good lathes. Of the two you mentioned I would get a DVR. I teach from time to time on a jet and I much prefer the DVR. In my opinion it has a better bajo, more power and mine is 5 years old without any issues. If you have any extra cash don't forget the Robust Sweet 16. In a 16" lathe they are hard to beat. I have a friend with one and it is a heck of a lathe, but of course more cash.
Re: lathe recomendations
Jim Barbour
When they first came out I got a DVR 3000. It is still running like a champ (in someone else's shop now). I ran it on 110 for a couple of years and then switched it to 220. Subsequently I sold it to a friend and bought a DVR XP, mostly for the selectable speed control. I have had it since they first came out and am very pleased. I have since added extension ways and am now able to turn spindles up to 40" easily. I have also added the remote on-off switch, which I would recommend.
At one point the motherboard went down on me (on the original DVR 3000). Within two days I had a new board, installed it myself (not hard) and was back to work. According to the guys at Teknatool I had one of a small batch of defective boards so they replaced it for free, next day shipping, even though it was out of warranty. I have subsequently purchased a spare motherboard and a spare board for the speed control (less than $100 combined if I remember correctly) and have them sitting on the shelf in case something goes down again. Thus far (six years or so) I have not needed them at all. Think of it as having a spare drive belt for a belt driven machine.
There is one bit of maintenance you need to undertake on the DVR lathes that you don't have on others. Since the speed control is actually a light shining through a spinning disk with holes, and the speed of the flash is converted to spindle speed, you need to occasionally clear the dust from the light. I quick puff of air in the lower back of the headstock will take care of it. I have found that most of the time when someone is having trouble with a DVR, simply blowing out the speed control will fix it right off.
In short, I would not trade for anything else within the price range. A big Robust, however, is another story .... ;-)
Re: lathe recomendations
robo hippy
Well, for turning bowls, the 220 volt and 2 hp is great. The biggest differences between the two are the sliding headstock, and the speed control. I do prefer the sliding headstock. I have only turned on the DVR at demos for our local club. I am surprised by the number of people who have pivoting headtsocks and sliding headstocks and don't use them. For me, it is just so much easier to move the headstock so you can stand up straight in front of the bowl, and keep your tools in close to your body for all the cuts. With the pivoting headstock, the standard banjo does not work well for them because it extends out too far from the lathe, and you need an after market tool rest with support all the way to the ground. Also, with the pivoting headstock, you can only use the McNaughton for coring if the headstock is pivoted.
After years on a PM, and now my Robust, I prefer that type of twist the knob for speed changes to the painfully slow ramp up/down that the DVR has. Yes, it does have pre set speeds, but just used to the other method, which is far more efficient for any quick speed change.
I will say that the DVR does have great torque. More than I would expect.
robo hippy
Re: lathe recomendations
paul grover
THANKS GUYS FOR YOUR IMPUT.I APPRECIATE IT .I TOOK A TRIP TO THE WOODCRAFT STORE IN CHAROLETT NC.THEY HAVE BOTH THE NOVA AND THE JET ON THE FLOOR.I WENT WITH THE JET.THANKS AGAIN.