In preparation to make Chinese balls as per Fred Holder, I've built a jig to turn spheres (somewhat similar to the Vermec jig) using an Oland-style tool bit. While it gives a nice round sphere, there is quite a bit of tearout with dry maple. I've also tried a Hunter bit presented in a flat position with the same type of tearout. Is there a better way to present the tool bit so as to reduce tearout? Advice would be welcome and thanks.
Charles, using the Hunter style tool/cutter with the tool flat on the tool rest is not much different than using a scraper. The edge will be sharper than most scrapers but the cut will still be a scraping cut.
To get the smoothest cut with a Hunter tool you must ride the bevel. To do this the "handle" of the tool must be dropped so that the cutter is presented in a bevel riding mode. Doing so will give you a much better cut.
Also the smoothness of the cut will be improved if the speed of the lathe is increased but everyone must turn at speeds which they feel comfortable.
What Mike said although tilting the cutter down 30 degrees like the Hercules does help. It's not very big improvement. Bevel rubbing is the way to go. What I've been thinking about when I build my jig is to be able to rotate the cutter so it is pushed in ideally a bevel rubbing cut. However this is probably impossible because the angle of the cutter (and consequently the shaft) will have to change as you rotate around the ball. That get mechanically very complicated.
I'll be in the shop later today and I'll make a cut with the cutter flat and then with the cutter at the 30 degree forward tilt and see if there is any improvement. Might be challenging since I'll be hand holding the tools and when it's held flat it's not very cooperative.
and have a tool holder that rotates left and then right while making the cuts with a Hunter insert. That may not work, as rotating the tool to reverse cutting direction, with it against the sphere may not work. Production duplicating lathes use a nearly vertical V shaped tool so that the leading edge has a vertical shearing cut. Better yet, buy the lathe in the video! LOL
Since your used my name in your post, I feel that I must comment. I use the Hunter tool to cut with my jigs. I got the best quality cut with a swinging jig if I took the trouble to rotate the Hunter cutter to a 45 degree angle for each cut, i.e., rotate it one way for the swing to the right and the other way with the swing to the left. This is not real practical, because it is hard to rotate the tool and keep the extension the same for both cuts. I had Mike Hunter make a modification to my Vermec Sphere Tool where the tip is slanted down, it cuts pretty well, but not a good as when I could rotate the tool for each direction. I've found the Hunter tools work best when they are tilted to 45 degrees when cutting.