Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

close up of square bowl

Posts

close up of square bowl

#1

close up of square bowl

Joe Herrmann

Rob asked for a close up photo of the end grain on the square bowl I pegged as mesquite. T his is the best I could get--verdict??

Re: close up of square bowl

#2

Re: close up of square bowl

Joe Herrmann

The color is pretty true here too...

Re: close up of square bowl

#3

Mike Stafford

Re: close up of square bowl

Mike Stafford

Okay, Joe, now it looks like mesquite. The color on my monitor for the first images you posted were quite red.

Love the square bowl but adore my rectangular bowl.

Re: close up of square bowl

#4

Re: close up of square bowl

john Veerkamp

I've turned some mesquite that is quite red. Got it from Unique Mesquite( Harold Jambers). It came from the Rio Grande Valley I think. Was from a large tree burl.

Re: close up of square bowl

#5

Steven Antonucci

An easy way to tell Mesquite (I think it is)

steven antonucci

Is that you can turn it to finish from completely wet, and it doesn't move. It's one of the most stable woods on the planet. Last piece I turned to finish 1" thick, not a single crack on it, might have moved .005 across 10".

Steve

Re: close up of square bowl

#6

Re: close up of square bowl

Joe Herrmann

I checked with the person who gave me the blank. He said he bought it in TX and it was indeed labeled as mesquite.

Re: close up of square bowl

#7

Rob Wallace

Re: close up of square bowl

Rob Wallace

Hi Joe:

It is looking better for an ID of mesquite based on some of the end grain characters.

You can have a look at: http://www.wood-database.com/wp-content/uploads/honey-mesquite-endgrain-zoom.jpg and see some of the cell structure of 'honey' mesquite (Prosopis glandulosa; a species native to Texas), particularly in characters of the parenchyma of the latewood.

Without seeing a piece of wood in front of me to confirm otherwise, it does look like mesquite given what I have seen in the image. It's not easy to see into the vessels but I'd bet there were no tyloses in them; the cell sizes and position of earlywood pores also suggest mesquite.

ID'ing wood over the internet is a challenge, but it is interesting to force yourself to think about the critical characters that are used to identify the wood. One of my demos (perhaps that some saw at the AAW symposium in St Paul in 2011) emphasizes the point that most wood "identifications" are really wood 'recognitions', and are not true identifications that systematically analyze critical cellular characters to make the determination. Doing this exercise via the internet forces you to look more carefully and not decide on a name based on the 'gestalt' of a generic mental image of what teh wood is "supposed to" look like.

Thanks for posting the close-up!

Rob

Rob Wallace

Re: close up of square bowl

#8

Re: An easy way to tell Mesquite (I think it is)

Steve Kniffen

An even easier way to tell is do what I did ... cut down a mesquite tree.

Re: close up of square bowl

#9

Rob Wallace

Probably only if you already know it's mesquite

Rob Wallace

That works when you already know it's mesquite and you can trust it to behave and not move when it dries, particularly where turning and leaving it it thick while wet is an option. Most of the time you are presented with DRY wood (and often pretty terrible scraps/offcuts at that) to do an identification, or as a finished piece for which someone wants an ID done. Very few people will let me take a razor blade to the end grain of their finished bowl to get a clean slice to study the cell characters. I'm not sure one could do a very good job at identifying wood based on shrinkage and distortion-upon-drying characteristics, since so many woods behave similarly in that regard.

Rob

Re: close up of square bowl

#10

Re: close up of square bowl

phillip medghalchi

can you tell whst this one is?

I try to take pictures of what the mesquite looks like for you guys tomorrow and show you some of the things I made.

Re: close up of square bowl

#11

Rob Wallace

Re: close up of square bowl

Rob Wallace

Hi Phillip!

From what limited information is shown, I can only guess at something like maple given the small ray fleck, but there are several other woods that this could be. there is no view of end grain, on the piece, so even determining the basic information about ring porosity vs. diffuse porosity, etc. is difficult or impossible to do. A close up view of a freshly made cross section cut of the end grain is MUCH more informative. If there are a large number of radial rays and the vessel distribution is somewhat diffuse porous, it could be sycamore as well (the figure character of what I call "dark band" is frequently found in sycamore, and it may be present in this piece). Without a macro photo/image of the end grain, from this image I am only relegated to making guesses, but without an end grain close-up, I can not do a systematic check for specific characters to include or exclude possibilities of what this wood might be.

Rob Wallace