Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Another Demo question (not a gripe!)

Posts

Another Demo question (not a gripe!)

#1

Steven Antonucci

Another Demo question (not a gripe!)

Steven Antonucci

The question was raised by the president of one of the clubs that I belong to, and I think it's a great question (thanks Gil):

"Why are we bringing these demonstrators here?"

Gil asked this question after we brought in a very well-known turner. The turner showed us a very interesting technique, but it was a very fringe/specialized technique... and he wanted to know if anyone had attempted to do anything with it since the last meeting.

Do you know how many hands went up?

Not one. (I eventually put mine up because I had played on a scrap, but not attempted anything serious. Gil put his up too.)

I categorize demos as follows:

1.) The "slightly more entertaining than what is on TV tonight" demo/night out of the house (don't care what the topic is, just glad to be in a social environment)

2.) The "hey, I like learning how things are done, even if I won't do them demo"

(I admit to going to a few of these)

3.) The "Shhh... be quiet! I need to know how to do this so I can do it tomorrow" demo (I personally don't learn this way..)

4.) The "I saw Ellsworth, Jordan, Hosaluk, checklist" demo

(Been to a few of these myself...)

5.) John Lucas' mentioned "I want to get a perspective" demo (I go to a lot of these to see how people demo, not what they demo)

I'm a 1,2,5 demo guy. I'm sure there are other reasons and demo types. Please feel free to share your list and attendee personality.

Steve

Re: Another Demo question (not a gripe!)

#2

It should be the responsibility....

JamieDonaldson

...of the guy selecting demonstrators for the club to choose topics relevant and beneficial to the majority of the group. Of course you can't cater to everyone every time, but knowing the methods, personality, and output of the prospective demonstrator best comes from actual experience of having seen that person in action. This is an added benefit from attending both regional and national symposia, sort of a tryout for later selection of demos at the local club level.

Re: Another Demo question (not a gripe!)

#3

Re: Another Demo question (not a gripe!)

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

I wrote an article on this subject for our club newsletter several years ago. Here is some of what I wrote.

In the world of woodturning, the demonstration seems to be the most popular method of instruction, and for many good reasons. Books and journals have their place, but try writing the directions for tying your shoes and you gain some appreciation for the value of a demonstration. It is difficult to describe, even with well constructed diagrams, the psychomotor skills important to woodturners, yet easy to demonstrate.

A woodturnng demonstration involves perspectives and expectations from three potentailly diverse components: the sponsoring organization, the demonstrator, and the audience.

Why has the sponsoring organization selected this person and this particular program? Does the demonstrator understand what the organization expects? Is this what the demonstrator wishes to do? Are the objectives clear to all concerned?

The audience needs to match the program. If the audience is composed of advanced woodturners/wood artists, the program can go in a different direction than a program for beginners, or for a diverse group of woodturners whose experience and skills range from newbie to expert.

For the usual woodturning club, it may be possible to offer programs which provide something for everyone -- a lot of basic principles woven into the production of a sophisticated product. A case can be made for providing programs that are more inspirational than educational, as long as such programs don’t deteriorate into a “look what I can do that you will never be able to do” exhibition. For some of us insecure people, a fine line may exist between inspiration and total discouragement.

Re: Another Demo question (not a gripe!)

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Another Demo question (not a gripe!)

Keith Tompkins

Good post, Steve. I don't attend all that many demos, but I do a lot of demonstrations myself. So, my question has to be: How will my demo benefit the members who invited me? I'm an artsy type, while many in the audience are not...but, all turning begins with the fundamentals...and you won't believe how many turners have not mastered the basics. So I always include my essential cuts, and show how ANY turning can be done if you know the basics. I always include ideas on design, and how you can apply these ideas to your work...Sure beats years of trial and error. One example, I almost always turn a cube, and people ask WHY? You wouldn't believe how many email I get showing cubes people have turned..some just outstanding how far they've pushed the idea, for example, a cube within a cube, or a open form inside a cube. One thing I would like to see become the norm....an evaluation of the demo a turner gave. The good, the bad, and how the demo could be improved.

Re: Another Demo question (not a gripe!)

#5

Re: It should be the responsibility....

