Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

Posts

Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

#1

Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

Stuart Johnson

I applied Mahony's Walnut Oil to a bowl a good six weeks ago following the instructions on the bottle. Both the bowl and oil were in the house at 70 degrees and the bowl has remained. It is still leaving a ring when set on a paper towel and your hands will be slightly oily after handling it. If it wasn't for the color and smell I would think I used Mineral Oil not Walnut oil.

I've sent a message to Mike asking about the problem but there hasn't been any answer yet. How can I remove the oil so I can use a finish that will dry? If it can't be removed is there a way to top coat it? I brought this up a couple times on the Wednesday chat but nobody else has seemed to have this issue. So far I've tried wiping it down several times a day, setting it in the sun for a few hours and baking it in the oven at 150 degrees for an hour. Can Walnut Oil go bad? FWIW, the wood is Cedar Elm which is actually a type of elm not a cedar.

Re: Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

#2

Re: Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

Jim Sebring

Try denatured alcohol (dna) first. If that doesn't do the job, go to acetone. Be sure to wear latex gloves when handling this stuff.

Re: Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

#3

Re: Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

Fred Holder

I've used walnut oil as a finish for quite a number of years. Originally, I was using the walnut oil from the grocery store, but it didn't dry as fast and Mike Mahony's Walnut Oil finish. The walnut oil does take a few days to dry. I never really timed it. Once dry it seems to buff very well to a nice finish. I finish all of my Chinese Balls by soaking them in Walnut Oil for a bit and then hanging them to dry for 2 or 3 days. I've never tried to remove walnut oil, but since it soaks into the wood I doubt that you could remove it.

Re: Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

#4

Jim Barbour

Re: Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

Jim Barbour

I was at John Hill's over the weekend and he is working with a similar problem. I don't know if it is Mahoney's finish or not, but it is a weeping bowl. He is wiping it down regularly for a week or so and will then put Watco on it. The idea is that the dryers in the Watco will react with the oil and cause it to dry as well. I think he got the solution from Alan Hollar

Re: Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

#5

Re: Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

mjonesrdg

I had a couple of horror stories that I shared here over the years and that I took personally to Mike while he was demoing at the AAW 'Portland" Symposium several years ago. I was having trouble with the oil "curing" and weeping out of the opposite side if the piece. At those particular times, I got a burr under my blanket

about it, and did not hold back my critical and accusatory verbage. (Though I did this in as gentlemanly way as I could muster, to allow for learned rebuff.

Back then, I learned that Mahonies Walnut is, essentiallya non-drying oli. A non-drying VEGETABLE oil is subject to rancidification A bottle of the product sugests exposing the piece to sunlight. My piece soaked through the wall of the piece in the form of ;sweat:when left in the sunlight.

To salvage those two pieces, I coated the outside surfaces with Waterlox. And finish my work. When I told mike what I had done....he simply walkd away and said that I had screwed the pooch, There is a place for it though!

Re: Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

#6

Joe Fleming

Re: In Defense of Mahoney's Walnut Oil

Joe Fleming

I have used Mahoney's Walnut oil for years for all of my users. No, it is not fast drying, but it does dry. It is important to NOT soak the piece during application. Just wipe on and wipe off. Over application will take a very long time to finally dry.

Joe Fleming

Re: Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

#7

Bill Blasic

Re: In Defense of Mahoney's Walnut Oil

Bill Blasic

I agree with Joe, wipe on wipe off. Never had a piece not dry with Mahoney's Walnut Oil.

Re: Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

#8

Re: Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

Dale Bonertz

I have used this method and it worked. (Natural color) Danish oil by watco. It will take a little longer to cure than using it without the walnut oil and it will have that danish oil odor for a couple of weeks but it did work. Good luck.

Re: Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

#9

Re: Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

Bill Jacksonville, NC

If were me would use hot soapy water to wash away walnut oil & wax finish. Yes, acetone would remove finish lot quicker but really need don more PPE than gloves.

Walnut oil can have an iodine value ranging from 138 to 162 depending upon reference less than 140 makes it semi drying oil. Drying oils form a film with exposure to oxygen (polymerization), semi drying oils will not polymerize unless go through heat treatment process. Non-drying oils never polymerize.

I doubt walnut oil venders catering to woodworking community analyze oil before selling. Their products do work better than what comes off grocery store shelves.

Great article on line by Jonathan Binzen, just search “Food-Safe Finishes.”

Re: Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

#10

Same here, no problem with drying


Re: Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

#11

Re: In Defense of Mahoney's Walnut Oil

Stuart Johnson

I'm not bashing Mahoney or his finish just asking where do I go from here. I didn't soak the bowl, it and the finish were at room temperature and still are six weeks later. It sounds like trying to remove it or top coating with something aren't good answers so I either have a worthless bowl or I can let it sit for however long it takes. We are heading into some very hot sunny days that will let it bake outside. At some point it will either cure/dry or I'll loose interest and toss it into the burn pile.

There are too many happy users of the finish for it not to be either the user (me) or a problem with the actual bottle of finish. I have a couple other pieces roughed from the same wood and will try it again being sure to use just a minimum of finish immediately wiped off. If that doesn't work I'll chalk it up to a finish I don't care to use.

Re: Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

#12

Re: Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

Craig Daymon

You didn't say what kind of wood the bowl was turned from. That can make a large difference.

One of my earliest adult woodworking projects were speaker stands made from walnut, hickory and red oak. I finished them with boiled linseed oil. On the closed grain walnut and hickory, everything worked great. The red oak STILL oozes oil. I made these about 15 years ago.

Oil finishes are a really bad choice for open pore woods for this reason. If you are going to use oil, it is probably best to cut it by 50% with thinner on the first coat and use a VERY light, dry coat. Let that cure a few days before applying any more.

I used Mahony's on a recent turning made from alder. I applied it while still on the lathe with a good bit of friction to heat it up a bit. It cured very well and was dry in a couple of days.

I've used it on some pieces where I applied it off the lathe and it cured much more slowly, maybe a couple of weeks. Mostly maple.

Re: Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

#13

Re: Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

Bill Jacksonville, NC

Cedar Elm wood can have straight or interlocking grain or both. Have no idea if Cedar Elm grain considered closed or open grain because never worked with it.

Using pure oils ( linseed, Tung, Walnut) to finish easy while wood still on lathe, apply, wait until oil soaks in, wipe off excess, and turn lathe back on a wipe down with soft cloth (friction finish). Depending upon wood, oil, may want to lightly sand between applications. Sounds great in theroy just not always practical.

Off the lathe sequence:

Apply once a day for a week

Once a week for a month

Once a month for a year

Once a year forever after

Reading this and other forums turners more apt to use products like Watco, Formby’s oil products over pure oil products.

Re: Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

#14

Re: Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

robo hippy

I have used Mike's Oil for years, and now use the Doctor's Woodshop oil (switched because he is from Oregon, not because of any problems with Mike's oil). I have only had oil ring problems with mineral oil which I quit using years ago. If I need to speed things up any, I put the bowls over a 45 watt incandescent light bulb. Never any problems after about a week. I had more problems with the oil/wax mixes than just the oil. Not sure what is going on with your problem. i have heard that if you put on a couple of heavy coats without the under coat totally curing out that you can get bleeding.

robo hippy

Re: Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

#15

Re: Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

Craig Daymon

Sorry about that. I missed the wood type in the original message.

Re: Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

#16

Re: Removing Mahony's Walnut Oil

Bernie Weishapl

Mike told me at a demo that ambient sunlight also helps cure the walnut oil. I have never had a problem with it and I also use Drs. Workshop walnut oil. It cures ok also.