Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Woods, Mike Mahoney and a cautionary tale... *LINK*

Posts

Woods, Mike Mahoney and a cautionary tale... *LINK*

#1

Woods, Mike Mahoney and a cautionary tale... *LINK*

Craig Daymon

...of web page design.

I wanted to ask Mike a couple questions about woods. One was whether the "Sycamore" used in his recent Woodturning magazine article, "Dinner Plate", was American Sycamore or the british, Sycamore Maple. (The article gives the botanical name as the maple, but that may have been an editor's decision.) I also wanted to know the botanical name of that fantastic Poplar he uses, which is NOT the same as what Home Depot sells. (If anyone is interested, I'll post his response when I get it.)

While there, I checked out the pieces he currently had for sale. I was particularly interested in dimensions of the pieces. I took a look at his pepper mill, which featured a caption under the picture, "Click on image to view it full sized". When I did, I got a picture MUCH smaller than the picture I clicked on, as in maybe 1" tall.

Since I'm guessing Mike isn't producing miniature turned pepper mills, that's probably not what he intended to show. I was using Firefox when I did this. I get the same result using Chrome. So, just a cautionary statement that when setting up your web page, double check that it shows things the way you want and use more than one browser to check it. (Similar, fractionally larger, results with Opera and Konqueror. I don't use IE.)

-Craig


Mike's tiny pepper mill.

Re: Woods, Mike Mahoney and a cautionary tale... *LINK*

#2

Re: Woods, Mike Mahoney and a cautionary tale...

Joe Herrmann

I believe the "Mormon Poplar" Mike uses is a name he made up--I believe it's actually cottonwood?

Re: Woods, Mike Mahoney and a cautionary tale... *LINK*

#3

Re: Woods, Mike Mahoney and a cautionary tale...

DickL in Tampa

A similarly small pepper mill shows up in Safari on my Mac.

Re: Woods, Mike Mahoney and a cautionary tale... *LINK*

#4

Re: Woods, Mike Mahoney and a cautionary tale...

Don in Central Illinois

Also, on IE?

Re: Woods, Mike Mahoney and a cautionary tale... *LINK*

#5

Re: Woods, Mike Mahoney and a cautionary tale...

Don in Central Illinois

That was supposed tome a statement,not a question.

Re: Woods, Mike Mahoney and a cautionary tale... *LINK*

#6

Re: Woods, Mike Mahoney and a cautionary tale...

John Jordan

The "Mormon Poplar" is cottonwood and a true poplar. The poplar HD sells, that is a widely used furniture wood (yellow poplar, tulip poplar, Liriodendron tulipifera ) is not a true poplar, but a member of the magnolia family.

Its also the state tree of Tennessee. :)

John

Re: Woods, Mike Mahoney and a cautionary tale... *LINK*

#7

Re: Woods, Mike Mahoney and a cautionary tale...

Craig Daymon

I wouldn't be surprised if he made up the name. There is a Spruce cookie jar on the site with a "Mountain Mahogany" finial and I feel pretty confident that is not the common name.

Re: Woods, Mike Mahoney and a cautionary tale... *LINK*

#8

"Mormon" Poplar *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

is actually Lombardy Poplar [Populus Dilotata], is 'relative" of Cottonwood [Populus Deltoides], but without the stink. ;)

You can see the difference(s) at the link, in the 2nd and 3rd section under common names. It got the name Mormon because (allegedly) so much of it was plated in Utah as landscaping and street shade.


Woods

Re: Woods, Mike Mahoney and a cautionary tale... *LINK*

#9

Re: Woods, Mike Mahoney and a cautionary tale...

robo hippy

Most of the 'sycamore' on this side of the Rockies is the London Plane tree. They are closely related, but I don't know the specifics.

The 'Mountain Mahogany' is a common name for a tree that prefers high rocky desert in the western mountains and generally above 5,000 ft. Cereocarpus leadifolia, which is the curl leaf variety, or some thing like that is the name. Called 'mahogany' because of the color. I picked up a bunch some years back that was growing at 8500 feet outside Las Vegas. Heavy enough and hard enough to sink in water. I had a couple of fret boards made for my guitars with it, so maybe 'red ebony' would be a better name for it.

Don't know about the Mormon Poplar. Any of the cotton wood and poplar trees around here tend to smell like vomit, and the smell doesn't seem to go away.

robo hippy

Re: Woods, Mike Mahoney and a cautionary tale... *LINK*

#10

Turned a Piece of Cottonwood . . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

My wife wouldn't allow the clothes I was wearing into the house.

Re: Woods, Mike Mahoney and a cautionary tale... *LINK*

#11

Re: Turned a Piece of Cottonwood . . .

Don in Central Illinois

I turned somecottonwood (central Illinois), not so much a smell but very fuzzy. No matter hoe sharp the tool and how small a cut, still left a lousy surface.

Re: Woods, Mike Mahoney and a cautionary tale... *LINK*

#12

Re: Woods, Mike Mahoney and a cautionary tale...

Craig Daymon

London Plane is the name used by the British for American Sycamore.

I believe Mark Baker covers this in his Woods for Woodturners book.

Re: Woods, Mike Mahoney and a cautionary tale... *LINK*

#13

Re: "Mormon" Poplar, Mtn Mahogany, Eucalytus, et.a

bos bosworth

This discussion illustrates why foresters use scientific names rather than common names when discussing woods. I'm a westerner, and 'yellow pine' to me is ponderosa pine, but if you go into the south east and mention 'yellow pine' they are thinking of one of several southern yellow pines. Each of these species has a specific scientific name that is distinct to the species(variety). Poplar can be aspen (west, north), yellow poplar (east) or cottonwood ( eats-west) among various common names used, while some are of the genus Populus, others not. And in some regions, more than one common name is used for the same species.

Mountain mahogany is mentioned. Generally a shrub found on semi-arid western sites, this species is one of the most valuable browse species for deer and elk in those vicinities. It is a fantastic wood for turning, although most stems will only produce small boxes or vases. Grain patterns, colors and natural voids in the wood can be eye-boggling!

I understand that there are over 800 eucalytis species. In my visit to Oz, I saw a number of 'ash' forests, named blue, gray, etc. My estimation of the naming came from the color of the foliage, but that may not tell the whole story. All these forests were extremely impressive to this forester.

Use scientific names for clear communication.

Re: Woods, Mike Mahoney and a cautionary tale... *LINK*

#14

Re: Woods, Mike Mahoney and a cautionary tale...

robo hippy

I looked it up on Wickapedia, London plane is a hybrid of the American sycamore, and the eastern European sycamore (orientalis or some thing like that).

robo hippy

Re: Woods, Mike Mahoney and a cautionary tale... *LINK*

#15

Rob Wallace

It would be easier using scientific names...

Rob Wallace

I agree Bos.....

.... the problem is that many people have an aversion to Latin/scientific names and would much prefer to use common names. Unfortunately, there is no standardization of wood common (or vernacular) names as there is for common names of birds, for example.

Rob