H. Phillip Medghalchi

Demos are good, however, they are not as good as a video that is professionally made by a pro turner. this is my personal opinion. I have to take into considerations that not everyone learns the same way. and, also, not everyone creates and design the same thing same way. I personally learn by watching some one very enclose to see how and why they do it rather than watching them from far and try to guess at what they are doing. You also have to consider the skills of the person behind the camera as how they zoom in or out or what they should be showing on the big screen if you are to project the image on those large flat screens for the attendees to see. In our club the guy who does it also trying to enjoy the demo which sometimes he forgets that other attendees need to watch what's going on, therefore he forgets to zoom in on what the demo-er is trying to concentrate on since his own attention is drawn to certain thing of his interest. when you have the pro es individual video (which hopefully is professionally recorded) then you can stop and restart and rewind to look at over and over again to catch certain techniques. I noticed at our meetings some people come directly from work and fall sleep while the demo goes on or it may not be of tsoemthing that they have interest in. However, you mentioned it can be that we need to go for the socialization aspect of it and for the comradry then it's all different.

This last soummer I went to SWAT and didn't enjoy it very much at all the demos, because soem of the presenter had personla agenda to sell their own product and I even heard it few times that they bickered with another fellow turner over that they didn't knwo what they were talkinng about because of the presenter's product. That turns me off, no matter how good a product or demo they are doing.

Re: Another Demo question (not a gripe!)

#6

Re: Another Demo question (not a gripe!)

H. Phillip Medghalchi

Emett, well put.

Re: Another Demo question (not a gripe!)

#7

Re: Another Demo question (not a gripe!)

Jerry Klug

I am the editor for my club's newsletter. When I took over the job, I didn't expect a lot of submittals from members to fill out the monthly publication. I wasn't wrong. I did ask and finally passed out uncomplicated comment forms to see what the members wanted. Almost none were filled out. When I asked individuals what they wanted for content, the answers were very vague. I pretty much write and publish what I want with requested guidenance from the club president. I consider my efforts to be my way of giving back to the club. I do get positive feed back from members that are respected so I feel I am doing OK.

What has this have to do with demonstrations? The same lack of input is given to the program selection. The person trying to set up the demonstrations has to schedule them a year in advance. When asked for suggestions, very few are offered.The few that are submitted get a lot of weight because there are so few. I am not a pen and little in the way of bowl turning so my suggestions are for multi centered, offset and unique demonstrations. I greatly enjoyed Stephen Hatcher teaching stone inlay. Very thin turning and carved/textured hollow forms as the class with John Jordan were great. Did every attendee enjoy those demo's? Probably not as much as I.

We do utilize local turners and there is an effort to include fundimentals for the newer turners. Our membership runs around 100 and about a quarter consider themselves beginners. Last month we had a demo on bracelets. The turner giving the demo had a lot of questions and discourse with the 80 or so watching so judging by that there was a lot of interest. It will be interesting how many bring a bracelet for the meeting's challenge display.

Re: Another Demo question (not a gripe!)

#8

Re: Another Demo question (not a gripe!)

Steve Mushinski

The club demo needs to be more of a entertaining night out for the people that attend. Most are there to be entertained not learn turning. This doesn't mean you are not teaching idea's and technique's. It just need to be done in a manner which people enjoy.

Most demo's are boring and lose the crowd every early. You should know you have lost the crowd when people start talking or move around to other items of interest at the meeting. Such as the show and tell table, the refreshment table, washrooms, or if you have anyone selling tools or wood.

When someone has a certain technique to make something special it is only of interest to a very select few, more often then not that demo sucked and most tuned out. It has to be a complete package. Some of the worst demo's are people coming in and telling everyone this is the best way to do this or that. Demo's really need the complete package, skill knowledge and a bit of a humorous personalty. Too many people demo with the corporate thinking of a seminar.

I will give the example of Jimmy Clewes, he entertains as much as he teaches which makes his demo's very enjoyable and a learning experience. If he was to do an in-depth slide show demo on design and inspiration he would not be as popular.

Club demos -- Make Shavings and make more shavings and be able to talk well.

Re: Another Demo question (not a gripe!)

#9

Re: Another Demo question (not a gripe!)

John Lucas

Some great responses. I have found exactly what you all are saying. First of all most members don't turn very much. They also don't subscribe to the magazines or visit the forums. consequently they don't know what's out there, don't know what they want to see and in some cases don't care.

They do want to be entertained. I know in one club many are there for a boy's night out and I'm not sure if they ever turn anything. My other club is great, with lots of members turning things and the instant gallery is always great. The inactive club has little or no input on what they want to see, the other club will usually fill out the demo list by member volunteers. I'm not sure how or why either club is the way it is.

What does this have to do with Demos. Exactly what Steve said. You have to be an entertainer. You need to show the basics. I do that even on demos that are kind of exotic. I constantly talk (except during cuts that throw shavings in my mouth). I try to tell them what the tool is doing and why I'm rotating it or how I use my body to guide the cut. I try to be funny which is not easy for me but it helps keep the crowd from falling to sleep.

It's impossible to please everyone and some people just aren't good demonstrators. I thank them for trying. I usually learn something from everyone although it some cases it's I don't want to do it that way. Still at least they got up and tried which is more than most club members do. I find that if your supportive they get better and eventually you end up with a club like our second one where you have lots of members contributing.

Re: Another Demo question (not a gripe!)

#10

Steven Antonucci

Is there any other type of club?

Steven Antonucci

I think I agree with every last word you said, John?

For starters, I am pretty sure at least a third, if not more, of the one club that I belong to, turns once a month. Depending upon how you define "beginner", it is pretty hard to have any skills without practice, and once per month is probably not going to get you there- even if you've been doing it for 10 years.

I think most club members are actually beginners, and there in lies some of the issues. Do we show them an advanced technique when it might be dangerous to a beginner? Are we teaching or are we demonstrating? Most people would think a motorcycle jump over a flaming bus is pretty entertaining, but not too many would consider trying it after seeing it.

I try to keep my demo's entertaining and instructive because I want people to try to do some of the things that I am showing... but safely and the proper precautions. You cannot learn everything you need to know in 90 minutes.

I have also pushed people who were not experts to demo anyway. It's hard because many people feel like they need to be on the front page of the Journal to demo, but that's just not true. You will never be an expert if you do not try and fail, and you will never be a good demonstrator if you do not try and fail.

My first demo was a train wreck. I knew what I was doing, but no one else did. I knew why I was doing it, but I could never understand why someone else couldn't. I would have booed me off the stage. I think the most important thing you can tell someone who has never demoed is that NOBODY came to the demo to watch you fail... we are all rooting for you, and we'll help you along if you stumble.

Steve

Re: Another Demo question (not a gripe!)

#11

Another Great Topic Steve.

Don Orr

I go to demos and I do demos. What do I want from each? Many years ago a friend gave me a great piece of advice-go to as many demos as you can, you will get something from all of them. He was right. I go in with the expectation of learning something. I am not an expert by any means even though I have been turning for several years. I am competent and do decent work but certainly don't know everything. I tend towards basic work done as well as I can. I am not the artsy type-yet. I try to see as many different types of turners and artists as I can and take notes and photos. I am fortunate to have seen many of the "big" names and many very skilled turners over the years. Hopefully some day I will have the time and motivation to use some of this information in my own work. Not everyone is as interested in all things turning as I am and many just want to see a show and hang out witht he guys/gals. Different strokes for different folks.

As John described, I also belong to a few clubs, all of which are different in there skill levels and member involvement. Human nature I guess. One of them brings in outside demonstrators a couple of times a year and puts on a very good regional symposium. The members are also fairly generous with their skills and knowledge. Not everyone is comfortable "perfoming" in front of a group. I get that. I personally don't have a problem with that. In fact just the opposite. My last demo was basic bowl turning and I could have easily done 3+ hours on it and still had room for more. I had to cram it into 1.5 hours and really scramble but got very good feedback from the group despite the frantic pace. I try to put forth as much as I can about what I am doing and why. I try to direct the camera person to get the view I think will get my point across. Does everyone care-no. But if I feel I am doing the best job I can then hopefully someone will get something out of it. One of the other clubs has only a few members that actually turn anything on their own. Their meetings are mostly a hang out and chat affair. Nice people though. The club of which I am currenly president is somewhere in between. Few members, most of whom turn at home, still a social event, but with some sort of educational demo program. Too small to bring in any outside talent.

What does all this have to do with Steve's question? You can't please everyone all the time, human nature is what it is, get what you can out of a demo you are watching, and do the best you can when giving a demo. I've never seen Steve demo but would like to. I do know some of his work and have met and hung out with him a little. I'm sure his programs are well thought out, prepared and executed. If the audience does not appreciate that it is their loss. If they don't appreciate an outside demonstrator it is also their loss. Folks is funny critters.

Re: Another Demo question (not a gripe!)

#12

Learning demos should be done by club mentors,

Dick Coers

entertainment demos should be from hired guns. My opinion of course, but a thousand dollars can be spent by the club to bring in someone who will teach you how to make a pepper mill, box, or everyday knicknack. Watching a professional hired gun sand, or make a jamb chuck is certainly not the best use of sparse club funds.

Re: Another Demo question (not a gripe!)

#13

Re: Learning demos should be done by club mentors,

John Lucas

Dick I agree. We had a famous demonstrator come in. He's known for his finishes. I do agree that the only way to get that finish is to sand to the "N"th degree but he sanded for literally half the demo. I don't sand during a demo. I will occasionally just to show how to get rid of the spiral cross grain lines but I keep it very short. It does leave me with a less than perfect finished piece if they want to auction off the demo pieces. Many venues won't allow sanding due to the dust problem.